cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Request credit line DECREASE: when does it make sense?

tag
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Request credit line DECREASE: when does it make sense?


@KJinNC wrote:

Answering the question in the OP and thread title, I wouldn't worry about it unless you start getting denial reasons that you think might be related to this. It seems far-fetched to me that it would be a problem.


Well OP,  a situation like mine is one good reason to request a CLD,  and any other situation where your available credit becomes a risk to you, including where you think you might use too much of it and regret it later. 

 

I have too much revolving available credit,  I'll never use most if it. But it's good for utilization and the credit scores. I never worry about going on a spending spree or being tempted to take them to the casino for the high roller table. 

Message 21 of 45
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Request credit line DECREASE: when does it make sense?


@Anonymous wrote:

@KJinNC wrote:

Answering the question in the OP and thread title, I wouldn't worry about it unless you start getting denial reasons that you think might be related to this. It seems far-fetched to me that it would be a problem.


Well OP,  a situation like mine is one good reason to request a CLD,  and any other situation where your available credit becomes a risk to you, including where you think you might use too much of it and regret it later. 

 

I have too much revolving available credit,  I'll never use most if it. But it's good for utilization and the credit scores. I never worry about going on a spending spree or being tempted to take them to the casino for the high roller table. 


That's really not a good time to ask for a CLD IMO. If you think you'll use too much credit and regret it later, you need to start budgeting. You never learn if you don't have the ability to go beyond your means and you're just hurting yourself in the end if you have an emergency that requires credit and don't have it. If you truly can't control your impulses, a CLD won't do anything to stop you.

Message 22 of 45
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Request credit line DECREASE: when does it make sense?


@Anonymous wrote:

@KJinNC wrote:

Answering the question in the OP and thread title, I wouldn't worry about it unless you start getting denial reasons that you think might be related to this. It seems far-fetched to me that it would be a problem.


Well OP,  a situation like mine is one good reason to request a CLD,  and any other situation where your available credit becomes a risk to you, including where you think you might use too much of it and regret it later. 

 

I have too much revolving available credit,  I'll never use most if it. But it's good for utilization and the credit scores. I never worry about going on a spending spree or being tempted to take them to the casino for the high roller table. 


That's one reason I lowered mine.  It's too easy to run up a balance that can't easily be paid off.

 

Based on your siggy, assuming your annual spend is evenly distributed over 12 months and you aren't carrying balances, you could get by with $45.5k of credit lines and still not exceed 8% utilization.  You could take a $199K CLD and not hurt your scores. Smiley Happy

 

My max monthly spend could be supported with $25K of credit without exceeding 8% utilization, but I feel more comfortable with lower limits since it forces me to spend less and keep balances low so utilization doesn't tank my scores.  Paying before statement cut pretty much makes utilization moot other than when carrying a balance.

 

Message 23 of 45
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Request credit line DECREASE: when does it make sense?


@Anonymous wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

@KJinNC wrote:

Answering the question in the OP and thread title, I wouldn't worry about it unless you start getting denial reasons that you think might be related to this. It seems far-fetched to me that it would be a problem.


Well OP,  a situation like mine is one good reason to request a CLD,  and any other situation where your available credit becomes a risk to you, including where you think you might use too much of it and regret it later. 

 

I have too much revolving available credit,  I'll never use most if it. But it's good for utilization and the credit scores. I never worry about going on a spending spree or being tempted to take them to the casino for the high roller table. 


That's really not a good time to ask for a CLD IMO. If you think you'll use too much credit and regret it later, you need to start budgeting. You never learn if you don't have the ability to go beyond your means and you're just hurting yourself in the end if you have an emergency that requires credit and don't have it. If you truly can't control your impulses, a CLD won't do anything to stop you.


Well, I agree budgeting is the better way to go. That's what I would do. But unfortunately, and I don't understand it myself, not everyone is disciplined enough to grab a hold of themselves and fix the situation. 

 

A CLD might be better than leaving the CLs at a higher level, even though both are bad. A $4900 balance on a $5000 card isn't as bad as a $29,000 balance on a $30K card. In both cases,  not much is left for emergencies. And in both cases, credit scores will suffer. But paying off 4900 is better than paying off 29K.

