Mine will be 20 in December, so I say this with love
The moment I read " She wants, she doesn't want"
the caution flag HAS to go up
We want our kids to get off to great starts but the maturity level and understanding that this is ADULT life has to be addressed SERIOUSLY.
I had this same type issue when it became car time...
I want... I prefer...
Ok BRUTALLY honest, big girl talk time
I don't give a ish about the color or how 'cute' a lights are the REALITY is there is some REAL ish that YOU gotta be aware of and are going to pay attention to like it or not
Unwanted ish like registration and tags and maintenance and insurance...it can NOT matter what she WANTS this is a LIFE SKILL and responsibility to learn and master, period.
My daughter said 'Do I really "need" more than one'
Yep because we're building for the future, laying a foundation don't let her whim rob her of what you know will serve her well later
We = parent
They = inexperience
They have all the answers as to WHY to do it this way vs that....based on WHAT
Gotta learn sometime, baby step her now
Before she WANTS cards
My daughter said the same thing
But you KNOW she's better off with a mature,solid profile when does go house shopping 8 years from now vs some stupid Victoria Secret decision debate today
Grab the Captain's hat and lead your baby ( Daddy ain't an easy job and we take arrows from time to time but they didn't call it Father knows Best for nothing 😊)
Seriously
If you go the secured route ( I know, folks a Re-reading but new to others)
Grab the SSL 1st then use those same funds to secure a CC thus doubling up on the use of funds if you start with the secured CC the money stops moving with move 1
The reason for the SSL is it adds credit mix to the profile for additional points and will also pay dividends as the 1st car loan/home loan won't be a 1st installer
Again the SSL along with the secured CC or better 2 and one or two AU accounts from Mom/Dad and baby girl is cooking with grease.
The last reason I like the SSL is it can be used as a credit & savings TRAINING ground ( with safety net, of course) for our new young adult
The SSL will generate a token payment which can be paid using the secured or other CC showing a token usage all the while building and puffing a credit profile for our young person
Example deposit $600 in the CU borrow $500
As the payments get made to hold amount decreases and the available amount increases ....thus the payment is never in jeopardy of NOT being paid credit report wise
But by putting the young adult in charge of this video game gives them a monthly 'chore' responsibility that will serve them and your grandchildren well in life.
If they have a job have them pay/save $10-12/wk ($40-50/mo) 10-15-20 months in a row
Again the goal is building skill and good habits and by doing so the kid will build a little emergency fund and if they have hiccups there's no real harm done and discussion can be had w/o real life jeopardy
Hopefully the exercise normalizes the monthly management that has to be addressed no matter what, at least this way credit is being built vs just a few years passing w/o history being built
Why waste 18-24 use it
Good luck