I am in the same boat as you. Optima Jail. Some how, I got the Platinum from them right after Optima. It might have slipped through crack. Any thing I apply at it is rejected with message "Active Recovery Product". I just stopped trying for any card with Amex.
I have my Optima Card with 5K CL. I am not going to cancel it unless they give me another card. Looks like they will not give me another card as long as I have the optima card. It is a catch 22. I am going leave it the way it is for.
I am not in that much love with Amex to feel bad about not having another card from them. Platinum Card gives me every thing I want from Amex. No point in loosing my sleep.
I like the term you used "Optima Jail".