cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Personal Loans or Personal LOC for Debt Consolidation

tag
twpounds
Valued Member

Re: Personal Loans or Personal LOC for Debt Consolidation


@FicoMike0 wrote:

Looks like a good plan. I would question paying off the car. Often, car loan rates are fairly low. If that's the case, don't trade low rate car debt for higher rate debt, just keep making the payments.

I have went back and forth on that one. The benefit to paying the car off would be it would free up a $600/month payment which is one of our largest payments. The car is a lower rate, but it would also move some of those higher interest balances quicker if I snowballed that $600 payment into our additional payments.

 


 

Message 11 of 17
Drifter73
Established Contributor

Re: Personal Loans or Personal LOC for Debt Consolidation

From what I've encountered, I've noticed even  a CU PLOC has a slightly higher interest rate than a straight up Loan. Possibly because a PLOC is rotating and a Loan is one time.

 

With that said, if the lowest interest is your target in consolidating, a PLOC might not be the best fit.

 

If interest rate isn't a factor and you just want the ability to tap back into it once some is paid off, then a PLOC might work.











Message 12 of 17
RealEstateGuy89
Frequent Contributor

Re: Personal Loans or Personal LOC for Debt Consolidation


@twpounds wrote:

I've got another thread under the credit card forum discussing BT cards and paying down cc debts. I have learned a lot in the last few weeks and I am trying to come up with a solid/methodical plan to get us off of running around on the hamster wheel of debt. My wife and I have racked up $44k in cc debt with a $7k balance on a car. Her credit is very low 600s with $21k of the $44k debt in her name as well as the $7k car balance. I have $23k in my name. $5k of which is on a RTG 0% promo that I'm handling fine. My big problem is my capital one card that has the $18k balance on it. I have FICO 8 scores ranging from 797-801. My total utilization rate on my 6 cards is about 22%. However, the utilization rate on my capital one card with the $18k balance is 62%. I recently opened a new Citi card with 0% BT offer for 21 months that I intend on using to put about $5,200 of my wife's cards on to pay off. That would payoff 6 of her cards, but it would put me with a 33.73% utilization rate on the new Citi card. I have not done any BT yet and after doing some research, I think it would be best to try to obtain a personal debt consolidation loan for all or as much of our debt as possible. My debt to income ratio is currently sitting at around 33% which includes my mortgage. I have read about debt consolidation loans and it seems like there are a lot of scams out there as well as the companies that are supposed to be paying your debts while you pay them, but they only cause you to have late payments and ruin your credit. We have no late payments and have been snowballing the best we can, but it is taking a toll on us because it is an extremely slow process. I think a personal loan coupled with 0% BT offers may be the way to go for us. I have read about SoFI and have saw credit unions mentioned as possible personal debt consolidation loan possibilities. I'd like to apply for a loan before doing any BTs while my total utilization and debt to income ratios are still in decent shape. We can make payments, but we would like to see the balances reducing instead of being eaten by the high interest cards my wife has. Do any of you know anything about SoFi or any other companies that would possibly lend me the total $44k or really any large sum at a decent rate(15% or less preferably) given my credit scores, utilization rates, and debt to income ratio? I'd rather not involve my wife at all other than using her income to help pay the loan off because of her low scores and very high utilization. We'd also not want to consider a secured loan such as a HELOC if at all possible. We don't want to risk our house. Would a personal debt consolidation loan or a personal line of credit be the best route and if so, which one would you go with? I'm leaning personal loan over line of credit even though the LOC would give flexibility for unexpected house or car repairs while paying down our cc debt. Any feedback on our situation would be greatly appreciated as well as any personal loan leads that any of you have had good experience with. We have done all the cutting back that we can and we have had the tough discussions about how we got here and how to not get back here. We just need some favorable lending to help us. If I left out any pertinent details, please ask.


About three or four years ago, I took out a $20,000 loan at LightStream for 60 months at 6.99%. It's almost paid off now and it has been a really good loan for me.  I love the interest-rate.  I think their loans go up to $100,000, so I would recommend taking a look at their website.  I applied for the loan and the next day it was in my checking account.  It was so easy that I never even talked to anybody at LightStream and still haven't.  I filled it out online and it approved me right after submitting it.

