Big FICO Score difference

Anonymous · ‎07-22-2008

I recently pulled up my FICO scores from the three reporting agencies and found that Experian has me ranked 60 points lower than the other two. The other two are within 4 point of each other. How can the difference be so great? And what do I do to get Experian to adjust or re-evaluate it. I called them and they referred me to this site. The rep here that I spoke with last night (on the phone) referred me back to Experian. I can understand slight variations, but 60 points??????

I found one derog medical ($200) on my reports and have been reading here about how to remove. Frustrating thing is it really isn't my bill, it belongs to my ex, but I'm the one that it reflected on. If someone could please explain a little more about the process involved. I need a little hand holding at times to better understand the order in which I should address this problem. I understand that I need to pay the bill directly to the hospital and then once the check clears ... who do I begin writing letters to and in what order?

Any help is greatly appreciated.

Anonymous · ‎07-22-2008

TxEclectus wrote:

I recently pulled up my FICO scores from the three reporting agencies and found that Experian has me ranked 60 points lower than the other two. The other two are within 4 point of each other. How can the difference be so great? And what do I do to get Experian to adjust or re-evaluate it. I called them and they referred me to this site. The rep here that I spoke with last night (on the phone) referred me back to Experian. I can understand slight variations, but 60 points??????

I found one derog medical ($200) on my reports and have been reading here about how to remove. Frustrating thing is it really isn't my bill, it belongs to my ex, but I'm the one that it reflected on. If someone could please explain a little more about the process involved. I need a little hand holding at times to better understand the order in which I should address this problem. I understand that I need to pay the bill directly to the hospital and then once the check clears ... who do I begin writing letters to and in what order?

Any help is greatly appreciated.

Where did you purchase these scores?

Look at all 3 reports side by side. What does EX have that EQ and TU does not?

What does EX not have, that EQ and TU does?

Were you married to the ex? I would contact the OC about removing my name from the account.

MidnightVoice · ‎07-22-2008

There is currently a 69 point difference between my EX and EQ

The slide from grace is really more like gliding
And I've found the trick is not to stop the sliding
But to find a graceful way of staying slid

Anonymous · ‎07-22-2008

I purchased the full reports from TrueCredit.

Anonymous · ‎07-22-2008

TxEclectus wrote:

I purchased the full reports from TrueCredit.

Those scores are FAKO.

For real FICO scores, you need to purchase them here on this site.

Always check the main page for discount promo codes and google for them as well before purchasing, you can save a few $.

Anonymous · ‎07-25-2008

My reports all have the same information and my Exp is 80 points less than my TU. SAME INFO!

Check to make sure Exp doesn't have more inquiries or lates etc than the others. Seems their scores are harsher.

Anonymous · ‎07-25-2008

KYgirl wrote:

My reports all have the same information and my Exp is 80 points less than my TU. SAME INFO!

Check to make sure Exp doesn't have more inquiries or lates etc than the others. Seems their scores are harsher.

Reports from here?

granny031350 · ‎07-26-2008

I pulled this am from myfico. TU is 623 Equifax is 604 and Experian is 589.

I just had my student loans go from "deferred" to "derogatory, included in wage earner plan" which tanked them all.

When I pulled Experian, listed as the 3rd ranking important reason for the low score is the "recent" serious delinquency.

Now I had that message with TU after I disputed some things back in January and the report date updated. Status date did not change. So I suspect that that is what happened to my Experian score (which was over 600 before this change) and Fico DOES factor in the report date in their scoring.

However that reason is now gone from TU and I expect that in 6 months it will disappear from Experian (hoping)

I have not been late or missed a payment since August 2005 on any account. The only change was that my student loan accounts (4) went to the included in bankruptcy notation.

Once I am discharged officially in December of this year, I will update everything to reflect IIB/zero balance.

Will see what that does to my scores when that happens.

Anonymous · ‎07-26-2008

Mine is the exact same way. It is so aggravating. Try talking to India. I am over 60 pts diff with Experian than the other two. I just had a 12 pt drop in Transunion with an inquiry made by my electric company that I just switched to. I called and emailed the electric co. and they emailed me back that they not only don't, but can't do a hard inquiry and that it is an error on the part of Transunion. I called transunion and they said they only report what they are given, and I need to call the company. The electric company says it is impossible that they did a hard inquiry and that is the end of it. Talking to the people in India with transunion is useless. There is NO figuring these out. They are money making things that we all follow religiously and really are no where close to being accurate or real..and yet here I am too. Glutton for punishment.

RobertEG · ‎07-26-2008

You have stumbled upon the mysterious world of credit scoring.

The first thing to realize is that federal regulations, as codified in the FCRA, govern only what CANNOT be reported to a CRA, and does not in any way regulate what MUST be reported to a CRA. Any creditor can decide not to report at all, to report to only one, or to all three of the CRAs. That is why it is critical to carefully review your three CRA reports to make sure of any differences in their base data.

OK, so each CRA has its own database. Then we come to scoring against their database. There is no such thing as a TU, EX, or EQ credit score. There are no regulations at all on the generation of credit scores, other than that the data they use complies with the FCRA. So all scorers use data from the three CRAs, which are regulated.

There are many vendors of credit scores. FairIsaac vends a credit scoring algorithm to each CRA. But the CRAs have also developed their own scoring algorithms, the most prominent of which is their Vantage score algorithm. So you have to know the source of the algorithm that produced any score that you purchase. Scores vended through TruCredit are not based on the FairIsaac algorithm, and thus cannot be compared in any way with FICO scores. That is not to say that they are fake scores. However, most lendors rely upon the FairIsaac scoring algorithm.

But even FICO scores, coming from algorithms developed from FairIsaac, are not consistent. FairIsaac vends different versions of its basic algorithm to each CRA, So even with totally identical data in the files of each CRA, the FICO scores that they provide can vary by as much as 20 points.

Then it gets really confusing. Aside from the different consumer versions marketed to each CRA, FairIsaac also vends different flavors of its algorithms. Classic FICO, enhanced FICO, auto-enhanced FICO, and the impending FICO 08, just to name a few.

FICO, in its various versions, and non-FICOs, proliferate.

Stick to what the lendors use. FICO.