cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

New Tesla Model 3: NFCU v. Tesla Finance

tag
ridgebackpilot
Established Contributor

New Tesla Model 3: NFCU v. Tesla Finance

This week, I ordered a new 2020 Tesla Model 3 Long Range AWD from existing inventory. NFCU offered me $52K @3.99% for 72 months. Tesla Financial shopped around but was only able to offer $52K @4.69% through TD Auto Finance, LLC.

 

Having heard nothing good about TD Auto Finance, I opted to go for the lower rate with Navy. TD Auto Finance pulled TU and Navy pulled EQ, although in each case I'm not certain which FICO scores they use.

 

Navy also offered GAP insurance for $299, paid over the life of the loan, which I accepted. That's about what I would have paid to Gap Direct, but they require the entire premium up front.

 

FICO Auto 8: EQ 718; TU 714; EX 706

FICO Auto 9: EQ 737; TU 706; EX 699

7 REPLIES 7
Gmood1
Super Contributor

Re: New Tesla Model 3: NFCU v. Tesla Finance

Not a bad deal. But certainly not the best interest rates available.

Congrats on your new Tesla!

 

Thanks for the DPs.

Message 2 of 8
AllZero
Mega Contributor

Re: New Tesla Model 3: NFCU v. Tesla Finance

Congratulations on your approval and new Tesla!
Message 3 of 8
ridgebackpilot
Established Contributor

Re: New Tesla Model 3: NFCU v. Tesla Finance


@Gmood1 wrote:

Not a bad deal. But certainly not the best interest rates available.

Congrats on your new Tesla!

 

Thanks for the DPs.


Not sure why I wasn't able to get Navy's best rate. There are two possible causes: First, lenders are tightening qualification policies for auto loans during the pandemic. And, BMW is in the process of buying back one of my cars under California's lemon law. But that loan is still showing on my reports for now. So it looks as if I'm adding a car when actually I'm just replacing an existing one.

 

The Navy CSR told me I could always refinance with them in a year to get their best rate.

 

Message 4 of 8
Gmood1
Super Contributor

Re: New Tesla Model 3: NFCU v. Tesla Finance

@ridgebackpilot 

Yeah, I've noticed Navy can be a bit wishy washy on those rates. 

Even with good credit, they aren't giving the best rates they offer.

 

Family member went with some one else because of it. His last vehicle was financed with Navy.

 

Penfed has jacked their rates up as well. Head scratcher for me, as they used to beat Navy in auto loan rates pretty easily.

 

I've been looking a lot at rates lately. Thinking of buying another vehicle in the coming months.

 

Navy displays good rates, but doesn't look like they give them out too often.

 

Nephew financed a used 2018 Honda Accord through AOD and still got 2.39% for 72 months.

Rates went up a 10th of a point this month. But they are still really good.

 

So far in my search. The lowest rates I've found on a used vehicle loans are through AOD or Redstone federal credit union.

 

Surprisingly, Cap ones aren't too shabby either. Some are in the 2% range.

 

Places like US bank and BBVA have lost their minds offering 5% rates on new vehicles to prime credit customers!😂

 

Just a 1.5% decrease on your loan would save you around $3000!

Message 5 of 8
Brian_Earl_Spilner
Credit Mentor

Re: New Tesla Model 3: NFCU v. Tesla Finance

Congrats!

 

Maybe that's what they're capping at right now? Navy offered me the same rate on 72 mos and my score is 51 points lower. Don't remember my internal.

    
Message 6 of 8
Thenutisout81
Established Member

Re: New Tesla Model 3: NFCU v. Tesla Finance

I recently got Tesla Financing also. I first applied at Navy the best they would give me was 6.49 then I went to Alliant they also said 6.49 and the for the hell of it I tried PenFed they offered 2.99 for 72 months or 4.49 for 84 and I was not a member of PenFed or Alliant when I applied. When they pull my  FICO9 it was between 740 to 750. 

Message 7 of 8
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: New Tesla Model 3: NFCU v. Tesla Finance

So does Alliant and Pedfed use Fico auto score 9? or 8?

Message 8 of 8
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.