cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

PenFed Power Cash Visa Signature Pre-Approval *Updated*

tag
Waldemar
Regular Contributor

PenFed Power Cash Visa Signature Pre-Approval *Updated*

I tried the PenFed online "Pre-Qualify" tool, logged in, and was "pre-approved" for 12.5k. I went through the process and submitted the app. It is now under review. I was hoping for an instant approval. How reliable are these pre-approvals? Any idea?

 

PNG image.jpg

 

On 6/8/2023, I was notified that I was denied. Won't know the reasons until I get the letter in the mail.

Credit Cards

Amazon Prime Store Card: $10,000 | Apple Card MC: $3,500 | Best Buy Visa: $3,000 | BCU Cash Rewards Visa Signature: $25,000 | BCU Travel Rewards Visa Signature: $10,000 | Bread Cashback AmEx: $14,500 | Bread Rewards AmEx: $7,650 | Capital One Kohls Visa Signature: $4,000 | Capital One Quicksilver WEMC: $3,000 | Capital One SavorOne WEMC: $17,750 | Capital One VentureOne WEMC: $3,100 | Express Credit Card: $4,050 | Famous Footwear Credit Card: $650 | FNBO Platinum Visa: $950 | Helzberg Diamonds Card: $3,000 | IKEA Projekt Credit Card: $6,100 | Macy’s Amex $1,500 | PayPal Cashback WMC: $20,000 | Sam’s Club Plus WEMC: $20,000 | Suncoast CU Rewards Platinum Visa: $10,000 | Target RedCard: $1,200 | Toyota Rewards Credit Card: $10,000 | Toyota Rewards Visa Signature: $7,500 | Truist Enjoy Cash Visa Signature: $8,000 | US Bank Cash+ Secured Visa: $500 | US Bank Platinum Secured Visa: $500 | WF One Key+ WEMC: $9,000

BCU Unsecured LOC 5k | PenFed OD LOC 300

BCU Auto Loan $19,194.00

Rebuilding since June 2021.
10 REPLIES 10
OmarGB9
Community Leader
Super Contributor

Re: PenFed Power Cash Visa Signature Pre-Approval

Without knowing any details about your credit profile, it's hard to say.


Last App: 1/10/2023
Penfed Gold Visa Card

Currently rebuilding as of 04/11/2019.

Starting FICO 8 Scores:




Current FICO 8 scores:


Message 2 of 11
GZG
Senior Contributor

Re: PenFed Power Cash Visa Signature Pre-Approval

Message 3 of 11
Waldemar
Regular Contributor

Re: PenFed Power Cash Visa Signature Pre-Approval

@OmarGB9 all good, I got notification that I was denied.

Credit Cards

Amazon Prime Store Card: $10,000 | Apple Card MC: $3,500 | Best Buy Visa: $3,000 | BCU Cash Rewards Visa Signature: $25,000 | BCU Travel Rewards Visa Signature: $10,000 | Bread Cashback AmEx: $14,500 | Bread Rewards AmEx: $7,650 | Capital One Kohls Visa Signature: $4,000 | Capital One Quicksilver WEMC: $3,000 | Capital One SavorOne WEMC: $17,750 | Capital One VentureOne WEMC: $3,100 | Express Credit Card: $4,050 | Famous Footwear Credit Card: $650 | FNBO Platinum Visa: $950 | Helzberg Diamonds Card: $3,000 | IKEA Projekt Credit Card: $6,100 | Macy’s Amex $1,500 | PayPal Cashback WMC: $20,000 | Sam’s Club Plus WEMC: $20,000 | Suncoast CU Rewards Platinum Visa: $10,000 | Target RedCard: $1,200 | Toyota Rewards Credit Card: $10,000 | Toyota Rewards Visa Signature: $7,500 | Truist Enjoy Cash Visa Signature: $8,000 | US Bank Cash+ Secured Visa: $500 | US Bank Platinum Secured Visa: $500 | WF One Key+ WEMC: $9,000

BCU Unsecured LOC 5k | PenFed OD LOC 300

BCU Auto Loan $19,194.00

Rebuilding since June 2021.
Message 4 of 11
Waldemar
Regular Contributor

Re: PenFed Power Cash Visa Signature Pre-Approval

@GZG I was denied after all. I should had done some reading before wasting a hard pull.

Credit Cards

Amazon Prime Store Card: $10,000 | Apple Card MC: $3,500 | Best Buy Visa: $3,000 | BCU Cash Rewards Visa Signature: $25,000 | BCU Travel Rewards Visa Signature: $10,000 | Bread Cashback AmEx: $14,500 | Bread Rewards AmEx: $7,650 | Capital One Kohls Visa Signature: $4,000 | Capital One Quicksilver WEMC: $3,000 | Capital One SavorOne WEMC: $17,750 | Capital One VentureOne WEMC: $3,100 | Express Credit Card: $4,050 | Famous Footwear Credit Card: $650 | FNBO Platinum Visa: $950 | Helzberg Diamonds Card: $3,000 | IKEA Projekt Credit Card: $6,100 | Macy’s Amex $1,500 | PayPal Cashback WMC: $20,000 | Sam’s Club Plus WEMC: $20,000 | Suncoast CU Rewards Platinum Visa: $10,000 | Target RedCard: $1,200 | Toyota Rewards Credit Card: $10,000 | Toyota Rewards Visa Signature: $7,500 | Truist Enjoy Cash Visa Signature: $8,000 | US Bank Cash+ Secured Visa: $500 | US Bank Platinum Secured Visa: $500 | WF One Key+ WEMC: $9,000