 

I don't blame you for not wanting to take out a loan against your house.  I would not do that myself.  With how things are uncertain lately with the economy and the election coming up, we just never know where we are headed as a nation right now.

 

I would take a look at spreading some of your debt around to any 0% BT cards that you may have opened up so that your utilization looks a little bit lower on certain cards that are high.  Then, I would look at LightStream and if you are satisfied with them, apply for it.  From everything that I've seen about SOFI, it looks like they charge higher rates of interest.  Most likely in the teens or upper teens in some cases.  There are definitely places that charge lower rates of interest for personal loans, but you just have to look for them.  I haven't seen anyone that can compete with LightStream yet though.

 

Another good thing about taking out a personal loan out is that it will lower your utilization on your cards and make your score go up considerably.  That's what happened with my scores at the time.  Please let us know what you decide.  Best of luck to you!

Message 13 of 17
twpounds
Valued Member

Re: Personal Loans or Personal LOC for Debt Consolidation


@RealEstateGuy89 wrote:

@twpounds wrote:

I've got another thread under the credit card forum discussing BT cards and paying down cc debts. I have learned a lot in the last few weeks and I am trying to come up with a solid/methodical plan to get us off of running around on the hamster wheel of debt. My wife and I have racked up $44k in cc debt with a $7k balance on a car. Her credit is very low 600s with $21k of the $44k debt in her name as well as the $7k car balance. I have $23k in my name. $5k of which is on a RTG 0% promo that I'm handling fine. My big problem is my capital one card that has the $18k balance on it. I have FICO 8 scores ranging from 797-801. My total utilization rate on my 6 cards is about 22%. However, the utilization rate on my capital one card with the $18k balance is 62%. I recently opened a new Citi card with 0% BT offer for 21 months that I intend on using to put about $5,200 of my wife's cards on to pay off. That would payoff 6 of her cards, but it would put me with a 33.73% utilization rate on the new Citi card. I have not done any BT yet and after doing some research, I think it would be best to try to obtain a personal debt consolidation loan for all or as much of our debt as possible. My debt to income ratio is currently sitting at around 33% which includes my mortgage. I have read about debt consolidation loans and it seems like there are a lot of scams out there as well as the companies that are supposed to be paying your debts while you pay them, but they only cause you to have late payments and ruin your credit. We have no late payments and have been snowballing the best we can, but it is taking a toll on us because it is an extremely slow process. I think a personal loan coupled with 0% BT offers may be the way to go for us. I have read about SoFI and have saw credit unions mentioned as possible personal debt consolidation loan possibilities. I'd like to apply for a loan before doing any BTs while my total utilization and debt to income ratios are still in decent shape. We can make payments, but we would like to see the balances reducing instead of being eaten by the high interest cards my wife has. Do any of you know anything about SoFi or any other companies that would possibly lend me the total $44k or really any large sum at a decent rate(15% or less preferably) given my credit scores, utilization rates, and debt to income ratio? I'd rather not involve my wife at all other than using her income to help pay the loan off because of her low scores and very high utilization. We'd also not want to consider a secured loan such as a HELOC if at all possible. We don't want to risk our house. Would a personal debt consolidation loan or a personal line of credit be the best route and if so, which one would you go with? I'm leaning personal loan over line of credit even though the LOC would give flexibility for unexpected house or car repairs while paying down our cc debt. Any feedback on our situation would be greatly appreciated as well as any personal loan leads that any of you have had good experience with. We have done all the cutting back that we can and we have had the tough discussions about how we got here and how to not get back here. We just need some favorable lending to help us. If I left out any pertinent details, please ask.


About three or four years ago, I took out a $20,000 loan at LightStream for 60 months at 6.99%. It's almost paid off now and it has been a really good loan for me.  I love the interest-rate.  I think their loans go up to $100,000, so I would recommend taking a look at their website.  I applied for the loan and the next day it was in my checking account.  It was so easy that I never even talked to anybody at LightStream and still haven't.  I filled it out online and it approved me right after submitting it.

 

I don't blame you for not wanting to take out a loan against your house.  I would not do that myself.  With how things are uncertain lately with the economy and the election coming up, we just never know where we are headed as a nation right now.

