cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

MIT study: Paying with CCs activates your brain to create ‘purchase cravings’ for more spend

tag
gdale6
Moderator Emeritus

MIT study: Paying with CCs activates your brain to create ‘purchase cravings’ for more spend

Using credit cards stimulates the brain’s reward system and an urge for further spending, according to a recent study from MIT that examined the neuroscience of buying things.

 

Credit card shopping tells us to “step on the gas” and leads to more “purchase cravings” in the future, Drazen Prelec, study author and professor at the MIT Sloan School of Management, said in a release.

 

https://www.cnbc.com/2021/03/13/credit-cards-activate-brain-reward-network-create-cravings.html

Message 1 of 5
4 REPLIES 4
TattnallTrio
Frequent Contributor

Re: MIT study: Paying with CCs activates your brain to create ‘purchase cravings’ for more spend

I disagree with that and also Dave Ramsey has said similar before. I suppose I should reveal that I'm fairly low maintenance and usually on a budget. 

I mostly use my CapOne Visa QS and while I enjoy seeing the cash rewards, I don't go crazy shopping to watch them add up... but I have shifted how I pay things. For instance, I PIF my auto insurance every 6 months and I use my QS instead of my debit card. I do factor in my head how much cash back I'll get and get excited about it. But I don't buy extra stuff for the fun of it to see the rewards LOL. I feel like most people I know are similar to me. But also, the ones that I don't know, if they do as this article says it'll be short lived because then they'll be maxed out and end of story LOL 

Message 2 of 5
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: MIT study: Paying with CCs activates your brain to create ‘purchase cravings’ for more spend

Not very surprisingly, most people don't like to admit that it's true:

 

"Self-reports taken after the shopping task suggest that participants were largely unaware of the influence of payment methods on their decisions, disagreeing with statements that they were more impulsive and less price-conscious when shopping with credit cards (see Supplementary Information)."

 

But they were in an MRI tube while making these purchase decisions and the fMRI scan doesn't lie.

 

Just the mere presence of credit card logos at the point of sale had an influence!

 

"Exposure to credit card logos has also been shown to increase the willingness to pay for items even when people pay with cash, consistent with the idea that credit cards can serve as cues that trigger spending behavior."

Message 3 of 5
K-in-Boston
Epic Contributor

Re: MIT study: Paying with CCs activates your brain to create ‘purchase cravings’ for more spend

Interesting story.  I think the level of it certainly varies from non-existent to extreme.  There are those who always treat credit cards as if they were debit cards and pay them in full each month and those who see any unused amount of credit as there to be used today.  Most of us I want to think fall somewhere in the middle, and we know from studies on the average amount of carried credit card balances that the average consumer leans a bit more toward the latter.

 

All of my cards for daily use and shopping are paid in full each month, so I do think I am at least somewhat conscientious about what I am spending but there is no doubt there's a feeling of satisfaction every time I book "free" travel.

 

Chasing rewards certainly influences how I pay for purchases, but I am also well aware that it also strongly influences where and how I buy at times, particularly for online purchases.  Using shoes as an example, if I know I can get the same pair for $75 locally, I may still elect to buy them for $100 at another retailer if there is a 10% Rakuten coupon, 10%/x Rakuten earnings, and 3%/x earnings on my Rakuten card.  Running those numbers, I paid $90 for the shoes and earned at least $23.40 in Amex Membership Rewards, making my net cost $66.60 at most.  So I ultimately still saved at least $8.40 and a trip to the store so that's worth it to me, and I can justify it as paying a small premium ahead of time for purchasing even more in future travel at a hefty discount.

Message 4 of 5
Gonzozap
Frequent Contributor

Re: MIT study: Paying with CCs activates your brain to create ‘purchase cravings’ for more spend


@TattnallTrio wrote:

I disagree with that and also Dave Ramsey has said similar before. I suppose I should reveal that I'm fairly low maintenance and usually on a budget. 

I mostly use my CapOne Visa QS and while I enjoy seeing the cash rewards, I don't go crazy shopping to watch them add up... but I have shifted how I pay things. For instance, I PIF my auto insurance every 6 months and I use my QS instead of my debit card. I do factor in my head how much cash back I'll get and get excited about it. But I don't buy extra stuff for the fun of it to see the rewards LOL. I feel like most people I know are similar to me. But also, the ones that I don't know, if they do as this article says it'll be short lived because then they'll be maxed out and end of story LOL 


What are you disagreeing with?  Merely because you don't fit into the survey category doesn't make the study false.  Surveys are rarely (if ever)  about 100% of the group.  Surveys merely tell us how many people fit into the various legs of the survey.  Nowhere does the study state that everybody spends more when using credit cards.  We have no grounds to disagree with a valid study.  I can only say that the survey doesn't apply to me.  Frankly, I don't see anything new with this survey.  Banks and creditors have known from eons ago that people using cards will spend more.

Message 5 of 5
† Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.