BCU Unsecured LOC 5k | PenFed OD LOC 300

BCU Auto Loan $19,194.00

Rebuilding since June 2021.
Message 5 of 11
GZG
Senior Contributor

Re: PenFed Power Cash Visa Signature Pre-Approval


@Waldemar wrote:

@GZG I was denied after all. I should had done some reading before wasting a hard pull.


yeah if I was denied after being told this:

 

image.png

 

I wouldn't be happy and I'd be demanding the inquiry removed by them

 

'accept the card offer' is not 'submit application for consideration' that's crap

Starting FICO 8:
Current FICO 8:



0/6, 0/12, 4/24 new accounts
Message 6 of 11
ThomasJNewton
Frequent Contributor

Re: PenFed Power Cash Visa Signature Pre-Approval


@Waldemar wrote:

@GZG I was denied after all. I should had done some reading before wasting a hard pull.


Please let us know what reason they gave you for the denial. Once you get it, you may decide to ask them to either reconsider, or remove the hard pull, based on the misleading wording.

 

 

Message 7 of 11
Waldemar
Regular Contributor

Re: PenFed Power Cash Visa Signature Pre-Approval

@ThomasJNewton I called them, and the lady told me it was because of too many inquiries in the past 12 months and too many accounts opened within the past 12 months. I told her how I felt about the misleading pre-approval because a soft pull shows the same information a hard pull does. The difference is that a hard pull is designed to show lenders that the person is seeking credit. She said she understood and agreed. Although she said she loves this new tool as it's something PenFed did not have before, she nonetheless offers no solution. I did email info@hq.penfed.org and expressed my dissatisfaction with this "new tool." They emailed me back and knowledge my email and asked if I wanted to escalate the issue; I told them yes. 

 

I must point out how different BCU and Suncoast CU are from PenFed. BCU gave me a 7.5k Cash Rewards card 6 months ago and a 5k personal line of credit. Recently their Travel Rewards, with 5k, plus a bump to 10k on the Cash Rewards card, and Suncoast increased my limit to 10k from 500.00 on their Platinum Rewards card less than two weeks ago.

 

Still, PenFed can't honor their pre-approval or come back with a recon, even if it was a 5k or something. I'm considering closing my accounts there; they are at a point that serves me no purpose anyway. BCU has become my second main financial institution.

Credit Cards

Amazon Prime Store Card: $10,000 | Apple Card MC: $3,500 | Best Buy Visa: $3,000 | BCU Cash Rewards Visa Signature: $25,000 | BCU Travel Rewards Visa Signature: $10,000 | Bread Cashback AmEx: $14,500 | Bread Rewards AmEx: $7,650 | Capital One Kohls Visa Signature: $4,000 | Capital One Quicksilver WEMC: $3,000 | Capital One SavorOne WEMC: $17,750 | Capital One VentureOne WEMC: $3,100 | Express Credit Card: $4,050 | Famous Footwear Credit Card: $650 | FNBO Platinum Visa: $950 | Helzberg Diamonds Card: $3,000 | IKEA Projekt Credit Card: $6,100 | Macy’s Amex $1,500 | PayPal Cashback WMC: $20,000 | Sam’s Club Plus WEMC: $20,000 | Suncoast CU Rewards Platinum Visa: $10,000 | Target RedCard: $1,200 | Toyota Rewards Credit Card: $10,000 | Toyota Rewards Visa Signature: $7,500 | Truist Enjoy Cash Visa Signature: $8,000 | US Bank Cash+ Secured Visa: $500 | US Bank Platinum Secured Visa: $500 | WF One Key+ WEMC: $9,000

BCU Unsecured LOC 5k | PenFed OD LOC 300

BCU Auto Loan $19,194.00

Rebuilding since June 2021.
Message 8 of 11
Dhani76
New Contributor

Re: PenFed Power Cash Visa Signature Pre-Approval

Same thing happened to me late May. Was pre approved for Visa Gold $6K then denied. Did not know I could request them to remove the hard inquiry. I may investigate.

Starting Score: 621
Current Score: TU 685 EQ 687 EXP 699
Goal Score: 700


Take the myFICO Fitness Challenge
Message 9 of 11
GZG
Senior Contributor

Re: PenFed Power Cash Visa Signature Pre-Approval


@Dhani76 wrote:

Same thing happened to me late May. Was pre approved for Visa Gold $6K then denied. Did not know I could request them to remove the hard inquiry. I may investigate.


you don't technically have a basis for having the inquiry removed other than

 

'this is crap, look at how you presented this offer to me, you guys aren't being reasonable'

 

the ultimate goal is for them to offer a true amex/apple card solid approval w/o HP until accepted or have them change their language on the pre-qual

Starting FICO 8:
Current FICO 8:



0/6, 0/12, 4/24 new accounts
Message 10 of 11
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.