cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Debt Consolidation Question?!

tag
Anonymous
Not applicable

Debt Consolidation Question?!

Which of these three options should I pick for handling mby debts:

 

1.)  I pay $911 a month right now - it's every penny we have.  Calculators online say I should be debt free in 3 YEARS if nothing else is spend.  Which is hard in three years.  We buy gas and groceries Friday on pay day and are broke rest of week - literally every penny.

2.)  I could pay $811 a month on all the individual debts below - I would be debt free in 7 YEARS.

 

3.)  Debt consolidatin personal loan (SoFi or Upstart or similar) - rate is around 10.99%.  Payoff debts in 5 years.  No origination fees.  But just have one payment and it is lower - around $750 so gives us some money to save / spend when needed instead of turning to cards because there is no spare cash.

 

4.)  Refinance house and take out extra $28000.  My rates would stay at 4.5% -- my payment would go from $1513 to $1590 a month.  But I am paying on that for 30 years (or however long I live there).

 

Here is what we owe:

Personal loan - $14,624 @ 9.75%

Medical loan - $6852 @ 6.99%

Chase Credit Card - $2980 @ 0%    (forever rate since we will keep balance transfering)

Citi Card- $3400 @ 0%    (forever rate since we will keep balance transfering)

Doctor bills - $1052 @ 0% 

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

TOTAL - $28,908

Message 13 of 38
37 REPLIES 37
Anonymous
Not applicable

WHICH ORDER SHOULD I PAY THESE DEBTS?

So I have read about snowball and avalanche but wanted some advice on how to pay down these debts the best and fastest.

 

Personal loan - $14,624 @ 9.75%

Medical loan - $6852 @ 6.99%

Chase Credit Card - $2980 @ 0%  (intro rate)

Citi Card- $3400 @ 0%  (intro rate)

Doctor bills - $1052 @ 0% 

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

TOTAL - $28,908

 

Now all the websites say to make minimum payments to everything except the Personal Loan and put $100 extra a month towards that.  Smart since it's the highest interest.  Says if I do the avalanche method I will be out of debt in 3 YEARS.

 

 But my credit score keeps dropping every month.  I am wondering if I should be putting that $100 extra towards one of those instead?  Those report to the credit score faster right?  Those would make it rise faster than the personal loan right?

 

I plan to keep finding BALANCE TRANSFER cards and moving the credit card debt to them.   I have 22 cards (only these two have balances - so those cards often offer me ability to do a 0% transfer)

 

Also - I just stashed away $350 today into savings.  I read I should have an emergency fund so if something comes up tomorrow I have cash instead of credit cards.  But would it be better used at paying down $350 of debt?

 

OPTIONS:

#1 - continue to pay $911 a month individually.  Online calculators say I should be debt free in 3 years if I spend nothing more (long shot)

 

#2 - use a personal loan to consolidate debt.  Pay $750 a month approx for 5 YEARS.   That $175 approx a month in savings would come in handly towards emergencys, day to day life.  Rate is 10.99%

 

#3 - refinance house and take out money.  Keep same mortgage rate as I have now.  Increase monthly payments by $100 (for 30 years).  And have $280000 cash to pay off above debts.

Message 1 of 38
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: WHICH ORDER SHOULD I PAY THESE DEBTS?

You might want to include for how long your 0% intro offers are, and when those offer rates began. Good luck!

Message 2 of 38
OmarGB9
Community Leader
Super Contributor

Re: WHICH ORDER SHOULD I PAY THESE DEBTS?

Credit scores shouldn't take priority over finances. Do what's best for your finances, and the score increases will follow. Unless there's a pressing need for credit anytime within the next few years (i.e. new car because your current one is about give out, mortgage), don't sweat the scores so much. 

 

That said, definitely have a safety net and put money away into savings for a rainy day. And yes, IMO, tackle that personal loan first as it has the highest interest and is costing you the most money every month. 


Last App: 1/10/2023
Penfed Gold Visa Card

Currently rebuilding as of 04/11/2019.

Starting FICO 8 Scores:




Current FICO 8 scores:


Message 3 of 38
FireMedic1
Community Leader
Mega Contributor

Re: WHICH ORDER SHOULD I PAY THESE DEBTS?


@Anonymous wrote:

So I have read about snowball and avalanche but wanted some advice on how to pay down these debts the best and fastest.

 

Personal loan - $14,624 @ 9.75%

Medical loan - $6852 @ 6.99%

Chase Credit Card - $2980 @ 0%  (intro rate)

Citi Card- $3400 @ 0%  (intro rate)

Doctor bills - $1052 @ 0% 

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

TOTAL - $28,908

 

Now all the websites say to make minimum payments to everything except the Personal Loan and put $100 extra a month towards that.  Smart since it's the highest interest.  Says if I do the avalanche method I will be out of debt in 3 YEARS.

 

 But my credit score keeps dropping every month.  I am wondering if I should be putting that $100 extra towards one of those instead?  Those report to the credit score faster right?  Those would make it rise faster than the personal loan right?

