cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Help me choose! Amex PRG, CSP or BCP

tag
Anonymous
Not applicable

Help me choose! Amex PRG, CSP or BCP

Hello everybody, first post, very excited to be here! 

 

So I've been looking to find a new primary card, and have been looking at three different cards. 


I was prequaled/special offered for:  

Amex BCP, $250 cash back 1k over three months. 

Amex PRG, 50,000 points, 1k over three months.

Chase Sapphire Preferred, no special incentive over the (already great!) 40,000 bonus. 

 

Stats: 

TU: 739 Equifax: 753 

AAOA (TU): 5 yrs,

2 credit inquiries, 

 

Chase Freedom as an authorized user with $10k limit (on my line), which I have been paying dilligently for 5 or so years. The account overall is 24 years old (parents), but they really almost never use the chase line. 

Sam's Club Mastercard with $5k limit, about 6 months old.

Handful of deferred federal education loans, about $7k total. 

 

About 5% utillization overall.

No "baddies", always pay in full. 

 

Here's my background: 21 year old college student graduating in December. I have a job offer lined up for post grad in consulting, but will look for even more options in the fall during on campus recruiting. Worst case scenario salary-wise soon would be about $70k plus signing, relocation and performance bonuses. My income currently, is not so strong. I get about $1800/mo from my parents, make about $500 from a job. (I have a ton of scholarship, but not sure that counts because it is through my school).This summer I will make about $700/week. All in all, about $30,000 in yearly income for the time being. Feel like this might hurt a lot unless I can find a way to spin my story. 

 

 

I'm torn between these cards. I currenlty spend most of my money on food, split pretty evenly between restaurants and eating out. I will be travelling quite a lot once I start working, however, and I do like to travel. I'm convinced that the Chase UR are better than the Amex MR, but frankly, having a relationship with Amex seems like a great idea, and they have solid benefits. I'm also not sure I'd make the $4k over 3 months on the CSP without basically having my parents do a lot of it for me. 

 

So the options are: 1) get one of the travel cards now (which one!) and make that my primary, or 2) apply for the BCP, and use that while my expenses are lower and focused on food and get a travel card (either one of those or even the AMEX SPG, which I probably won't qualify for now) in a few months closer to when I'll be travelling a ton?

 

I'd love your feedback on anything about this, including chances and other cards I should be looking at. Thanks guys! 

Message 1 of 9
8 REPLIES 8
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Help me choose! Amex PRG, CSP or BCP


@Anonymous wrote:

Hello everybody, first post, very excited to be here! 

 

So I've been looking to find a new primary card, and have been looking at three different cards. 


I was prequaled/special offered for:  

Amex BCP, $250 cash back 1k over three months. 

Amex PRG, 50,000 points, 1k over three months.

Chase Sapphire Preferred, no special incentive over the (already great!) 40,000 bonus. 

 

Stats: 

TU: 739 Equifax: 753 

AAOA (TU): 5 yrs,

2 credit inquiries, 

 

Chase Freedom as an authorized user with $10k limit (on my line), which I have been paying dilligently for 5 or so years. The account overall is 24 years old (parents), but they really almost never use the chase line. 

Sam's Club Mastercard with $5k limit, about 6 months old.

Handful of deferred federal education loans, about $7k total. 

 

About 5% utillization overall.

No "baddies", always pay in full. 

 

Here's my background: 21 year old college student graduating in December. I have a job offer lined up for post grad in consulting, but will look for even more options in the fall during on campus recruiting. Worst case scenario salary-wise soon would be about $70k plus signing, relocation and performance bonuses. My income currently, is not so strong. I get about $1800/mo from my parents, make about $500 from a job. (I have a ton of scholarship, but not sure that counts because it is through my school).This summer I will make about $700/week. All in all, about $30,000 in yearly income for the time being. Feel like this might hurt a lot unless I can find a way to spin my story. 

