No credit card required
Browse credit cards from a variety of issuers to see if there's a better card for you.
Hi all,
I'm already thinking at least a year ahead, so I just have a general question for now. We have a few items that we're paying for monthly that are not on our credit reports for various reasons. Question: How do these monthly recurring payments that are not on our credit reports affect getting a mortgage loan.
These do not show up on our credit reports, but can be clearly seen as recurring withdrawals/payments on a monthly basis when looking at bank statements. Please give me the skinny on how these kinds of items are handled by loan officers.
@trnl2016 wrote:Hi all,
I'm already thinking at least a year ahead, so I just have a general question for now. We have a few items that we're paying for monthly that are not on our credit reports for various reasons.
- Regular payments toward a Disney Vacation Club interest (Disney does not report to CRAs)
- Regular payments toward a purchase that was put on a family member's credit card (completely under his name, we make the payments) - You'll need to be an authorized user
- Regular payments toward a friend for a shared IRS obligation (completely under her name, we transfer the money to her bank acct) - Is this a lien? If so, is the lien reporting on your credit? If not, you really don't want a lien on your credit report.
- Regular payments toward a family member for loaning us money (we transfer the money to her bank acct) - This won't show up, she isn't a valid merchant/creditor. If she co-signed for a personal loan through a bank, perhaps.
These do not show up on our credit reports, but can be clearly seen as recurring withdrawals/payments on a monthly basis when looking at bank statements. Please give me the skinny on how these kinds of items are handled by loan officers. - So, considering I am in talks with some right now, they will probably ask for bank statements and, if it raises question, they will ask about the payments you're making to discern your monthly expenses when calculating debt-to-income ratios. Funny thing I've noticed is, they're more concerned about larger sums of money you deposit into your bank than payments going out. For instance, I got my bonus check, well over $10,000, and they were "concerned" about it. They were also concerned about $8,000 in deposits I made over a small period of time, all based on people paying me to work on their motorcycles in my garage. I can understand it isn't "reported income", but if your experience is anything like mine, be prepared to answer more questions about money going into your account versus going out.
@trnl2016 wrote:
Thanks for the reply, robertmp.
Fortunately (or unfortunately, rather) we don't have any big deposits going in -- just our standard biweekly paychecks.
As far as the rest, I'll address them in order.
For #2 above, we don't want to be an authorized user on the account. My husband's brother allowed my husband to buy a piece of jewelry for me using a 0% promo on his card, so we have about 24 more months left with a small monthly payment of $62. His brother is fine with the debt being under his name, and he doesn't even worry about the payments. We pay it monthly, but are not interested in having this debt come under our names. - It won't show up on the credit report and, if the lender counts this against your debt-to-income ratio, you're getting double whacked because you're not getting it reported against your credit and you're getting the amount you're paying counted against your DTI ratio. I don't really forsee them worrying about this so I wouldn't raise too much fuss about it.
For #3 above, the IRS obligation is not a lien. My friend and I sold items on eBay one year and ended up owing a few thousand in taxes. We were using her PayPal account, so the tax obligation became hers. She set up a payment plan with the IRS that we've been on for 2 years, but we split the payment equally since we are both responsible for the income. The payment plan is not on her credit report (nor mine, since it's not legally my tax obligation), but I send her $150/mo to cover my half of the payment we make monthly. - Ah, well, they're probably going to ask for 2 years of IRS returns and your returns won't show the obligation; thus, don't worry about it because legally, you're not obligated to it.
For #4 above, it is obviously not on our credit reports because we were just given cash from my aunt's personal bank. We have agreed to pay her back a certain amount (which is TBD) monthly. - Yeah, this won't be reported either. If there is a question about the debt, you'll likely have to get a contract made up to prove it and, to be honest, make the monthly "minimum payment" very low, so it doesn't hurt too bad on the monthly DTI ratio of expenses.
