No credit card required
Browse credit cards from a variety of issuers to see if there's a better card for you.
I opened an Alliant Credit Union savings account last week and transfered $600. I was contacted by a represenative on Monday who wanted to help however she could. I explained my purpose: a $500 shared secured loan. She said she could help, but it could only be for 12 months. I said okay. She called back shortly and said there was a temporary hold on funds because the account was brand new. It would take three days. I said no problem.
This morning I noticed that the funds were available, so I applied for the loan online. I just prefer to do it that way rather than over the phone. Also, I found I was able to select a longer term, so I selected 48 months. Then I called the represenative to let her know, so that she didn't do any unnecessary work.
She said she could still work the loan. I assumed (perhaps wrongly?) that this meant that someone would have to review it on that end anyway, and it might as well be her. I said thanks, and asked her to contact me via email (as I'm often not in a place where I can talk about such things on my cell phone -- email is more convenient).
A short time later, I got an email from her showing terms for a loan, this time with a 12 month term, and asking me "if this looks good?" She says she'll send (I assume email) "the documents" after my response.
My questions:
1. Does Alliant limit $500 loans to 12 months terms?
2. When you apply for a loan online with Alliant, do you need to fill out an return additional documents? Or is she canceling that applicaiton and initiating a new one (perhaps so she gets credit for it)?
I don't fault her if she's just trying to be helpful, or even if she's hustling to get ahead. But I don't want to sacrifice my preference to do things online using automated means.
Thanks in advance for your help!
Send her this link from their site. You want the 48 month loan secured by savings account. The 12 month loan has no monthly payments and is due at the end. You are not the first person who has had to educate their staff:
https://www.alliantcreditunion.org/borrow/get-a-credit-union-personal-loan#compare
Thanks!
I love this:
"You are not the first person who has had to educate their staff."
That will apply to conversations you will have with customer service reps from many companies over the next 30 years. Get used to it now.
I know I have read of others on here who have gotten share secured loans for longer than 12 months. I believe I have seen 48 months. Maybe they require a larger minimum loan amount than $500? It seems strange.
I would not take 12 month share secured. You want one for the longest possible term and lowest possible amount. $500 for 48 months is ideal.
I believe State Dept FCU also offers these loans, as well as DCU and probably Nasa Fed and Penfed. All of these credit unions can be joined by anyone -- usually by joining some organization for 10 bucks. DCU does do a hard pull for membership, so be aware of that. The rest are soft pulls for membership. You do need to have a clear Chexsystems report.
Also most local credit unions offer these share secured loans. Are there any decent sized CU's in your area? Here in Seattle, BECU does them (I have one for four years).
The interest rate should be no more than 3% or so.
I may call Alliant tomorrow and try to understand why they are telling you something different than the website offers.
I pulled the plug on the loan (I mentioned that in another thread, too). And at this point I feel good about not getting it. I don't have any pressing need for it, so I think I'm probably just as well off not messing around with (just to try to squeeze a few more points out of my FICO scores).
Thanks so much for your help, CH-7-Rebuilding!
@CH-7-Mission-Accomplished wrote:I know I have read of others on here who have gotten share secured loans for longer than 12 months. I believe I have seen 48 months. Maybe they require a larger minimum loan amount than $500? It seems strange.
I would not take 12 month share secured. You want one for the longest possible term and lowest possible amount. $500 for 48 months is ideal.
I believe State Dept FCU also offers these loans, as well as DCU and probably Nasa Fed and Penfed. All of these credit unions can be joined by anyone -- usually by joining some organization for 10 bucks. DCU does do a hard pull for membership, so be aware of that. The rest are soft pulls for membership. You do need to have a clear Chexsystems report.
Also most local credit unions offer these share secured loans. Are there any decent sized CU's in your area? Here in Seattle, BECU does them (I have one for four years).
The interest rate should be no more than 3% or so.
I may call Alliant tomorrow and try to understand why they are telling you something different than the website offers.
Cool! I didn't know that.
Just in case anyone finds this thread, I just opened the loan and they gave me the option for anywhere up to 60 months. I went with 48 and $500. I applied for it online and I opened the accounted yesterday and got the loan today. I did have to sign some documents with it.
@JBjunior wrote:Just in case anyone finds this thread, I just opened the loan and they gave me the option for anywhere up to 60 months. I went with 48 and $500. I applied for it online and I opened the accounted yesterday and got the loan today. I did have to sign some documents with it.
I'm glad to hear this. I am thinking there was some kind of miscommunication between OP and Alliant.
@CH-7-Mission-Accomplished wrote:I'm glad to hear this. I am thinking there was some kind of miscommunication between OP and Alliant.
As the OP, I'm thinking the same thing! I tried to get her to understand what loan I was looking for. I sent her the link to their site that you gave me. I told her which loan in which column on the table on the site.
I suspect she got the wrong loan product plugged into her software and then couldn't make it do what I was asking her to do. So she kept insisting it couldn't be done. Oh well, probably just as well.