cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

STRANGE NFCU FSR APPROVAL after DENIAL, with $18k CL. Multiple Derogs & thin file too.

tag
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: STRANGE NFCU FSR APPROVAL after DENIAL, with $18k CL. Multiple Derogs & thin file too.

Lol 😆 @visualfxpro ! I'm with you. It's completely understandable to not want to rock the boat given your last update was a no. But you had the right mindset to just go with it!!!

 

And I check my baby limit cards daily so I can only imagine checking your accounts multiple times a day for that 18K!!!! 🍾 🥳 

Message 11 of 24
Total80sKid
Senior Contributor

Re: STRANGE NFCU FSR APPROVAL after DENIAL, with $18k CL. Multiple Derogs & thin file too.

Congrats on your Flagship approval 👍🏼

Message 12 of 24
visualfxpro
Regular Contributor

Re: STRANGE NFCU FSR APPROVAL after DENIAL, with $18k CL. Multiple Derogs & thin file too.


@Anonymous wrote:

Lol 😆 @visualfxpro ! I'm with you. It's completely understandable to not want to rock the boat given your last update was a no. But you had the right mindset to just go with it!!!

 

And I check my baby limit cards daily so I can only imagine checking your accounts multiple times a day for that 18K!!!! 🍾 🥳 


So it STILL says $18k, but no mail came in. It's 1AM, so the mailman might not be working

May 2022: TU Fico 8: 692 | EQ Fico 8: 713 | EX Fico 8: 708
NFCU Flagship Rewards $25,000 | Capitol One $750 | TD Bank $1000 | Bank of America $3000 | Wells Fargo $500 | Amazon $4000

Charge Off from 2015: Municipal Credit Union $5300 ($6500 limit)[PAID IN FULL]
Credit Age: 4 years | Inquiries (6/12/24 month): 12 mo | Debt to Income ratio: 10%
Message 13 of 24
gdale6
Moderator Emeritus

Re: STRANGE NFCU FSR APPROVAL after DENIAL, with $18k CL. Multiple Derogs & thin file too.

Grats on getting you flagship card approved Smiley Happy

Message 14 of 24
kidink1911
Established Contributor

Re: STRANGE NFCU FSR APPROVAL after DENIAL, with $18k CL. Multiple Derogs & thin file too.

Congratulations! What a story of trial and triumph!! Smiley Happy

PERSONAL: AMEX Platinum- NPSL / AMEX Gold- NPSL / Macy's AMEX Card- $4,500 / SavorOne- $500 / PenFed Gold Visa- $5,000 / Venmo Visa - $20,000 / PayPal MC- $20,000 / PayPal Credit- $1,700 / NFCU Visa Signature cashRewards- $5,800 / AMEX Delta Platinum- $4,200 / NFCU More Rewards AMEX- $3,400 / NFCU Cash Rewards- $4,000 / Credit One Platinum Visa Rewards- $1,000 / Discover IT Chrome- $1,000 / Capital One Venture- $3,550 / AMEX Cash Magnet Card- $1,000 / Belk MC Card- $800 / Citi Shell Mastercard- $400 / Credit One AMEX- $800 / Capital One Spark- $700 / Capital One Platinum- $300 / Citibank Shell- $400 / Oportun Visa- $500 / Fifth Third Bank MC- $300
BUSINESS: American Express Business Platinum- NPSL / AMEX Hilton Honors Business Card- $3,000 / AMEX Delta Platinum Business Card- $3,000 / Marriott Bonvoy Business Card- $3,000 / American Express Business Gold- NPSL / American Express Business Green- NPSL / Sam's Club Business Mastercard- $20,000 / Floor and Decor Pro Premier Business- $20,000 / Phillips 66-Conoco-76 Business Gas Card- $5,000 / Walmart Community Credit Line- $5,000 / Fuelman Mastercard- $3,000 / Amazon Synchrony Business Credit Line- $5,000 / Lowe's Business Credit- $5,000 / Office Depot Commercial Credit- $2,500 / Tractor Supply Company Business- $1,500 / Citi Exxon/Mobil Business Gas Card- $3,000 / Speedway Business Mastercard- $4,500
Message 15 of 24
visualfxpro
Regular Contributor

Re: STRANGE NFCU FSR APPROVAL after DENIAL, with $18k CL. Multiple Derogs & thin file too.

