cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Help! Not sure which card to apply for!

tag
Anonymous
Not applicable

Help! Not sure which card to apply for!

I'm in the market for a new credit card and am unsure of which to apply for.  My goal is to get a high SL.  From what I've read here, Venture seems to be the best card for that, but I do not want to get hit with 3 HPs, especially since I am about to take on (my first!) mortgage loan.  Don't know if that might potentially raise a red flag.  FICO 8 Scores are 695 TU/698 EQ/695 EX with 10% utilization and about $55k in available credit.  I've also been considering BofA Travel Rewards - only because I currently have a Cash Rewards card (which I actually just converted over to from a Travel Rewards card) - I started at 3k in 2013 and in the past 8 months got 3 CLIs to 22.9k.  BofA has been really, really good to me and I'm wondering if the SL would be comparable to Venture.

 

Which of these two cards would be the better choice?  Or, are there any others I should consider?  Would love some input from all the experts here Smiley Happy

 

Message 1 of 15
14 REPLIES 14
DeeBee78
Valued Contributor

Re: Help! Not sure which card to apply for!


@Anonymous wrote:

I'm in the market for a new credit card and am unsure of which to apply for.  My goal is to get a high SL.  From what I've read here, Venture seems to be the best card for that, but I do not want to get hit with 3 HPs, especially since I am about to take on (my first!) mortgage loan.  Don't know if that might potentially raise a red flag.  FICO 8 Scores are 695 TU/698 EQ/695 EX with 10% utilization and about $55k in available credit.  I've also been considering BofA Travel Rewards - only because I currently have a Cash Rewards card (which I actually just converted over to from a Travel Rewards card) - I started at 3k in 2013 and in the past 8 months got 3 CLIs to 22.9k.  BofA has been really, really good to me and I'm wondering if the SL would be comparable to Venture.

 

Which of these two cards would be the better choice?  Or, are there any others I should consider?  Would love some input from all the experts here Smiley Happy

 


Absolutely nothing, until your mortgage has closed!

 

It would help if you listed all your current cards. 

Message 2 of 15
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Help! Not sure which card to apply for!

Lol! That'd probably be wise Smiley LOL

 

Here's what I have at the moment:

 

QS - $8650 (combined two cards a few months ago)

BofA Cash Rewards - $22.9k

Citi Prestige - $4250

Citi DC - $2600

Chase Freedom Unlimited - $3000

USBank Flex Perks - $2000

Amex Everyday - $3000

Discover - $1600

Amex Green Card AU - $3000 (primary user got hit with a financial review 5 years ago and Amex will not budge!)

Chase Freedom Unlimited AU - $3000

Wayfair Card - $4600

Neiman Marcus Card - $10.5k

Macy's Store Card - $6500

TJX Rewards Store Card - $2400

Message 3 of 15
DeeBee78
Valued Contributor

Re: Help! Not sure which card to apply for!


@Anonymous wrote:

Lol! That'd probably be wise Smiley LOL

 

Here's what I have at the moment:

 

QS - $8650 (combined two cards a few months ago)

BofA Cash Rewards - $22.9k

Citi Prestige - $4250

Citi DC - $2600

Chase Freedom Unlimited - $3000

USBank Flex Perks - $2000

Amex Everyday - $3000

Discover - $1600

Amex Green Card AU - $3000 (primary user got hit with a financial review 5 years ago and Amex will not budge!)

Chase Freedom Unlimited AU - $3000

Wayfair Card - $4600

Neiman Marcus Card - $10.5k

Macy's Store Card - $6500

TJX Rewards Store Card - $2400


I would suggest growing your current limits versus cold-apping in hopes of getting a crazy SL out of the gate. You have several cards that grow easily with SP CLI's:

 

US bank - Ask for $1,500 every few months, and it will most likely be a SP. 

Citi- SP every 6 months, sometimes more frequently, almost guaranteed. 

Capital One - SP every 6 months with regular usage and large payments. 

Amex - 61 day initial 3x CLI. 3X every 6 months after that. 

Discover - Can ask any time, but most people see regular SP increases every 60 or 90 days. Can grow into a monster limit in less than a year. 