 

A CLD isn't the best solution, but it might be a solution. The best solution is not always possible with everyone. Changing behavior and becoming very disciplined is the best way. 

Message 24 of 45
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Request credit line DECREASE: when does it make sense?


@Anonymous wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

@KJinNC wrote:

Answering the question in the OP and thread title, I wouldn't worry about it unless you start getting denial reasons that you think might be related to this. It seems far-fetched to me that it would be a problem.


Well OP,  a situation like mine is one good reason to request a CLD,  and any other situation where your available credit becomes a risk to you, including where you think you might use too much of it and regret it later. 

 

I have too much revolving available credit,  I'll never use most if it. But it's good for utilization and the credit scores. I never worry about going on a spending spree or being tempted to take them to the casino for the high roller table. 


That's one reason I lowered mine.  It's too easy to run up a balance that can't easily be paid off.

 

Based on your siggy, assuming your annual spend is evenly distributed over 12 months and you aren't carrying balances, you could get by with $45.5k of credit lines and still not exceed 8% utilization.  You could take a $199K CLD and not hurt your scores. Smiley Happy

 

My max monthly spend could be supported with $25K of credit without exceeding 8% utilization, but I feel more comfortable with lower limits since it forces me to spend less and keep balances low so utilization doesn't tank my scores.  Paying before statement cut pretty much makes utilization moot other than when carrying a balance.

 


I could take a 199K total CLD with my spend and keep util low enough where if I needed a loan, my scores would not suffer enough to affect my interest rate. So yes, i don't need most of it.

 

For me, nothing outside of a major emergency would cause me to go haywire on spend. I'm not tempted to spend any more than I normally would because I have larger lines. If it were given million dollar lines on all my cards, nothing would change.

Message 25 of 45
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Request credit line DECREASE: when does it make sense?


@Anonymous wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

@KJinNC wrote:

Answering the question in the OP and thread title, I wouldn't worry about it unless you start getting denial reasons that you think might be related to this. It seems far-fetched to me that it would be a problem.


Well OP,  a situation like mine is one good reason to request a CLD,  and any other situation where your available credit becomes a risk to you, including where you think you might use too much of it and regret it later. 

 

I have too much revolving available credit,  I'll never use most if it. But it's good for utilization and the credit scores. I never worry about going on a spending spree or being tempted to take them to the casino for the high roller table. 


That's really not a good time to ask for a CLD IMO. If you think you'll use too much credit and regret it later, you need to start budgeting. You never learn if you don't have the ability to go beyond your means and you're just hurting yourself in the end if you have an emergency that requires credit and don't have it. If you truly can't control your impulses, a CLD won't do anything to stop you.


Well, I agree budgeting is the better way to go. That's what I would do. But unfortunately, and I don't understand it myself, not everyone is disciplined enough to grab a hold of themselves and fix the situation. 

 

A CLD might be better than leaving the CLs at a higher level, even though both are bad. A $4900 balance on a $5000 card isn't as bad as a $29,000 balance on a $30K card. In both cases,  not much is left for emergencies. And in both cases, credit scores will suffer. But paying off 4900 is better than paying off 29K.

 

A CLD isn't the best solution, but it might be a solution. The best solution is not always possible with everyone. Changing behavior and becoming very disciplined is the best way. 


I mean its putting a bandaid on a wound that needs stitches really. I still maintain its not a good reason for asking a lender for a CLD for obvious reasons.

Message 26 of 45
KJinNC
Valued Contributor

Re: Request credit line DECREASE: when does it make sense?

Reducing CLs doesn't seem like the most straightforward way to deal with spending problems, but whatever works for you, and I really mean that. I have noticed some gaps in my logic (for example, recurring transfers from one account to another don't feel real to me, so I end up raiding the account - while manual transfers do feel real, so I leave that account alone), so I know psychology can be as important as math.

 

Strictly in credit terms, to my knowledge, there is no upside and likely downside in reducing your credit limits, unless you are getting denials based on having too much credit. JMO. Either way, good luck!



