cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

I NEED EXPERT HELP FROM ANYBODY WITH EXPERIENCE IN THIS

tag
bsal
Frequent Contributor

I NEED EXPERT HELP FROM ANYBODY WITH EXPERIENCE IN THIS

Hey guys I have a serious question at hand, i'm new in trying to rebuild my credit, i'm in the market for a new house and i'm trying to save as much money as posable. I know when they say in having good credit you have to have as many trade-lines open and in good standings as much as posable , i wanted to know would it wise for me to keep my student loan open and continue  paying it monthly witch its only a 900 dollar balance left to show open trade-ins, or can i pay it off in full without having a drop in my credit score, since i only have my car loan on my creidt report showing  as paying on time, i also have a 200 dollar maycs credit card but it has a zero balance cause i dont use it, and i also have a credit overdraft protection from my credit union navy fed. should i keep payin my monthly school loan and keeping that trade line open , or can i pay it off in full and have it not affect my credit score, witch is 698 transunion and 714 equfax . another thing i just got this car loan and i been paying on time since june 09
Message 1 of 11
10 REPLIES 10
BungalowMo
Senior Contributor

Re: I NEED EXPERT HELP FROM ANYBODY WITH EXPERIENCE IN THIS


@bsal wrote:
Hey guys I have a serious question at hand, i'm new in trying to rebuild my credit, i'm in the market for a new house and i'm trying to save as much money as posable. I know when they say in having good credit you have to have as many trade-lines open and in good standings as much as posable , i wanted to know would it wise for me to keep my student loan open and continue  paying it monthly witch its only a 900 dollar balance left to show open trade-ins, or can i pay it off in full without having a drop in my credit score, since i only have my car loan on my creidt report showing  as paying on time, i also have a 200 dollar maycs credit card but it has a zero balance cause i dont use it, and i also have a credit overdraft protection from my credit union navy fed. should i keep payin my monthly school loan and keeping that trade line open , or can i pay it off in full and have it not affect my credit score, witch is 698 transunion and 714 equfax . another thing i just got this car loan and i been paying on time since june 09

If you pay it off, your score will get a bump for having it paid off.  This will remain on your reports for another7 years at minimum, but likely...more like 10+.

 

Paying it off now won't hurt you in the least.  Did you ever have lates??

BK 7 discharge 06.24.2020 No Fico score at all. Smiley Sad
Message 2 of 11
bsal
Frequent Contributor

Re: I NEED EXPERT HELP FROM ANYBODY WITH EXPERIENCE IN THIS

no i never had any lates, but i was thinking if i pay it off in full that would be one less trade line open and isnt that what u need to have great creidt score i'm so confused, i dont have that many trade lines, if i pay it off in full the only trade line that i would have open is my car loan
Message 3 of 11
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: I NEED EXPERT HELP FROM ANYBODY WITH EXPERIENCE IN THIS

Frankly, my impression's always been that a paid installment account, closed in good standing is just as good as an open one. For one thing, that baby'll stay on your CRs for another 10 years, looking beautiful to potential creditors. For another thing (and don't be offended ~ crap happens, yannow?) paying it off NOW means that it's no longer a potential for trouble once you have your home.

Trust me, the last, last, last thing you want is to have to make that measly payment when you have a mortgage and the car needs a new computer chip, or the water heater breaks, etc.

Trust me on this.

Plus, it'll make your DtI (assuming that you still have 10+ months on that loan) prettier. Surely, if you have to deal with a cranky underwriter for your mortgage, being able to say "I paid this off in FULL, EARLY" has to mean SUMPIN. Yannow?
Message 4 of 11
BungalowMo
Senior Contributor

Re: I NEED EXPERT HELP FROM ANYBODY WITH EXPERIENCE IN THIS

Well, I would think that an open CC or "4", in good standing is definitely a positive for your score.  A PIF loan, in good standing is also a good thing.

 

An open loan is not considered the same as an open CC in FICO terms.  In fact, it may even look better if posted as paid early.  For instance, you have a 10k car loan.  Open in June 06 for a term of 4 years.  If you paid that off now, that just shows that you are very responsible and paid this loan 1 year early.  Nothing wrong with paying in the alloted 4, but paid in 3 is better.

 

A cc is an open line....no real "end" to payments.  See what I mean?  But even with a cc, a $0 or <5% balance always looks better than a 75% balance.  Means you use it responsibly, and pay it off in full (or close to it) as you should.  It's never beneficial to your FICO to carry a large balance % on a revolving debt.

 

This obviously does not involve or include any mortgage balances in my loan scenerio....

 

 

*Wonderin beat me to it!!!  Smiley Very Happy

Message Edited by BungalowMo on 07-30-2009 10:16 AM
BK 7 discharge 06.24.2020 No Fico score at all. Smiley Sad
Message 5 of 11
BungalowMo
Senior Contributor

Re: I NEED EXPERT HELP FROM ANYBODY WITH EXPERIENCE IN THIS

Just another quick addition.  If your school loan is with Sallie Mae or the US Dep of ED....Pay it off!  If anything should happen & you miss a payment, they are 99.999999% cold & unforgiving.  Don't invite trouble.

 

Also....what kind of FICO's do you have?  We might be able to make suggestions on a cc that might help your file look a little more diversified.

BK 7 discharge 06.24.2020 No Fico score at all. Smiley Sad
Message 6 of 11
bsal
Frequent Contributor

Re: I NEED EXPERT HELP FROM ANYBODY WITH EXPERIENCE IN THIS

THANKS. GUYS, to bungalomoe and wonderin i really need your advise. but bungalow you asked what my fico looks like? well as of today my transunion score is 698 and my equifax is 718, i dont know what my expriean is myfico no longer has it, i have a 939.00 school loan balance left, i have a 20k car loan from my navy credit union at 476 a month, and i have a 500.00 line of credit with navy fed, overdraft protection, oh yea and i have a 200 limt on my maycs card with a 0 balance and thats it. so if u have any other tips please feel free to fill me in
Message 7 of 11
BungalowMo
Senior Contributor

Re: I NEED EXPERT HELP FROM ANYBODY WITH EXPERIENCE IN THIS

If you're with Navy Fed & have scores like that...get a CC with them!  I've heard lots of good things about them!  And the big plus for you is that you're already established with them & they know your history!

 

You're as good as IN!  Smiley Wink

BK 7 discharge 06.24.2020 No Fico score at all. Smiley Sad
Message 8 of 11
bsal
Frequent Contributor

Re: I NEED EXPERT HELP FROM ANYBODY WITH EXPERIENCE IN THIS

lol my thing is i'm not sure if i really want a creidt card tho, i hear so many stories about people being in cc debt, i dont ever want to be in debt
Message 9 of 11
BungalowMo
Senior Contributor

Re: I NEED EXPERT HELP FROM ANYBODY WITH EXPERIENCE IN THIS


@bsal wrote:
lol my thing is i'm not sure if i really want a creidt card tho, i hear so many stories about people being in cc debt, i dont ever want to be in debt

Just because you have a cc, that doesn't mean you're going to be "in debt".  Use it now & then for a tank of gas, then PIF.  Let it post a $40 balance on the fill up now & then...and then pay it off.

 

It's not the card that gets anyone in debt.  It's how it's utilized.

 

I use a couple of mine for $$ or points.  I get Staples gift cards w/the points & that pays for my printer ink!!!  The other gives me $$ back toward my gas.

 

Make those cards be the slave to YOU!   Not the other way around.

BK 7 discharge 06.24.2020 No Fico score at all. Smiley Sad
Message 10 of 11
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.