cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Does Closing a Credit Card Help or Hurt Credit Score?

tag
Anonymous
Not applicable

Does Closing a Credit Card Help or Hurt Credit Score?

Hi, all:

I recently closed my Target RED Card which I had for 3 years with $300 credit limit.

I just applied and got approved for Barclaycard Arrival World Mastercard. My 1st Barclaycard.

I'm planning to close one of my Capital One credit card and apply for Sallie Mae Mastercard in 6-8 months.

How will this affect my credit?

Thank you!

 

Btw, I'm really glad I found this board.

Message 1 of 28
27 REPLIES 27
slicemans
Regular Contributor

Re: Does Closing a Credit Card Help or Hurt Credit Score?

Message 2 of 28
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Does Closing a Credit Card Help or Hurt Credit Score?


@Anonymous wrote:

Hi, all:

I recently closed my Target RED Card which I had for 3 years with $300 credit limit.

I just applied and got approved for Barclaycard Arrival World Mastercard. My 1st Barclaycard.

I'm planning to close one of my Capital One credit card and apply for Sallie Mae Mastercard in 6-8 months.

How will this affect my credit?

Thank you!

 

Btw, I'm really glad I found this board.


Even if it is closed, it remains on your report for 10 years.  Also, if there is no annual fee, it is good to keep it open.  A number of factors affect your score such AAOA among other things.  With a thin file, it may drop your score temporarily and then bounce back.

Message 3 of 28
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Does Closing a Credit Card Help or Hurt Credit Score?

The link doesn't work. 

Message 4 of 28
CreditMagic7
Mega Contributor

Re: Does Closing a Credit Card Help or Hurt Credit Score?

Welcome To The Forums and Happy First Day In This New Year Smiley Happy

 

You should be just fine. As mentioned IF it happens to affect your score at all it will only be for short time then return even better given better limit approvals entering your credit field.

 

I'm just about to close my own Target RedCard ($500) that i've only had for 2 years (amongst others on the close out list) and have already replaced those type cards with much fairer SL's (starting limits) that DO OFFER cli's with only a SP!

 

Best of luck to you with your credit success and wise choices going forward.

Message 5 of 28
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Does Closing a Credit Card Help or Hurt Credit Score?

Thanks for the advice. I'll keep my capital one around since there is no annual fee. 

But I already closed my Target RED Card. Is this gonna affect my AAOA? 

Message 6 of 28
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Does Closing a Credit Card Help or Hurt Credit Score?

Even if it is closed, it remains on your report for 10 years.  Also, if there is no annual fee, it is good to keep it open.  A number of factors affect your score such AAOA among other things.  With a thin file, it may drop your score temporarily and then bounce back.


I'm sorry but I've never understood this. No matter how many times I see it written around here (and I see it plenty) it still doesn't make sense to me. Why? I had/have a thin file and there was no score drop when I closed any of my three cards. There were small decreases from inquiries and new accounts reporting but scores are still steadily rising and made those drops insignificant. There was actually a 10-15 point increase when Cap One was closed and I took that as myFICO's way of saying, Congrats for dropping the dead weight! Smiley LOL Honestly if the loss of a card isnt causing a spike in utilization I truly dont understand the purpose of keeping a card open solely bc there's no annual fee especially considering this part >>> Even if it is closed, it remains on your report for 10 years. Call me crazy

 

OP I'm sure you'll be fine whatever you decide Smiley Happy

Message 7 of 28
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Does Closing a Credit Card Help or Hurt Credit Score?

Thank you so much. 

Happy New Year to you, too! Smiley Happy

Message 8 of 28
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Does Closing a Credit Card Help or Hurt Credit Score?

Got it. Thanks, again. 

Looks I have a lot reading to do. 

Message 9 of 28
CreditMagic7
Mega Contributor

Re: Does Closing a Credit Card Help or Hurt Credit Score?


 wrote:

Even if it is closed, it remains on your report for 10 years.  Also, if there is no annual fee, it is good to keep it open.  A number of factors affect your score such AAOA among other things.  With a thin file, it may drop your score temporarily and then bounce back.


I'm sorry but I've never understood this. No matter how many times I see it written around here (and I see it plenty) it still doesn't make sense to me. Why? I had/have a thin file and there was no score drop when I closed any of my three cards. There were small decreases from inquiries and new accounts reporting but scores are still steadily rising and made those drops insignificant. There was actually a 10-15 point increase when Cap One was closed and I took that as myFICO's way of saying, Congrats for dropping the dead weight! Smiley LOL Honestly if the loss of a card isnt causing a spike in utilization I truly dont understand the purpose of keeping a card open solely bc there's no annual fee especially considering this part >>> Even if it is closed, it remains on your report for 10 years. Call me crazy

 

OP I'm sure you'll be fine whatever you decide Smiley Happy


That's NOT crazy. More like WISE in my eyes. I couldn't have done any better laying that out as very nice & to the point the way that you done just now HeavenlyFlower .
Kinda sums it up in a nutshell. I feel the same way. The advantages far outweigh the negatives when it comes to letting go of as you say "dead weight!"

Message 10 of 28
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.