cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

CHASE denies me then approves me for something else? Please give me some insight...?

tag
ACTonic
New Member

CHASE denies me then approves me for something else? Please give me some insight...?

Hi folks,

 

I've been perusing the forums here and there over the last few months, and you guys are so knowledgeable and great, I now have an issue I need to put out there and ask for some insight on/get some advice for...

 

I have not so perfect credit, and have been working on it with focus over the last year. I use CreditKarma, etc, to realluy stay on it. The biggest detriment to my score right now is two collection accounts that are closed but are being paid as agreed (until paid off), and all of my current accounts are current, but are carrying fairly high balances. My utilization is high, admittedly. About 85%. Yes I know that's bad... but I'm working on it!

 

That all said, I have really been wanting the CHASE Amazon Prime Visa for a long time, and I thought since I had a [slowly] climbing score, 0 inquiries on record, and things were being paid and maintained, plus I have a solid income of about $59k/year, that I might as well roll the dice and apply. Of course, based on my two old bad accounts, and the high utilization, I was denied the card. I called recon to explain specifics, hoping for some mercy. Even with a low limit, I really want the card itself, so I explain I don't need or even necessarily want extra credit, just want the account. I even had two exisiting cards with them, the Slate ($500 limit, $0 balance, 2 yrs old) and the Freedom Unlimited ($1000 limit, $800 balance, 2 yrs old). I suggested moving my available CHASE credit to the Amazon card, but the recon rep said they cannot approve any new accounts for me at this time. He said it was final, and I left it alone.

 

Fast forward a week, and when going onto my CHASE online banking, I see a green-checked, "selected for you" offer on the CHASE Sapphire Preferred. It was offering a good, specific interest rate (good for me anyway, better than any of my other CC's), and all it asked for was my annual income and phone number. I figured hey what the hell, and I was INSTANTLY approved, for a $5000 credit line! I'm in shock.

 

Why would CHASE deny me the Amazon Prime Visa, recon tell me that decision is final and my profile cannot allow it right now, but then a week later they give me my biggest credit line yet on a different card? This is very odd to me so maybe you can share some insight? Is it a fluke and I should just count my blessings and treat this card well and be happy? Can I/should I rock the boat by calling recon back and telling them to please give me the Amazon card instead? Or is that a bad idea where they might see this automatic approval I just got and then take it back from me?

 

Thanks in advance for any light you can shed on this for me, and for reading this absurdly long post. I just wanted ot share all the details. Smiley Happy

21 REPLIES 21
pinkandgrey
Senior Contributor

Re: CHASE denies me then approves me for something else? Please give me some insight...?

If there’s one credit-related thing we know for sure, it’s that Chase is an odd duck. But congrats! Enjoy that beautiful card! It’s a favorite around these here parts. 

 

It is strange, though, seeing as the CSP is the better of the 2 cards.... I would just be happy and not poke that giant Chase bear 

Discover It: 26.5k
Amex Cash Magnet: 24.4k
Fidelity Visa: 21.5k
Apple Card: 13k
Message 2 of 22
AverageJoesCredit
Legendary Contributor

Re: CHASE denies me then approves me for something else? Please give me some insight...?

Never look a gift Chase in the mouthSmiley Wink
Message 3 of 22
Pikaboo-icu
Valued Contributor

Re: CHASE denies me then approves me for something else? Please give me some insight...?

Welcome to My Fico 000welcome17.gif

 

Congrats.. ?? AAshrugs.gif

 

Is it possible you had a score bump in that week? 

  


Message 4 of 22
FinStar
Moderator Emeritus

Re: CHASE denies me then approves me for something else? Please give me some insight...?

@AverageJoesCredit literally took the words out of my mouth. No pun intended 😄

OP, Chase is not going to be able to switch the CC. Sorry, no crossovers. Potentially, you met their internal criteria to pre-qualify for the CSP and there you have it. Plus, there's different UW criteria for a variety of their CCs so that will remain a mystery.

So, in short, don't look at a gift horse in the mouth and enioy your new CSP.
Message 5 of 22
Meanmchine
Super Contributor

Re: CHASE denies me then approves me for something else? Please give me some insight...?

I would keep the CSP card.

You could always get the Synchrony Amazon store card. I have it and it rocks

>3/2016 EX 644 CK-TU 642 CK-EQ 660 WalMart- 671.
>7/2025 All 3 reports 830 - 845(F8) F9s = all 850 but my app finger is still twitching
Message 6 of 22
Pikaboo-icu
Valued Contributor

Re: CHASE denies me then approves me for something else? Please give me some insight...?


@Meanmchine wrote:

I would keep the CSP card.

You could always get the Synchrony Amazon store card. I have it and it rocks


I agree nodding.gif  Yep, I agree.. I have the Synch Amazon card.. Love it!! Except Amazon just charged me $128. to renew my Prime.

Yikes! Holy Price Hike Batman! Batman.gif

  


Message 7 of 22
ACTonic
New Member

Re: CHASE denies me then approves me for something else? Please give me some insight...?

Thank you very much everyone! I really appreciate it, and I will treat my new CSP card well. Smiley Happy

Message 8 of 22
Meanmchine
Super Contributor

Re: CHASE denies me then approves me for something else? Please give me some insight...?


@Pikaboo-icu wrote:

@Meanmchine wrote:

I would keep the CSP card.

You could always get the Synchrony Amazon store card. I have it and it rocks


I agree nodding.gif  Yep, I agree.. I have the Synch Amazon card.. Love it!! Except Amazon just charged me $128. to renew my Prime.

Yikes! Holy Price Hike Batman! Batman.gif


I didnt know they raised their membership Smiley Sad

And mine is due to renew on March 1

 

>3/2016 EX 644 CK-TU 642 CK-EQ 660 WalMart- 671.
>7/2025 All 3 reports 830 - 845(F8) F9s = all 850 but my app finger is still twitching
Message 9 of 22
CramEiko
Established Contributor

Re: CHASE denies me then approves me for something else? Please give me some insight...?


@Pikaboo-icu wrote:

@Meanmchine wrote:

I would keep the CSP card.

You could always get the Synchrony Amazon store card. I have it and it rocks


I agree nodding.gif  Yep, I agree.. I have the Synch Amazon card.. Love it!! Except Amazon just charged me $128. to renew my Prime.

Yikes! Holy Price Hike Batman! Batman.gif


 

Really? Dang, Prime just went from $99 to $120 just last year too....





Updated Feb 2023:
Citi Double Cash: $26,300
Citi Costco: $33,800
PenFed Power Cash: $50,000
Chase Freedom Unlimited: $33,400
NFCU Cash Rewards: $29,000
BoA Unlimited Cash: $99,900
Wells Fargo Active Cash: $50,000
Citi AAdvantage Executive: $30,500
Wells Fargo Mortgage 30yr fixed 3.625%

Business Cards:
BoA Business Advantage Unlimited Cash: $8,000
Chase Ink Business Unlimited: $75,000
Chase Ink Business Unlimited: $75,000

RIP: EECU PLOC | BBVA PLOC | Chase SP | Chase Amazon | Chase Freedom | WF Propel | Cap1 QS | AMEX Gold | BoA Custom Cash | Lowes | Barclays Aviator Red
Message 10 of 22
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.