With your Experian score at 740+, I’m 99% sure you’ll be approved for any Amex card you desire, even ones that didn’t appear on the pre-qual. The question is whether you value cash back or membership rewards points; if you simply want to be rewarded for your purchases with statement credits or gift cards, then obviously cash back is the way to go. Personally I find MR points to be more valuable since I value travel more, especially since they can be transferred to airline partners and you can get a pretty good value out of them that way. For example, something like 75k MR points could get you 2 round trip tickets to Spain— maybe that seems like something you would be interested, for me it certainly is.
Once you figure that out, and if you’re like me and value MR points more, I would probably get the PRG since its the most balanced MR earning structure, and then probably double app with either the Everyday or EDP to get the best MR earning. But again, look through all of the MR earning cards and figure out which one fits your spend the best.
And remember to apply on your private browser, if you applied for both the ED and PRG incognito, and met the minimum spend, you got yourself 75k MR points right there with a $4k spend between the two cards.
