cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Discover It Secured Worth It or Wait for Something Better?

tag
Supermama
Established Member

Discover It Secured Worth It or Wait for Something Better?

Hello All-  

 

I'm mostly a lurker and am nearing the end of my rebuild after a CH 7 in 2017.   My scores as of today are pretty decent:

EQ: 710, TU 743, EX: 713.  My utilization percentages are currently showing at 43%, 24% and 45% respectively, although my actual revolving debt is closer to 1% across the board as I just paid off nearly all my credit card debt and my Toyota car loan.  Basically, I don't owe anyone anything ATM which feels great! I have 2, 3 and 3 inquiries showing.

 

I received a preapproval for a Discover It (secured).  Is this something you would advise accepting or does anyone think I have a decent chance at acceptance with Citi or Wells Fargo or basically anything else that is not secured?  Should I wait a bit longer until my payments have all been reported to the CBs and then re-evaluate?

 

As far as majors, I currently have an Amex Platinum (No PSL), an Amex Marriot Bonvoy Bevy (just received this one with a soft pull) (CL 1700).  I have a Comenity Bread Amex (CL 3900), an Apple card (CL 1250) and a GM Marcus (CL  2300). I have a few other crap/rebuilder cards with low limits that I will likely close.

 

What do y'all think about my odds on being approved for another unsecured major?

 

Thanks!

 

Seeking advice on how to  

Message 1 of 9
8 REPLIES 8
Yoshi1981
Regular Contributor

Re: Discover It Secured Worth It or Wait for Something Better?


@Supermama wrote:

Hello All-  

 

I'm mostly a lurker and am nearing the end of my rebuild after a CH 7 in 2017.   My scores as of today are pretty decent:

EQ: 710, TU 743, EX: 713.  My utilization percentages are currently showing at 43%, 24% and 45% respectively, although my actual revolving debt is closer to 1% across the board as I just paid off nearly all my credit card debt and my Toyota car loan.  Basically, I don't owe anyone anything ATM which feels great! I have 2, 3 and 3 inquiries showing.

 

I received a preapproval for a Discover It (secured).  Is this something you would advise accepting or does anyone think I have a decent chance at acceptance with Citi or Wells Fargo or basically anything else that is not secured?  Should I wait a bit longer until my payments have all been reported to the CBs and then re-evaluate?

 

As far as majors, I currently have an Amex Platinum (No PSL), an Amex Marriot Bonvoy Bevy (just received this one with a soft pull) (CL 1700).  I have a Comenity Bread Amex (CL 3900), an Apple card (CL 1250) and a GM Marcus (CL  2300). I have a few other crap/rebuilder cards with low limits that I will likely close.

 

What do y'all think about my odds on being approved for another unsecured major?

 

Thanks!

 

Seeking advice on how to  


@Supermama Congrats on your rebuild progress so far! Smiley Happy YMMV of course but I think you have a good chance of being approved for an unsecured card. I would start checking pre-approvals once your reports update and see if anything pops up. Maybe target specific cards that would work best with your spending habits. You could always check now but the APR and/or limit would likely be better with lowered util. 

 

Was approved for USB Connect with 28% util/716 TU, pre-approved for three Citi cards and Amazon Prime (although APR is always highest in my case, but won't be carrying balances on future cards). Good luck!


FICO 8: EQ 712 | EX 711 | TU 706
Discover $10k (AU) | Wayfair $4.5k | AAA Daily Advantage $4.2k | Citizens Bank Cash Back+ | USB Altitude Connect $2k | Target $1k
Message 2 of 9
Creditwiser
Valued Contributor

Re: Discover It Secured Worth It or Wait for Something Better?

I would take advantage of Preapprovals and also limit your INQ's and AAOA. Your scores are decent and you need to set yourself up for the next two years when your BK falls off.  Resist the apps and use what you have. Seek SP CLI's.

NFCU Visa 43k | NFCU Platinum 37k | Cap1 QS 14.5K | Cap1 QS 12.5K | Barclay MC 25k | Delta Gold Amex 40K | Discover IT 22K | CFNA FS 3600 | CareCredit 20k| PayPal Credit 10k |
Message 3 of 9
Yoshi1981
Regular Contributor

Re: Discover It Secured Worth It or Wait for Something Better?