 

 

I'm torn between these cards. I currenlty spend most of my money on food, split pretty evenly between restaurants and eating out. I will be travelling quite a lot once I start working, however, and I do like to travel. I'm convinced that the Chase UR are better than the Amex MR, but frankly, having a relationship with Amex seems like a great idea, and they have solid benefits. I'm also not sure I'd make the $4k over 3 months on the CSP without basically having my parents do a lot of it for me. 

 

So the options are: 1) get one of the travel cards now (which one!) and make that my primary, or 2) apply for the BCP, and use that while my expenses are lower and focused on food and get a travel card (either one of those or even the AMEX SPG, which I probably won't qualify for now) in a few months closer to when I'll be travelling a ton?

 

I'd love your feedback on anything about this, including chances and other cards I should be looking at. Thanks guys! 


Welcome to the forums.  If it were me I would apply for all three if the $5K spend requirement for the CSP and PRG are doable.  Very good chance that the two Amex cards will only be one HP if you apply for the PRG first then the BCE.  With $30K as income you shouldn't have a problem there and others can chime in but I think you can count your scholarship if it helps with living expenses.  Advantages of getting all three now will be the inqs against same time and each card has varying benefits.  Good luck and let us know the results of whatever you decide.

Message 2 of 9
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Help me choose! Amex PRG, CSP or BCP


@Anonymous wrote:

 

Welcome to the forums.  If it were me I would apply for all three if the $5K spend requirement for the CSP and PRG are doable.  Very good chance that the two Amex cards will only be one HP if you apply for the PRG first then the BCE.  With $30K as income you shouldn't have a problem there and others can chime in but I think you can count your scholarship if it helps with living expenses.  Advantages of getting all three now will be the inqs against same time and each card has varying benefits.  Good luck and let us know the results of whatever you decide.


The only problem is that I cannot probably make the spend requirements for all three, and instead was sort of looking for a solid primary card to use until I start working (when I hope to expand out into some other premium cards, like the SPG), 

 

 

Message 3 of 9
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Help me choose! Amex PRG, CSP or BCP

If you are focusing on travel you could do Amex Everday + PRG. Thats 60k+ points for only 2k spend. You could pick up the Chase Freedom as well to start building UR points with only $500 spend in the first three months.  The freedom also has restaurants as a category at the moment so that matches your spending pattern.

Message 4 of 9
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Help me choose! Amex PRG, CSP or BCP

I'm 22 and a recent college grad. I chose the CSP and freedom combo for me. Working well so far. 

Message 5 of 9
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Help me choose! Amex PRG, CSP or BCP

Thanks all for the good advice! I went with the PRG because they actually sweetened the deal a bit more on the phone. I already have the chase freedom, so I'll begin using both and eventually transfer out to the CSP when I get to a point when it makes sense to have that spend limit. 

 

I really chose the PRG because it covers more categories that I care about (travel, dining, groceries, gas) than any of the others, and I really was mostly interested in a primary card. Thanks for all of your advice! 

Message 6 of 9
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Help me choose! Amex PRG, CSP or BCP

Congrats and good choice. The PRG deal is high priority since they are upgrading the card June 1st and we don't know if they will alter the sign-up deal to reflect those changes or not. Just remember to pay it in full every month since it is a charge card.

 

Did you apply for an AmEx revolver as well? They should combine the pull if you do.

Message 7 of 9
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Help me choose! Amex PRG, CSP or BCP

What are they changing or upgrading on June 1st ??? Just applied and got one yesterday. Wondering if I should've waited now. What's going on with PRG June 1st??? Thanks.
Message 8 of 9
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Help me choose! Amex PRG, CSP or BCP

They're essentially boosting the perks and raising the AF by $20. 

 

Changes:

- No foreign transaction fee (!!!!!)

 - $100 credit for airline incidental charges, like baggage fees

- Every dollar spent at restaurants will now earn 2x MR points

- AF: $195 (up from $175)

 

http://about.americanexpress.com/news/pr/2015/amex-adds-benefits-premier-rewards-gold-card.aspx

Message 9 of 9
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.