No credit card required
Browse credit cards from a variety of issuers to see if there's a better card for you.
So I guess sometime in the last four-or-five years, I've disputed an old Barclay's credit card. The card was closed like six years ago and charged off, but randomly started impacting my CU 2-3 years ago, so I disputed to try to limit that impact (wasn't on here, and didn't really know what I was doing).
Flash foward to now and I'm going through the underwriting process and I'm told to avoid a manual underwrite, I need to get the dispute remarks taken away from the reports, so my mortgage guy has had me draft a letter and he says it'll take 4-5 days and they will be gone.
I guess the main question is what impact will this have on my score. The last activity is listed as 07/2015, and the last update on any of the reports is 12/2019.
It would seem to be pretty unusual for something that is nearly seven years old to impact FHA qualification, but I'm suddenly concerned. My mid score is 659 as of today.
Because of its age, it is likely that your score wouldn't drop at all but if it does it ahouldnt be nore than a couple of points. The next pricing threshold would be a 639 middle score. Your score isn't going to drop 20 points. No worries!
I'm currently in the market for a home as well. I was able to get my credit utilization down to 4% and my Experian score jumped up 17 points! Unfortunately, I paid off a collection from 2016 and my score decreased by that same 17 points. I'm terrified of what this will do to my EQ and TU scores. The credit system has it's own nuances. Things like this will likely make you or break you. Sometimes, all you can really do is cross your fingers and hope for a positive impact. I hope things go well for you, but unfortunately, they haven't gone well for me at all even when taking the proper steps to improve my score.
@Anonymous wrote:So I guess sometime in the last four-or-five years, I've disputed an old Barclay's credit card. The card was closed like six years ago and charged off, but randomly started impacting my CU 2-3 years ago, so I disputed to try to limit that impact (wasn't on here, and didn't really know what I was doing).
Flash foward to now and I'm going through the underwriting process and I'm told to avoid a manual underwrite, I need to get the dispute remarks taken away from the reports, so my mortgage guy has had me draft a letter and he says it'll take 4-5 days and they will be gone.
I guess the main question is what impact will this have on my score. The last activity is listed as 07/2015, and the last update on any of the reports is 12/2019.
It would seem to be pretty unusual for something that is nearly seven years old to impact FHA qualification, but I'm suddenly concerned. My mid score is 659 as of today.
Is the balance over $1,000?
@VALoanMaster wrote:
@Anonymous wrote:So I guess sometime in the last four-or-five years, I've disputed an old Barclay's credit card. The card was closed like six years ago and charged off, but randomly started impacting my CU 2-3 years ago, so I disputed to try to limit that impact (wasn't on here, and didn't really know what I was doing).
Flash foward to now and I'm going through the underwriting process and I'm told to avoid a manual underwrite, I need to get the dispute remarks taken away from the reports, so my mortgage guy has had me draft a letter and he says it'll take 4-5 days and they will be gone.
I guess the main question is what impact will this have on my score. The last activity is listed as 07/2015, and the last update on any of the reports is 12/2019.
It would seem to be pretty unusual for something that is nearly seven years old to impact FHA qualification, but I'm suddenly concerned. My mid score is 659 as of today.Is the balance over $1,000?
$2,256
Looks like these changes have gone through already. My FICO 8 dropped 12 points (Equifax), but my middle (mortgage) score just went down five points to 654. If that's all the damage done, I'm happy.
A Loan Officer, after pulling your credit, can run your credit through one or our credit analyzer programs, and remove the inquiry and see if the score drops. These tools are pretty accurate. If it's an old dispute, meaning greater than 1 year old, the scores most likely won't drop or very little. But if the inquiry is fairly new, removing 1 or more can kill your credit score. I have seen it!
So here's the trick.
Remove or Resolve Disputes
If you are applying for a Conventional Loan, you MUST remove all disputes and comments. If you are applying for a FHA, VA, or USDA loan, you have some options.
1.) You can remove the disputes and comments but risk a drop in your credit score.
2.) You can resolve the dispute and your scores will not drop. Why? Because technically, to the credit bureau, the tradeline is still in dispute.
3.) You can elect to do nothing, and your loan will downgraded to a manually underwritten loan. Which will carry additional conditions, and some lenders could have higher rates and or fees.
Contact Numbers
Experian (714) 830-7000, No Customer support on weekends. In order to talk with a representative, if you are not on PST, you must call after 12pm Eastern time Monday-Friday otherwise you will not be able to reach someone because the menu won't give that choice to select. You will get a menu run-around.
TransUnion (800) 916-8800, No Customer support on weekends. You can call Monday-Friday during normal business hours.
Equifax (888) 548-7878, you can talk with a representative during the week and weekends. I don't know the exact hours but calling M-F during normal hours and weekends late morning early afternoon will get you a representative.
Follow these instructions:
When they answer they will ask you the reason for the call? Tell them you are buying a home and the lender is requiring that all disputes to need to be updated to show “Dispute Resolved Consumer Disagrees”. The Rep may or may not transfer you to another rep. If so, just tell the new rep your purpose for the call. They will ask you, which accounts. If you are uncertain, ask them to go through tradeline line by line.
They know what you are talking about and can and will take care of it. Tell the representative that your loan will be denied if this is not done within the next 48-72 hours. Then once this has been completed over the phone, ask to be transferred to a supervisor. The reason being is 95% of the time the representatives always leave one or two disputes unresolved. You can ask the supervisor to check to make sure all disputes are resolved.
NOTE: TU may not allow you to resolve the dispute, it depends on who you speak to. They may make you remove the comments completely. But try! Go up the chain of command if necessary. If not, just have them remove all comments or call back and speak with another Rep.
After the 48-72 hours, I encourage you to call back and confirm your request was completed. I want you to know that Equifax is notorious for not completing your request correctly. Time after time when the credit is re-pulled, Equifax still has disputes showing. So I strongly encourage you to make sure to take the extra step and call again. I recommend you call and ask for a Supervisor.
If you have better phone numbers, please list them.