cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Cards cancel if score drops?

tag
Anonymous
Not applicable

Cards cancel if score drops?

Does anyone know if cards you have in good standing would auto cancel if your score drops badly? I am about to close on a mortgage, which I heard temporarily kills your score. And I (stupidly) made too many inquiries recently, which keeps dinging me too. None of my cards have ever had a problem, always been on time and PIF but there all under a year old. I went down from high 600s to mid recently and wondering if I’ll even dip into 500s when the mortgage shows up. Mortgage is less than one year of my salary — relatively low for most US real estate market. 

Message 1 of 8
7 REPLIES 7
AverageJoesCredit
Legendary Contributor

Re: Cards cancel if score drops?

I wouldnt think so but if your scores are that low and the cards are very young i guess AA is possible but i wouldnt overtly worry about it. Your score will bounce back so just keep using and paying your cards responsibly and you should be ok. Of course ymmv and maybe someone who has baught a house can chime in. Congrats on the house by the waySmiley Happy
Message 2 of 8
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Cards cancel if score drops?

Thanks Smiley Happy

Message 3 of 8
marty56
Super Contributor

Re: Cards cancel if score drops?


@Anonymous wrote:

Does anyone know if cards you have in good standing would auto cancel if your score drops badly? I am about to close on a mortgage, which I heard temporarily kills your score. And I (stupidly) made too many inquiries recently, which keeps dinging me too. None of my cards have ever had a problem, always been on time and PIF but there all under a year old. I went down from high 600s to mid recently and wondering if I’ll even dip into 500s when the mortgage shows up. Mortgage is less than one year of my salary — relatively low for most US real estate market. 


I wouldn't assume that your score would drop and if the mortgage is your only installment loan you may see an increase.  Even if it does, getting a mortgage trumps any effect on your FICO score.  Enjoy the new home.

1/25/2021: FICO 850 EQ 848 TU 847 EX
Message 4 of 8
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Cards cancel if score drops?

While I agree with the above posters that getting a Mortgage will not cause you any more than a one month blip, A word of caution. I dont think the above posters 100% answered your question - the answer is yes a radical ( Dipping into the 5XX range ) sustained drop in scores will cause your credit cards to either drop your limits or close your accounts. This is less common now but it was rampant in 2008-2013 ish . 

Message 5 of 8
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Cards cancel if score drops?

I've never heard of the introduction of a mortgage drastically dropping anyone's credit score.  I guess it depends on how you define drastic.  The largest drop one would see is if they already had an installment loan that's already almost all paid off (less than 8.9% utilization) and then a mortgage was added.  They would have had a 30 point boost or so from the first loan, but the mortgage adding on would raise overall installment loan utilization to near maxed out (depends on the original balance of that first loan, though).  A score in this situation could drop 20-25 points.  Now, if a previous loan was absent from the credit report to begin with (or if it was at very high utilization), there would be no 30 point boost in place, so the scoring drop from the mortgage reporting would be insignificant.

 

OP, what took your score from the high 600's to the mid 600's?  Just inquiries?  Were the inquiries for new accounts?  How many new accounts and how many inquiries per bureau in the last year?  It's generally not recommended that anyone app for anything when a mortgage is approaching, so hopefully you didn't get too crazy.  Definitely don't app for anything any time soon.

 

Also to answer the question regarding potential AA that the OP posed, it's quite unlikely that he'd experience the closing of any cards due to a score drop based on his profile.  9 out of 10 times that a creditor takes AA against someone it's because of the introduction of a negative piece of information to a credit profile.  This is almost always a first late payment and it's a huge sign of risk.  You're showing the lender that you have trouble meeting your financial obligations and other lenders can see that reported late payment and take action.  Score drops outside of the payment history sector of the FICO pie are far less meaningful.  Even someone going from great utilization to maxed out utilization that may see a 100 point score drop is unlikely to see AA so long as they are still making on-time payments.  I know someone that's had 8 out of 9 of their CCs maxed out for almost a year now.  Their aggregate utilization sits at 93%-95% depending on the month.  Not one of the creditors has taken AA against them.  As long as you're making minimum payments and they're getting their money as agreed, usually things are fine.

Message 6 of 8
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Cards cancel if score drops?

Though this doesn't completely answer the question, I thought it note-worthy.

 

I recently openned a mortgage (in August). It took a couple of months before the mortgage reported (late Oct or early Nov id I remember correctly). I was expecting a drop as well when it showed up on my report, but my score didn't change at all. The only time my score changed from the mortgage process was during the initial credit inquiry upon openning an application with the bank. But that was it. Some mortgage companies will run a second credit check before closing, so it could be said that the second check could cause it to drop more, but all of my inquiries have only ever resulting in a fluctuation of about 5 points. 

Message 7 of 8
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Cards cancel if score drops?


@Anonymous wrote:

I recently openned a mortgage (in August). It took a couple of months before the mortgage reported (late Oct or early Nov id I remember correctly). I was expecting a drop as well when it showed up on my report, but my score didn't change at all. The only time my score changed from the mortgage process was during the initial credit inquiry upon openning an application with the bank. But that was it. Some mortgage companies will run a second credit check before closing, so it could be said that the second check could cause it to drop more, but all of my inquiries have only ever resulting in a fluctuation of about 5 points. 


There's not enough information above to really determine anything unfortunately.  Did you have another open installment loan on your credit report prior to adding the mortgage?  If so, what was its utilization percentage at?  When the mortgage landed on your credit report, had you opened another account at all in the last 6 months?  How about the last 12 months?  Did the mortgage account showing up drop your AAoA across an integer value?

 

The above factors mentioned would all play a role in a potential score drop (or lack of).  A scoring change could range anywhere from 0 points depending on these pieces of data to as high as say 50.  The range is quite wide.

Message 8 of 8
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.