 

I plan to keep finding BALANCE TRANSFER cards and moving the credit card debt to them.   I have 22 cards (only these two have balances - so those cards often offer me ability to do a 0% transfer)

 

Also - I just stashed away $350 today into savings.  I read I should have an emergency fund so if something comes up tomorrow I have cash instead of credit cards.  But would it be better used at paying down $350 of debt?


Personal loan - $14,624 @ 9.75% Original Loan amount?

Medical loan - $6852 @ 6.99% Original Loan amount?

Chase Credit Card - $2980 @ 0%  (intro rate) Credit Limit?

Citi Card- $3400 @ 0%  (intro rate) Credit Limit?

Doctor bills - $1052 @ 0% Is this on Care Credit? If so. Credit Limit.

If you can fill out the red above. Then we can find out whats dropping your score each month.


Message 4 of 38
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: WHICH ORDER SHOULD I PAY THESE DEBTS?

Personal loan - $14,624 @ 9.75% Original Loan amount?  $18000

Medical loan - $6852 @ 6.99% Original Loan amount?   $7500

Chase Credit Card - $2980 @ 0%  (intro rate) Credit Limit?  $4500

Citi Card- $3400 @ 0%  (intro rate) Credit Limit?   4500

Doctor bills - $1052 @ 0% Is this on Care Credit? just owed to doctor offices - not being reported to credit

Message 5 of 38
FireMedic1
Community Leader
Mega Contributor

Re: WHICH ORDER SHOULD I PAY THESE DEBTS?


@Anonymous wrote:

Personal loan - $14,624 @ 9.75% Original Loan amount?  $18000

Medical loan - $6852 @ 6.99% Original Loan amount?   $7500

Chase Credit Card - $2980 @ 0%  (intro rate) Credit Limit?  $4500 64.2%

Citi Card- $3400 @ 0%  (intro rate) Credit Limit?   4500 75.5%

Doctor bills - $1052 @ 0% Is this on Care Credit? just owed to doctor offices - not being reported to credit


On the 2 cards your util is high. To get points faster. (Which getting out of debt ranks first) Paying those down to <48% would help. But theres no interest. Dont know how long the terms are until interest kicks in. If its soon. There's more instant debt. Paying the loan as much as possible due to the highest interest will save you short term money. Best case scenario is PIF before the interest kicks in on the cards.

 

But on the other hand. To say even more in the long run. Pay down the credit cards before the 0% promo ends. No credit card sits at 9.75%. Maybe a credit union. Likely not. So theres 2 routes to go with this. Pay down the cards. Then attack the loan 9% loan. Or if time will allow for you to pay down the loan before the 0 promo ends. Pay down the loan then the cards.

 

Kinda stuck in between. The interest will remain with the loan. But when the 0% promo ends. Here comes higher card payments. Good Luck!


Message 6 of 38
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: WHICH ORDER SHOULD I PAY THESE DEBTS?

Well the plan is to keep moving those credit cards to new balance transfer cards so the 0% will continue over and over and over.

 

We have about 22 cards (only these two used) and they are constantly offering us balance transfers for 18 months at 0%.

 

So if that is the case you think the PERSONAL LOAN?

 

My goal isn't only to get down debt - it's also to increase credit score to refinance house!

Message 7 of 38
satio
Frequent Contributor

Re: WHICH ORDER SHOULD I PAY THESE DEBTS?


@Anonymous wrote:

Well the plan is to keep moving those credit cards to new balance transfer cards so the 0% will continue over and over and over.

 

We have about 22 cards (only these two used) and they are constantly offering us balance transfers for 18 months at 0%.

 

So if that is the case you think the PERSONAL LOAN?

 

My goal isn't only to get down debt - it's also to increase credit score to refinance house!


Is a target goal for the home refinance to do a cash out and pay off debt, get a lower interest rate, or extend payments out further to reduce monthly expediture?

 

Are there any other debts, collections, charge off, or other derogatories (late pays in last 24 months) on your report(s)?

 



Message 8 of 38
RehabbingANDBlabbing
Established Contributor

Re: WHICH ORDER SHOULD I PAY THESE DEBTS?

I think the snowball method is likely the best. You start paying off your bills smallest to largest. So you would start with the doctor bills and pay all of your extra income on those until they are done, then you would move on to the next largest debt after that. The other thing to think about here is that those doctor bills could be turned over to collections at any time. You are expected to pay them as soon as possible, rather than dragging it out like a credit card balance. Many people on these forums end up with credit issues from that, so if your credit is a priority, I would definitely get those paid first.

 

In addition, paying down the credit cards first will get much more of a score increase than paying off the installment loans. Utilization on revolving accounts affects your credit score a lot, whereas installment loans matter very little in terms of the balance. For example, I played around with the FICO score simulator recently. I have about $38k in student loan debt. If I paid all of that off right now, the simulator says I would gain 5 points on my credit score. So if you do want to refinance your house, then your best bet would be paying the cards off first (after the doctor bills).

 

In this method, you'd pay them down in this order:

1. Doctor bills - $1052 @ 0% 

2. Chase Credit Card - $2980 @ 0%  (intro rate)

3. Citi Card- $3400 @ 0%  (intro rate)

4. Medical loan - $6852 @ 6.99%

5. Personal loan - $14,624 @ 9.75%

 

 

Message 9 of 38
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.