cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Citi Secured or NFCU nRewards Secured? Or both?

tag
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Citi Secured or NFCU nRewards Secured? Or both?


@Anonymous wrote:


  

I definitely concur re: everyone being helpful.  I've been reading these boards nonstop!  I have been dreaming about good credit the last few nights, lol.  I think it's going to be my new obsession, like a game...to see how high I can go and how fast.  I know it's a marathon and not a sprint, but I want to knock off as much as I can and just watch the results happen.  I'm 37 and I look forward to having near-perfect credit by the time I'm 40!


yeah, that was my internal goal as well.  but i'm less than 6 months to 40 so not sure if i can hit 800 by then, but i'm still trying lol    like all the guru's say..  visualize and achieve  

Message 21 of 39
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Citi Secured or NFCU nRewards Secured? Or both?


@Anonymous wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:


  

I definitely concur re: everyone being helpful.  I've been reading these boards nonstop!  I have been dreaming about good credit the last few nights, lol.  I think it's going to be my new obsession, like a game...to see how high I can go and how fast.  I know it's a marathon and not a sprint, but I want to knock off as much as I can and just watch the results happen.  I'm 37 and I look forward to having near-perfect credit by the time I'm 40!


yeah, that was my internal goal as well.  but i'm less than 6 months to 40 so not sure if i can hit 800 by then, but i'm still trying lol    like all the guru's say..  visualize and achieve  


Keep pushing and I'm sure you'll see 800 in your 40th year, if not BY 40, definitely shortly thereafter!

Message 22 of 39
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Citi Secured or NFCU nRewards Secured? Or both?

After rereading some of your info on this thread

1) I'm not quite sure of the age of the CCs but things feel relatively young

It appears you're chopping at the bit to get it done ( unneeded Self-Lender loan...but it's means you're trying hard) you're zealous, which is cool but you don't need to over think or jump at "everything"

Just calm it down, pump the brakes, no need to over stress yourself with all these to do

Before I forget to address it NO you don't have to fall for the put THOUSANDS in a secured account they'll be forced to match it at unsecurity time.
a) Not necessary
b) Not true

All this 'loan good' "prettier" lender crap is just that shuttle bucket crap

( As many will tell you lenders like NFCU have been known to give mind blowing SL no matter what, so this nonsense about stuffing a huge amount in security to ensure a huge SL is very over stated)
Frankly a lot of that also comes from ppl not understanding how to use a builder TL ( you "get" it) the only purpose IMO ( and I see you agree, by your plan of usage) is to build some history over time and show great utilization, until the score is stroked and some grass (history) has grown...but too often ppl 5k into these accounts with the thought pattern of turning a bunch of spend though with the idea that the lender will reward them with a huge CL 'because' of the fees made of exchange fees from vendor purchases...way over thinking it

a) Lenders don't score credit, the scoring model does
So IMO feed the girl that controls the score...meaning give the model what SHE is looking for and SHE doesn't give a crap about SIZE ( really, it's true in this case😀)
She's evaluating the % of debt to the CL, what that CL is 9% is 9% that's all she cares about $500 card, $2000 card, $5000 card she looking for the 9...9% that is

On-time payments are a given, we all know and expect that 35% of the score, the SWING issue is #2 & #3

Utilization 30% and Aging/Length 15%

We can manipulate the utilization but we can't rush TIME
This is where the ants in pants gets us moving in too many directions....just water your garden properly and let the Sun do its thing OP☺

You done good, so far let #3 (aging) work it's magic FOR you... I like to tell ppl 8-10 is about a school year, just perform properly for about a school year and you'll be amazed at the results

( Some will say 6 months but because of reporting times and varying updates etc...I like to allow a bit of room + at 10 months, we near the old HPs aging out if negative effect and said accounts are nearing the 1 year mark)

The waiting seems long but in the scheme of things it's minimal, especially considering what working from a position of a more mature, thicker profile can be so HUGE just in a matter of months ...just my take on where my experience has pulled me after all these years...
Message 23 of 39
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Citi Secured or NFCU nRewards Secured? Or both?

One last thing
If and when you do app Navy don't forget to gave them look into a refi of that auto loan ( CUs love TAKING a lot of business as they open relationships)

Remember that the HP for the auto may as well be double up to request a CLOC ( same pull, same department no harm, no foul to ask at that point)
Didn't want to forget 😉

* The CC and auto/CLOC will be separate pulls I'm just saying double up on the auto loan and let them feel like they're your new best girl and she might respond real nicely 😎
Message 24 of 39
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Citi Secured or NFCU nRewards Secured? Or both?