WOW, finally got the NFCU letters from my initial application in INTERESTING DETAILS!! So AGAIN...a nudge towards my account status and balance is seen, which supports that my deposit triggered the acceptance??

So they sent me two letters and it's a bit all over the place. So they have some internal score and they gave me 300 of 450. So that would give me like a 70% score? Then look at the factors for denial and note what tops the list:

[NOTE: These are key factors that hurt my NFCU score]
BALANCE status of NFCU accounts(near empty account!)
Direct deposit status of NFCU account (AGAIN money into or IN NFCU related)
Not enough variaty of secured loans (so having a personal loan or car loan would have likely helped)
Number of payments in last year (say what??)
Number of inquiries (ummm...TU only had ONE at that time, from a year ago)

Then ANOTHER part of the letter specifies the ACTUAL reason for denial, supposedly. It says delinquent past or present credit obligations. Ummm...OK. was that the 2 recent lates or the charge off about to fall off?

Then they sent ANOTHER letter that is vague. It does not really say much, but on back it has my TU score as ~580!!!! **bleep** is that? Then a while bunch of NEW factors affecting my score. Like not enough debt management or property ownership, high interest rate loans, not enough short term small dollar lending data, not enough loan paymen info on alternateive credit file...

So, I really don't know what to say about all this. I'm just happy I'm getting this card...supposedly. Smiley Happy

May 2022: TU Fico 8: 692 | EQ Fico 8: 713 | EX Fico 8: 708
NFCU Flagship Rewards $25,000 | Capitol One $750 | TD Bank $1000 | Bank of America $3000 | Wells Fargo $500 | Amazon $4000

Charge Off from 2015: Municipal Credit Union $5300 ($6500 limit)[PAID IN FULL]
Credit Age: 4 years | Inquiries (6/12/24 month): 12 mo | Debt to Income ratio: 10%
Message 16 of 24
AverageJoesCredit
Legendary Contributor

Re: STRANGE NFCU FSR APPROVAL after DENIAL, with $18k CL. Multiple Derogs & thin file too.


@visualfxpro wrote:

WOW, finally got the NFCU letters from my initial application in INTERESTING DETAILS!! So AGAIN...a nudge towards my account status and balance is seen, which supports that my deposit triggered the acceptance??

So they sent me two letters and it's a bit all over the place. So they have some internal score and they gave me 300 of 450. So that would give me like a 70% score? Then look at the factors for denial and note what tops the list:

[NOTE: These are key factors that hurt my NFCU score]
BALANCE status of NFCU accounts(near empty account!)
Direct deposit status of NFCU account (AGAIN money into or IN NFCU related)
Not enough variaty of secured loans (so having a personal loan or car loan would have likely helped)
Number of payments in last year (say what??)
Number of inquiries (ummm...TU only had ONE at that time, from a year ago)

Then ANOTHER part of the letter specifies the ACTUAL reason for denial, supposedly. It says delinquent past or present credit obligations. Ummm...OK. was that the 2 recent lates or the charge off about to fall off?

Then they sent ANOTHER letter that is vague. It does not really say much, but on back it has my TU score as ~580!!!! **bleep** is that? Then a while bunch of NEW factors affecting my score. Like not enough debt management or property ownership, high interest rate loans, not enough short term small dollar lending data, not enough loan paymen info on alternateive credit file...