@Creditwiser wrote:

I would take advantage of Preapprovals and also limit your INQ's and AAOA. Your scores are decent and you need to set yourself up for the next two years when your BK falls off.  Resist the apps and use what you have. Seek SP CLI's.


@Creditwiser doing too many things at once. Totally missed that BK is still listed. OP forget what I said, take this advice. Smiley Happy Waiting will be very rewarding for you. 


FICO 8: EQ 712 | EX 711 | TU 706
Discover $10k (AU) | Wayfair $4.5k | AAA Daily Advantage $4.2k | Citizens Bank Cash Back+ | USB Altitude Connect $2k | Target $1k
Message 4 of 9
Supermama
Established Member

Re: Discover It Secured Worth It or Wait for Something Better?

Thanks for the advice!  I'll take it!  I have no real need for a new card really... just getting excited that my scores are finally pretty good and I'm nearly out of debt 😇🤩

Message 5 of 9
FicoMike0
Senior Contributor

Re: Discover It Secured Worth It or Wait for Something Better?

You should see a score boost when your util. reports at 1%. I would hold until there is a card you really want. Then, go for it. 

Message 6 of 9
ScarlettHusky
Contributor

Re: Discover It Secured Worth It or Wait for Something Better?

Congrats on your rebuild so far! I would say your scores should support getting another card, but personally I would wait some time to ensure that your utilization is updated. Some banks would likely shy away from your current (reported) utilization, plus depending on how recently you were approved for your newest card, it wouldn't hurt to let it age a little.

EX: 631 VantageScore FICO: 662
TU: 633 VantageScore FICO: 677
EQ: 640 VantageScore FICO: 633
As of: 4/22

Wallet:
Chase Disney Premier Visa CL $3,600 Extra Credit Builder Debit Card CL $3,000
Amex Platinum SkyMiles Card CL $12,000 NFCU Signature cashRewards Visa CL $11,000
Synchrony Lenovo Store Card CL $10,000 Citi Shell Fuel Rewards Card CL $600
Comenity Victoria's Secret Angel Card CL $900 BofA Alaska Airlines Visa Signature CL $6,700
Capital One Venture One World Elite MC CL $3,950 Quicksilver World Elite MC CL $5,400
Message 7 of 9
nytimestraveler
New Contributor

Re: Discover It Secured Worth It or Wait for Something Better?

I like the discover card but get the 5% one

 

they gave me double the match but that's only the first year so 4% essentially 

 

I started the journey with a 200 secured and a year later they gave me 2000

 

c1 was crap aside from the free Uber One, they gave me 200 CL

 

then my first unsecure is a chase sapphire 

 

 

Chase Sapphire (reaching 95k SUB) 10800 | Discover IT Chrome 2000 | Capital One QuickSilver 200

Next Goal: Open to ideas, 3-5% cards, FCU cards or top limit cards, AMEX Gold/ Plat, Apple Card, RH Gold, 3-6 months out potentially Sapphire x Flex | Venture X Biz x SavorOne, Ink Series

Starting Credit Nov 2023 : 492
Current Credit : 716

QuickSilver I’m looking for PC to SavorOne/ VX and use for niche entertainment



Message 8 of 9
nytimestraveler
New Contributor

Re: Discover It Secured Worth It or Wait for Something Better?

You have great cards in the platinum and bread, I would shoot for the sapphire bro 

Chase Sapphire (reaching 95k SUB) 10800 | Discover IT Chrome 2000 | Capital One QuickSilver 200

Next Goal: Open to ideas, 3-5% cards, FCU cards or top limit cards, AMEX Gold/ Plat, Apple Card, RH Gold, 3-6 months out potentially Sapphire x Flex | Venture X Biz x SavorOne, Ink Series

Starting Credit Nov 2023 : 492
Current Credit : 716

QuickSilver I’m looking for PC to SavorOne/ VX and use for niche entertainment



Message 9 of 9
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.