@Anonymous wrote:
After rereading some of your info on this thread

1) I'm not quite sure of the age of the CCs but things feel relatively young

It appears you're chopping at the bit to get it done ( unneeded Self-Lender loan...but it's means you're trying hard) you're zealous, which is cool but you don't need to over think or jump at "everything"

Just calm it down, pump the brakes, no need to over stress yourself with all these to do

Before I forget to address it NO you don't have to fall for the put THOUSANDS in a secured account they'll be forced to match it at unsecurity time.
a) Not necessary
b) Not true

All this 'loan good' "prettier" lender crap is just that shuttle bucket crap

( As many will tell you lenders like NFCU have been known to give mind blowing SL no matter what, so this nonsense about stuffing a huge amount in security to ensure a huge SL is very over stated)
Frankly a lot of that also comes from ppl not understanding how to use a builder TL ( you "get" it) the only purpose IMO ( and I see you agree, by your plan of usage) is to build some history over time and show great utilization, until the score is stroked and some grass (history) has grown...but too often ppl 5k into these accounts with the thought pattern of turning a bunch of spend though with the idea that the lender will reward them with a huge CL 'because' of the fees made of exchange fees from vendor purchases...way over thinking it

a) Lenders don't score credit, the scoring model does
So IMO feed the girl that controls the score...meaning give the model what SHE is looking for and SHE doesn't give a crap about SIZE ( really, it's true in this case😀)
She's evaluating the % of debt to the CL, what that CL is 9% is 9% that's all she cares about $500 card, $2000 card, $5000 card she looking for the 9...9% that is

On-time payments are a given, we all know and expect that 35% of the score, the SWING issue is #2 & #3

Utilization 30% and Aging/Length 15%

We can manipulate the utilization but we can't rush TIME
This is where the ants in pants gets us moving in too many directions....just water your garden properly and let the Sun do its thing OP☺

You done good, so far let #3 (aging) work it's magic FOR you... I like to tell ppl 8-10 is about a school year, just perform properly for about a school year and you'll be amazed at the results

( Some will say 6 months but because of reporting times and varying updates etc...I like to allow a bit of room + at 10 months, we near the old HPs aging out if negative effect and said accounts are nearing the 1 year mark)

The waiting seems long but in the scheme of things it's minimal, especially considering what working from a position of a more mature, thicker profile can be so HUGE just in a matter of months ...just my take on where my experience has pulled me after all these years...

Great info!  Thank you.  You hit the nail on the head, "Chomping at the bit" is the perfect way to describe how I feel.  It's like when you've been unhealthy for a long time and you get a fire lit under you to get healthy and all you want to do is OD on wheatgrass and yoga and spinning and detox and HIIT and sign up for marathons and on and on and on, lol.  That's how I currently feel about my credit.  Coupled with the fact that my disposable income is so high for at least the next year, I feel like I want to get everything done right now, so that in the next year or so, when my expenses are higher, I will be in a much better financial position.  

 

Breathe, stretch, shake...LOL

Message 25 of 39
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Citi Secured or NFCU nRewards Secured? Or both?


@Anonymous wrote:
One last thing
If and when you do app Navy don't forget to gave them look into a refi of that auto loan ( CUs love TAKING a lot of business as they open relationships)

Remember that the HP for the auto may as well be double up to request a CLOC ( same pull, same department no harm, no foul to ask at that point)
Didn't want to forget 😉

* The CC and auto/CLOC will be separate pulls I'm just saying double up on the auto loan and let them feel like they're your new best girl and she might respond real nicely 😎

Yes, the refi is definitely on my radar as well, even though my goal was to pay down my loan and hopefully pay it off within 18 months.  I'm being SUPER aggressive in all areas.  I am going to give it 6 months of regular history and then attempt to refi at the beginning of the year.  Sound like a good plan? 

Message 26 of 39
joltdude
Senior Contributor

Re: Citi Secured or NFCU nRewards Secured? Or both?

Id say Join the Navy and Ditch the Sky.....

But id work on dropping that util a bit....

 

Id let things marinate for a month or two. and see if Navy suggests a car loan .... then id think of trying for a refi.. =)

 

Im different in that id still be tempted to get a Citi secured as well... but you dont have to put a lot into it.. just have to pay it in full.....

 

Just my .02cents.. YCMV

 

-J

 

Message 27 of 39
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Citi Secured or NFCU nRewards Secured? Or both?

@Joltdude makes a good point, since @ DoBetterSis says she has the income to dispose... Disposing a few bucks securing the Citi secured isn't gonna "hurt" and it opens that relationship....falls into the why the heck not, let it age with the rest of 'em category

Again she has the cash to splash and the gong ho go get 'em motion right now.....I'm so used to ppl counting pennies to rebuild that you start to get over protective of OPM but she says the cash is there and again Citi isn't just some bull crap company, I'd be cool with adding them to the squad
Message 28 of 39
Meanmchine
Super Contributor

Re: Citi Secured or NFCU nRewards Secured? Or both?

I vote for Citi.

Im a non-conformist

>3/2016 EX 644 CK-TU 642 CK-EQ 660 WalMart- 671.
>7/2025 All 3 reports 830 - 845(F8) F9s = all 850 but my app finger is still twitching
Message 29 of 39
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Citi Secured or NFCU nRewards Secured? Or both?

So far Navy has refused to give my husband and me ANYTHING, So we have 4-6 HP each in the last three month just from them with absolutely nothing to show for it. There is something they don't like about us but their denial letters are too generic for us to figure out what. They do five generous limits to some with lower scores, but certainly not us.
Message 30 of 39
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.