 

Once you you start getting these limits above $10K, and your income can support it, the $20 and $30K big boy limits come quickly, as you've seen with BoA. I would suggest you wait until your mortgage has closed before requesting CLI's though. Your lender looks at all your lines of credit, and might ask you to close some cards if they think your risk is too high. 

Message 4 of 15
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Help! Not sure which card to apply for!

I have actually gotten CLIs for all those cards within the past month, apart from US Bank - they denied my request stating my account was too new (opened last July).  I suppose it would be smarter to wait another 6 months or so until I can request more CLIs.  But I'm really itching for a new card!! Smiley Embarassed

Message 5 of 15
DeeBee78
Valued Contributor

Re: Help! Not sure which card to apply for!


@Anonymous wrote:

I have actually gotten CLIs for all those cards within the past month, apart from US Bank - they denied my request stating my account was too new (opened last July).  I suppose it would be smarter to wait another 6 months or so until I can request more CLIs.  But I'm really itching for a new card!! Smiley Embarassed


I would be a hypocrite if I told you to suck it up, because I'm apping for the Venture next month in hopes of a $10K+ starting limit, lol. Smiley LOL

 

Just wait ant until your mortgage closes before doing anything. 

Message 6 of 15
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Help! Not sure which card to apply for!


@DeeBee78 wrote:


I would suggest growing your current limits versus cold-apping in hopes of getting a crazy SL out of the gate. You have several cards that grow easily with SP CLI's:

 

US bank - Ask for $1,500 every few months, and it will most likely be a SP. 

Citi- SP every 6 months, sometimes more frequently, almost guaranteed. 

Capital One - SP every 6 months with regular usage and large payments. 

Amex - 61 day initial 3x CLI. 3X every 6 months after that. 

Discover - Can ask any time, but most people see regular SP increases every 60 or 90 days. Can grow into a monster limit in less than a year. 

 

Once you you start getting these limits above $10K, and your income can support it, the $20 and $30K big boy limits come quickly, as you've seen with BoA. I would suggest you wait until your mortgage has closed before requesting CLI's though. Your lender looks at all your lines of credit, and might ask you to close some cards if they think your risk is too high. 


^ x10

Message 7 of 15
SouthJamaica
Mega Contributor

Re: Help! Not sure which card to apply for!


@Anonymous wrote:

I'm in the market for a new credit card and am unsure of which to apply for.  My goal is to get a high SL.  From what I've read here, Venture seems to be the best card for that, but I do not want to get hit with 3 HPs, especially since I am about to take on (my first!) mortgage loan.  Don't know if that might potentially raise a red flag.  FICO 8 Scores are 695 TU/698 EQ/695 EX with 10% utilization and about $55k in available credit.  I've also been considering BofA Travel Rewards - only because I currently have a Cash Rewards card (which I actually just converted over to from a Travel Rewards card) - I started at 3k in 2013 and in the past 8 months got 3 CLIs to 22.9k.  BofA has been really, really good to me and I'm wondering if the SL would be comparable to Venture.

 

Which of these two cards would be the better choice?  Or, are there any others I should consider?  Would love some input from all the experts here Smiley Happy

 


You should not be applying for anything since you're about to apply for a mortgage.

 

 


Total revolving limits 569520 (505320 reporting) FICO 8: EQ 689 TU 691 EX 682




Message 8 of 15
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Help! Not sure which card to apply for!

Just thought I'd share a little update...mortgage lender ran my credit and my loan was approved today (yay!).  So I thought what the hell, let me apply for both the Venture card and BofA card.  Well I'm left feeling a little disappointed to be honest.  Got approved for both, Venture @ 5k limit and BofA at a mere $1,800 limit.  I feel so foolish and feel like I absolutely wasted those hard pulls (not to mention my AAoA is going to be way lower now).  I really thought I would get higher limits Smiley Sad

Message 9 of 15
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Help! Not sure which card to apply for!


Oops. Mortgage companies often ask if you have incurred new debt at closing. They may even pull a new report.

Message 10 of 15
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.