FICO Resilience Index: 64. Cards: 5/24, 2/12, 2/6. Accounts including loans: 8/24, 4/12, 3/6. Card CLs total $213,900, or $240,400 including the AU card. Cards (oldest to newest)

Authorized user / Corporate / Auto loans / Personal loan
Message 27 of 45
coldfusion
Credit Mentor

Re: Request credit line DECREASE: when does it make sense?


@Anonymous wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

@KJinNC wrote:

Answering the question in the OP and thread title, I wouldn't worry about it unless you start getting denial reasons that you think might be related to this. It seems far-fetched to me that it would be a problem.


Well OP,  a situation like mine is one good reason to request a CLD,  and any other situation where your available credit becomes a risk to you, including where you think you might use too much of it and regret it later. 

 

I have too much revolving available credit,  I'll never use most if it. But it's good for utilization and the credit scores. I never worry about going on a spending spree or being tempted to take them to the casino for the high roller table. 


That's really not a good time to ask for a CLD IMO. If you think you'll use too much credit and regret it later, you need to start budgeting. You never learn if you don't have the ability to go beyond your means and you're just hurting yourself in the end if you have an emergency that requires credit and don't have it. If you truly can't control your impulses, a CLD won't do anything to stop you.


Well, I agree budgeting is the better way to go. That's what I would do. But unfortunately, and I don't understand it myself, not everyone is disciplined enough to grab a hold of themselves and fix the situation. 

 

A CLD might be better than leaving the CLs at a higher level, even though both are bad. A $4900 balance on a $5000 card isn't as bad as a $29,000 balance on a $30K card. In both cases,  not much is left for emergencies. And in both cases, credit scores will suffer. But paying off 4900 is better than paying off 29K.

 

A CLD isn't the best solution, but it might be a solution. The best solution is not always possible with everyone. Changing behavior and becoming very disciplined is the best way. 


I mean its putting a bandaid on a wound that needs stitches really. I still maintain its not a good reason for asking a lender for a CLD for obvious reasons.


Perfect is the enemy of good. 

(5/2025)
FICO 8 (EX) 850 (TU) 850 (EQ) 850
FICO 9 (EX) 850 (TU) 850 (EQ) 850

$1M+ club

Artist formerly known as the_old_curmudgeon who was formerly known as coldfusion
Message 28 of 45
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Request credit line DECREASE: when does it make sense?


@KJinNC wrote:

Reducing CLs doesn't seem like the most straightforward way to deal with spending problems, but whatever works for you, and I really mean that. I have noticed some gaps in my logic (for example, recurring transfers from one account to another don't feel real to me, so I end up raiding the account - while manual transfers do feel real, so I leave that account alone), so I know psychology can be as important as math.

 

Strictly in credit terms, to my knowledge, there is no upside and likely downside in reducing your credit limits, unless you are getting denials based on having too much credit. JMO. Either way, good luck!


Totally agree. I'm just saying it minimizes damage if and until the problem is fixed. 

Message 29 of 45
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Request credit line DECREASE: when does it make sense?

Life situations can change as well.  If one takes an income decrease or additional debt/expense load (like a mortgage or higher rent), or loses money in a divorce or whatever, those high limits may no longer be useful.  In my case, moving and then having my wife leave put me into financial distress.  During my financial peak one card grew via auto CLIs to over $15K, but now, I'll never have any use for that much and it was a waste to keep it, so I lowered it a couple years ago and then eventually closed it completely as that card's rewards structure didn't align with my needs.  I got another card (CFU) and that's now my highest limit card, but it too will likely be lowered and capped once the 0% promo expires.

 

Some people want high limits because of utilization, or because they're building/rebuilding their credit and the growing limits are milestones to reach.  Some want them because it strokes their ego.  And others need them because they have tons of money and spend a lot.  These are all fine, but none of them are me.  I've had times where I've had TCL pushing $20K (not a lot to many here but that was a TON for me) and I've had times where I only had a $500 limit card.  Now I'm squarely in between those two extremes, and am fine where I am now.  I don't need more, and can easily live with less.

Message 30 of 45
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.