So, I really don't know what to say about all this. I'm just happy I'm getting this card...supposedly. Smiley Happy


Thats a case where i take the approval and forget about the denial reasons lol. I know people want to get the denial reasons so as to know what to work on, makes sense, but im the kind that they either approve or they dont and being that many times lenders will put the most ctazy reasons for denial that we often times have no control over,  i just take the yes no approach lol.

 

Enjoy 18k Smiley Happy

Message 17 of 24
visualfxpro
Regular Contributor

Re: STRANGE NFCU FSR APPROVAL after DENIAL, with $18k CL. Multiple Derogs & thin file too.

True, I think this is BS, lol.

NOT, my $18k. THAT is SWEET! These denial letters are BS.

May 2022: TU Fico 8: 692 | EQ Fico 8: 713 | EX Fico 8: 708
NFCU Flagship Rewards $25,000 | Capitol One $750 | TD Bank $1000 | Bank of America $3000 | Wells Fargo $500 | Amazon $4000

Charge Off from 2015: Municipal Credit Union $5300 ($6500 limit)[PAID IN FULL]
Credit Age: 4 years | Inquiries (6/12/24 month): 12 mo | Debt to Income ratio: 10%
Message 18 of 24
MartyWrite75
Valued Contributor

Re: STRANGE NFCU FSR APPROVAL after DENIAL, with $18k CL. Multiple Derogs & thin file too.

Congratulations on your approval! Awesome!

June 2025: Experian 772; Equifax 788; Transunion 781


Cards I Have:
Cap One QS: $600 (Sock drawer) || Cap One QS (#2): $7,500 (Sock drawer) || Discover It: $17,400 || Cap One Savor One: $600 (Sock drawer) || AMEX BCP: $10,000 || Amazon Prime Store Card: $10,000 || FNBO Rewards Visa: $2,600 || Discover Cash Back: $9,500 || Citi Custom Cash: $15,500 || Verizon VS Visa: $20,000 || Amex Hilton Honors: $12,000 || Amazon (Chase) Prime Rewards (VS): $9,500 || Citi Double Cash: $6,900

Wishlist Cards:
Paypal Mastercard || Bread Mastercard

Gardening to 6/2026(ideally)
Total Utilization: 11%
Inquiries: Exp: (2) Trans: (1) Equif: (1)

Message 19 of 24
visualfxpro
Regular Contributor

Re: STRANGE NFCU FSR APPROVAL after DENIAL, with $18k CL. Multiple Derogs & thin file too.

Ladies and gentlemen. It has arrived! I already bought lunch AND they let me pay it off already! Nice they don't block you from paying pending charges. So basically I paid it off before the charge was even active.

 

So now today I'll move ALL my auto pays to this card. Then I'll just rotate using the other cards for small stuff, but for now until mortgage close, I'll only use this card, so I will only have one cards with balance and less risk. No way I'm going ANYWHERE near even 30% until. So it will be tiny stuff reporting or stuff that won't hurt me.

I'm FREE!! No more watching EVERY SINGLE purchase! No need to worry so much about credit score either. I already have disputes going so nothing else for me to do but keep this card tight. My biggest stress was keeping until down, but that is not issue now.

 

And when I get my house this will come in handy for any large expenses, since money will be tight in the begining and my score won't matter. It will be down post mortgage and I'm not applying for any credit right now, unless I have to sell my card for downpayment after market crash. However I'll be able to get a car loan easy I think. Get it cheap enough and I can even pay off early to get something later with better rate.

Curious how my score looks in a year.

CardSmall.JPG

May 2022: TU Fico 8: 692 | EQ Fico 8: 713 | EX Fico 8: 708
NFCU Flagship Rewards $25,000 | Capitol One $750 | TD Bank $1000 | Bank of America $3000 | Wells Fargo $500 | Amazon $4000

Charge Off from 2015: Municipal Credit Union $5300 ($6500 limit)[PAID IN FULL]
Credit Age: 4 years | Inquiries (6/12/24 month): 12 mo | Debt to Income ratio: 10%
Message 20 of 24
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.