cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Hard Inquiry on Pre Approval

tag
markhs777
Frequent Contributor

Re: Hard Inquiry on Pre Approval

You are 100% correct. Checking for a pre approval should not result in a hard pull. 

I've done this this and and get letters about my "application" but no hard pull. You can bet if I did there would be trouble in River City. In fact I still have  two open applications on the website from months ago.

Message 11 of 17
GZG
Senior Contributor

Re: Hard Inquiry on Pre Approval

I thought for those people where it specifically bugged out when they did the pre-qualification, those all ended up in approvals. 

 

I fortunately was able to merely get denied without a HP when I tried when I did the pre-qual when it released awhile back 

Starting FICO 8:
Current FICO 8:



Message 12 of 17
us-east-nomad
Established Member

Re: Hard Inquiry on Pre Approval

Sharing an update:

I have called PenFed helpline to launch a complaint and asked them to review my request and remove this illegitimate hard inquiry. As I have initiated the process for pre-qualification which should have resulted in soft pull.

Screenshot 2023-08-18 001059.png

 

After doing an investigation for 7-10 days (not sure what they have investigated) they responded with a letter stating to decline my request for removing the credit inquiry. Although my request was to investigate why applying for pre-approval has resulted in hard inquiry instead of removing hard inquiry. I plan to visit one of their branches to discuss and escalate this matter.

penfed_letter.jpg

Capital One Platinum | $450Capital One: Walmart Rewards → VentureOne | $1,000Discover IT Cash Back Credit Card | $10,000Capital One Quicksilver Rewards | $9,500PNC Cash Rewards Visa | $10,000Apple Credit Card | $9,000Bilt Mastercard | $10,000

Message 13 of 17
coldfusion
Credit Mentor

Re: Hard Inquiry on Pre Approval

File a complaint online with the NCUA that the inquiry was made without permissible purpose and therefure needs to be withdrawn because you clearly folowed the correct steps to check for a simple preapproval for a credit card, not an application for credit, and PenFed did not disclose before the request that the preapproval would lead to an inquiry.

 

Use the exact word "withdrawn" and not a synonym or other alternate phrasing as In this context "withdrawn" has a special and specific meaning that defines the exact process to be followed which leads to the inquiry being removed in its entirety.

 

Unless for some bizarre reason the NCUA were to decide your complaint were frivolous it will almost certainly get PenFed C-suite visibility.

(10/2025)
FICO 8 (EX) 838 (TU) 846 (EQ) 850
FICO 9 (EX) 850 (TU) 850 (EQ) 850

$1M+ club

Artist formerly known as the_old_curmudgeon who was formerly known as coldfusion
Message 14 of 17
us-east-nomad
Established Member

Re: Hard Inquiry on Pre Approval

Thanks for the suggestion and the guideline for the complaint. I will raise a complaint with NCUA.

Capital One Platinum | $450Capital One: Walmart Rewards → VentureOne | $1,000Discover IT Cash Back Credit Card | $10,000Capital One Quicksilver Rewards | $9,500PNC Cash Rewards Visa | $10,000Apple Credit Card | $9,000Bilt Mastercard | $10,000

Message 15 of 17
DatBoiQuick
Regular Contributor

Re: Hard Inquiry on Pre Approval

If thats the case you might as well apply at that point.

Message 16 of 17
us-east-nomad
Established Member

Re: Hard Inquiry on Pre Approval

Any one recently used Penfed pre-approval tool with only a soft pull of credit report?

 

I checked few months back with a lock on my credit report and I got email from Penfed syaing my credit report is locked.

Capital One Platinum | $450Capital One: Walmart Rewards → VentureOne | $1,000Discover IT Cash Back Credit Card | $10,000Capital One Quicksilver Rewards | $9,500PNC Cash Rewards Visa | $10,000Apple Credit Card | $9,000Bilt Mastercard | $10,000

Message 17 of 17
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.