 

I would take a look at spreading some of your debt around to any 0% BT cards that you may have opened up so that your utilization looks a little bit lower on certain cards that are high.  Then, I would look at LightStream and if you are satisfied with them, apply for it.  From everything that I've seen about SOFI, it looks like they charge higher rates of interest.  Most likely in the teens or upper teens in some cases.  There are definitely places that charge lower rates of interest for personal loans, but you just have to look for them.  I haven't seen anyone that can compete with LightStream yet though.

 

Another good thing about taking out a personal loan out is that it will lower your utilization on your cards and make your score go up considerably.  That's what happened with my scores at the time.  Please let us know what you decide.  Best of luck to you!

 

We ended up taking a $28k loan with SoFi for 60 months at 11.45%. We then 0% BT approximately $12k for 21 months. That paid off all of our cc debt with the exception of a 0% Rooms To Go promotion that we used earlier this year for new mattresses and my wife's car note that should be paid off within the next 9 months max. I kind of knew SoFi was a higher interest rate than I'd like, but it was super easy and it wiped out all of our high interest cc debt. I just received a new Transunion Fico score yesterday and it went up 30 points to 827 because my cc debt reported. My 0% Citi BT card and the SoFi loan haven’t started reporting yet so I know my score will go back down. I'm just hoping for a soft landing. My wife doesn't have MyFico, but she received an alert yesterday through capital one showing that her score went up 89 points from paying off all the high interest cc debt. Her scores have been very low for a while so we are trying to get hers going in the right direction while paying some of this "new" debt that I have off. The problem that I have is although my credit was good enough to take the loan and BT card out to get rid of all this cc debt, my debt to income ratio is now higher. This will have to be worked on if we ever decide to buy a new house in the future. Hopefully, we will start seeing these balances drop while her credit is improving. That may put us in a pretty good position. I will look into LightStream for possibly lower rates. I wish I could've held off until the rates dropped, but we had to do something. The SoFi loan although at a higher rate than I'd like is still better than any of those cc rates. I appreciate your response.


 

Message 14 of 17
michaelmorgan123
New Visitor

Re: Personal Loans or Personal LOC for Debt Consolidation

You're definitely thinking about this the right way, tackling high-interest CC debt while your credit is still strong gives you more options. A personal loan is usually the cleaner route vs. a LOC if your main goal is consolidation and predictable payments.

 

I’ve seen people have good luck with SoFi, LightStream, and PenFed for larger loan amounts at sub-15% APR with 780+ scores. Credit unions tend to be more flexible on DTI too.

 

Just a heads-up, you can also check marketplaces like Upgrade or BestEgg to prequalify without a hard pull and compare offers side by side. That helped me avoid applying blindly.

Message 15 of 17
Stuart89
New Member

Re: Personal Loans or Personal LOC for Debt Consolidation

Go with whichever gives you the lowest APR and enough money to actually consolidate!

Message 16 of 17
Thomas_Thumb
Senior Contributor

Re: Personal Loans or Personal LOC for Debt Consolidation


@twpounds wrote:

@FicoMike0 wrote:

Looks like a good plan. I would question paying off the car. Often, car loan rates are fairly low. If that's the case, don't trade low rate car debt for higher rate debt, just keep making the payments.

I have went back and forth on that one. The benefit to paying the car off would be it would free up a $600/month payment which is one of our largest payments. The car is a lower rate, but it would also move some of those higher interest balances quicker if I snowballed that $600 payment into our additional payments.

 


 


That makes no sense. The car loan is lower interest rate. You are looking for lower interest rate loans.

 

Keep the car loan and put all the available extra $$ toward high interest debt - no exception. 

Fico 9: .......EQ 850 TU 850 EX 850
Fico 8: .......EQ 850 TU 850 EX 850
Fico 4 .....:. EQ 809 TU 823 EX 830 EX Fico 98: 842
Fico 8 BC:. EQ 892 TU 900 EX 900
Fico 8 AU:. EQ 887 TU 897 EX 899
Fico 4 BC:. EQ 826 TU 858, EX Fico 98 BC: 870
Fico 4 AU:. EQ 831 TU 872, EX Fico 98 AU: 861
VS 3.0:...... EQ 835 TU 835 EX 835
CBIS: ........EQ LN Auto 940 EQ LN Home 870 TU Auto 902 TU Home 950
Message 17 of 17
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.