cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Score drop for not having an auto loan?

tag
masscredit
Senior Contributor

Score drop for not having an auto loan?

My car was recently damaged in an accident, possibly totaled. If that is the case, I might use a friend's car while I decide what I'm going to do. I want to buy what I want and not have to rush into making a purchase because I need a car. I know FICO scores like to see a mix of credit cards and loans. What kind of a hit might I take for not having an auto loan?  My current score is good enough for the best rate and I'm concerned about jepordizing that by not having a loan. 

EQ - 693 / TU - 664 / EX - 675

Capital One Savor - $16000 / Capital One Venture - $13000 / Travel Advantage Visa - $13000 /Bread Rewards AMEX - $8450 / TD Cash Card - $7500 / Apple Card - $6500 / TD Double Up - $5500 / Mercury - $5000 / Ally Master Card - $4300 / DCU Visa - $3000 / Capital One QuickSilver - $500
$82,750
DCU Auto Loan
Message 1 of 9
8 REPLIES 8
pizzadude
Credit Mentor

Re: Score drop for not having an auto loan?


@masscredit wrote:

My car was recently damaged in an accident, possibly totaled. If that is the case, I might use a friend's car while I decide what I'm going to do. I want to buy what I want and not have to rush into making a purchase because I need a car. I know FICO scores like to see a mix of credit cards and loans. What kind of a hit might I take for not having an auto loan?  My current score is good enough for the best rate and I'm concerned about jepordizing that by not having a loan. 


Do you have any other open installment loans?   We've noticed a few people take a hit on the FICO08 score model if their only installment loan closes.

March2010 FICO® ~ 695 TU, 653 EQ, 697 EX
Message 2 of 9
masscredit
Senior Contributor

Re: Score drop for not having an auto loan?

The auto loan is my only one.  Credit card utilization is in the .001-1 range. Have been playing with that to see if I can gain a few points. I finance with DCU and would do that with the next loan. 

EQ - 693 / TU - 664 / EX - 675

Capital One Savor - $16000 / Capital One Venture - $13000 / Travel Advantage Visa - $13000 /Bread Rewards AMEX - $8450 / TD Cash Card - $7500 / Apple Card - $6500 / TD Double Up - $5500 / Mercury - $5000 / Ally Master Card - $4300 / DCU Visa - $3000 / Capital One QuickSilver - $500
$82,750
DCU Auto Loan
Message 3 of 9
pizzadude
Credit Mentor

Re: Score drop for not having an auto loan?


@masscredit wrote:

The auto loan is my only one.  Credit card utilization is in the .001-1 range. Have been playing with that to see if I can gain a few points. I finance with DCU and would do that with the next loan. 


Has the loan reported as closed yet?  You could go ahead and apply with DCU and they might pull your credit before that happens.

March2010 FICO® ~ 695 TU, 653 EQ, 697 EX
Message 4 of 9
masscredit
Senior Contributor

Re: Score drop for not having an auto loan?

That's a good idea. The accident just happened so I'm just starting the process. If the car is going to be totaled, I could get pre-approved around the time that it's paid off. I believe that approval might be good for about 30 days. 

EQ - 693 / TU - 664 / EX - 675

Capital One Savor - $16000 / Capital One Venture - $13000 / Travel Advantage Visa - $13000 /Bread Rewards AMEX - $8450 / TD Cash Card - $7500 / Apple Card - $6500 / TD Double Up - $5500 / Mercury - $5000 / Ally Master Card - $4300 / DCU Visa - $3000 / Capital One QuickSilver - $500
$82,750
DCU Auto Loan
Message 5 of 9
pizzadude
Credit Mentor

Re: Score drop for not having an auto loan?


@masscredit wrote:

That's a good idea. The accident just happened so I'm just starting the process. If the car is going to be totaled, I could get pre-approved around the time that it's paid off. I believe that approval might be good for about 30 days. 


Yep, I think most lenders will give you at least a month to find a car so hopefully there won't be any impact.

March2010 FICO® ~ 695 TU, 653 EQ, 697 EX
Message 6 of 9
yepbob
New Contributor

Re: Score drop for not having an auto loan?

I just refi'd my auto loan so my loan through GM reported as paid off today - new refi loan. It reporting yet - and I lost 21 points on myFico and that was the only alert and my only installment loan reporting. I'm hoping I gain those points back when my new loan reports...
Fico Scores as of 1/6/2014 from MyFICO
EX FICO - 649 / EQ FICO - 616 / TU FICO - 649
Lender pull 4/1/2014- EX-664 / TU - 675 / EQ - 626

Kohls - $300 Credit One - $600 WM - $700 Sams - $500
Amazon $600 PayPal MC - $300 NFCU $1000 Cap 1 - $2500
Cap 1 Plat: $2000 Von Maur - no limit set NFCU Nav Check - $10k
Message 7 of 9
pizzadude
Credit Mentor

Re: Score drop for not having an auto loan?


@yepbob wrote:
I just refi'd my auto loan so my loan through GM reported as paid off today - new refi loan. It reporting yet - and I lost 21 points on myFico and that was the only alert and my only installment loan reporting. I'm hoping I gain those points back when my new loan reports...

Hopefully you'll get them back.  We've noticed several people reporting FICO08 scoring hits when their only installment loan closes.

March2010 FICO® ~ 695 TU, 653 EQ, 697 EX
Message 8 of 9
masscredit
Senior Contributor

Re: Score drop for not having an auto loan?

I was just thinking, if it's going to take me longer than a month to figure out what I'm going to do then find or order a car, I could take out a small personal loan then pay it off when I'm ready to get another auto loan. 

EQ - 693 / TU - 664 / EX - 675

Capital One Savor - $16000 / Capital One Venture - $13000 / Travel Advantage Visa - $13000 /Bread Rewards AMEX - $8450 / TD Cash Card - $7500 / Apple Card - $6500 / TD Double Up - $5500 / Mercury - $5000 / Ally Master Card - $4300 / DCU Visa - $3000 / Capital One QuickSilver - $500
$82,750
DCU Auto Loan
Message 9 of 9
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.