I realize now that my question wasn't too clear. My question is: if a loan officer sees these regularly monthly payments from our bank statements (and they are NOT on our credit reports), how do they handle them? - Honestly, case-by-case, but they also don't question bill payments showing up on your bank statements, sometimes you can use Wells Fargo surpay or something similar to transfer money for bill payments too. Unless the amounts are large enough to notice, they're likely not to ask; however, if they do ask, just explain like you did here and try to work with your broker to see if they're willing to just ignore those anways, since they're not valid debts to begin with. From their perspective, if you AND the other obligated party discontinues payment, YOU are not liable, only the other party is, so you're not legally obligated to pay it back from the original creditors perspective.
@trnl2016 wrote:
Great, thanks so much for the response again!! So worst case scenario is that they'll consider it against my DTI, but best case, they won't even worry about it. That's not too bad. I'm not sure what I thought worst case scenario might be, but for some reason I was worried. Thank you again.
I'd say you hit the jackpot on that! If you really wanted to, just take out cash and pay with with cash and/or get a money order or use paypal or something to make the payments to them; thus, you'll never really need to explain this to them anyways.
One last thing, while I am sure you trust your friends and family, sign nothing without it first being reviewed by a lawyer.
@Anonymous wrote:
@trnl2016 wrote:
Great, thanks so much for the response again!! So worst case scenario is that they'll consider it against my DTI, but best case, they won't even worry about it. That's not too bad. I'm not sure what I thought worst case scenario might be, but for some reason I was worried. Thank you again.I'd say you hit the jackpot on that! If you really wanted to, just take out cash and pay with with cash and/or get a money order or use paypal or something to make the payments to them; thus, you'll never really need to explain this to them anyways.
One last thing, while I am sure you trust your friends and family, sign nothing without it first being reviewed by a lawyer.
Thank you, that's a great idea. I could easily send my friend $450 for 3 months worth of payments and then skip the next few months of paying her, for example. She would have no problem with that, and I wouldn't have to explain anything to anyone, haha.
The funny thing is... I think it's the friends & family who trust me! Eek for them! :-P ... they have all, in different ways, taken the responsibility for the debt which I'm paying. I suppose they should have asked me to sign something, but I haven't signed anything with anyone. Good thing for all of us that, at least this far, things have gone without a hitch.
Couple of comments on your situation OP:
1) Discuss with your LO the payment arrangements you have made outside of those on your CR - those payments will need to be included in your DTI
2) It is considered loan fraud if you don't disclose all the debt you have when you apply for a mortgage - you don't want to go down this road as the loan will be automatically denied, so don't go there.
The LO is your advocate in this process of obtaining a mortgage. S/he knows the guidelines, or ought to know the guidelines. Don't keep these types of issues from the LO. Have a discussion with your trusted LO and put all your info on the table. It is better for you.
@StartingOver10 wrote:Couple of comments on your situation OP:
1) Discuss with your LO the payment arrangements you have made outside of those on your CR - those payments will need to be included in your DTI
2) It is considered loan fraud if you don't disclose all the debt you have when you apply for a mortgage - you don't want to go down this road as the loan will be automatically denied, so don't go there.
The LO is your advocate in this process of obtaining a mortgage. S/he knows the guidelines, or ought to know the guidelines. Don't keep these types of issues from the LO. Have a discussion with your trusted LO and put all your info on the table. It is better for you.
Hey StartingOver10, thanks for the reply!
That's interesting, I had never considered that it might be considered loan fraud. Just to play devil's advocate, is it still loan fraud if I don't disclose those debts that are truly not my legal responsibility? An example would be... Item #1 in my list (DVC loan) is definitely ours, and our legal responsibility... it's just not reported to the CRAs. However, I would still disclose that. Items #2 and #3 are not my legal responsibility in any way. Would not disclosing them still be considered loan fraud??
That being said, please don't take my questions to mean that I would commit any kind of fraud.
I don't know the answer to your question about debts that you elect to pay that are not your legal responsibility to pay.
From what I gather, the whole reason for disclosing all of your debt is so the lender can get an accurate financial picture of you and your financial ability to support the loan you are requesting. The link below mentions that omission of debt is mortgage fraud. I don't know if they distinguish between debt that you are obligated to pay and debt that you do pay but have no legal obligation to pay.
Here is a link to informaiton about Mortgage Fraud Prevention and Detection directed toward lenders (if you are curious about it) https://www.corelogic.com/research/fraud-prevention/mortgage-fraud-prevention-and-detection.pdf