cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Second Card for Super Thin File

tag
SecondToLastDraftDodger
Established Member

Second Card for Super Thin File

Long time lurker, first time poster.

 

Went through the first half of my life not using credit. No student loans, paid for cars in full, etc. I just recently got into the credit scene a few months ago. My first card was the Chase FU (have a banking relationship with Chase; still had to call recon) with a $2k limit.

 

February will be six months, and I'm wanting to get a second card. I've paid the Chase card on time every month. I'm looking at the Amex BCE. I've checked the prequal site and I get prequaled for it now. 

 

Right now, my EX8 score is 730, and TU and EQ aren't showing yet. The goal is to get one card at the 6 month mark and then one more at the year mark so I get the three-card dillhickey and the accounts all age together for the second half of life. That way, if I need credit in the future, I'll have a solid base.

 

So two questions: 1) is this a realistic, workable plan; and 2) is the BCE a good second card to get?

Message 1 of 9
8 REPLIES 8
USMC_Winger
Frequent Contributor

Re: Second Card for Super Thin File


@SecondToLastDraftDodger wrote:

Long time lurker, first time poster.

 

Went through the first half of my life not using credit. No student loans, paid for cars in full, etc. I just recently got into the credit scene a few months ago. My first card was the Chase FU (have a banking relationship with Chase; still had to call recon) with a $2k limit.

 

February will be six months, and I'm wanting to get a second card. I've paid the Chase card on time every month. I'm looking at the Amex BCE. I've checked the prequal site and I get prequaled for it now. 

 

Right now, my EX8 score is 730, and TU and EQ aren't showing yet. The goal is to get one card at the 6 month mark and then one more at the year mark so I get the three-card dillhickey and the accounts all age together for the second half of life. That way, if I need credit in the future, I'll have a solid base.

 

So two questions: 1) is this a realistic, workable plan; and 2) is the BCE a good second card to get?


@SecondToLastDraftDodger:

 

1.)  Yes

2.)  Yes, or a Discover IT card, which doubles your cash back at the end of the first year.

 

Since it takes a minimum of 6 months of credit reporting to calculate a FICO 8 score, and you'll be there in February, that means you have another credit account reporting on your Experian credit report that's at least 6 months old.  (It takes 7 months of reporting for TU and EQ CRs to generate the first FICO 8 scores.)  Are you an authorized user on someone else's credit card?

FICOs:





Message 2 of 9
SouthJamaica
Mega Contributor

Re: Second Card for Super Thin File


@SecondToLastDraftDodger wrote:

Long time lurker, first time poster.

 

Went through the first half of my life not using credit. No student loans, paid for cars in full, etc. I just recently got into the credit scene a few months ago. My first card was the Chase FU (have a banking relationship with Chase; still had to call recon) with a $2k limit.

 

February will be six months, and I'm wanting to get a second card. I've paid the Chase card on time every month. I'm looking at the Amex BCE. I've checked the prequal site and I get prequaled for it now. 

 

Right now, my EX8 score is 730, and TU and EQ aren't showing yet. The goal is to get one card at the 6 month mark and then one more at the year mark so I get the three-card dillhickey and the accounts all age together for the second half of life. That way, if I need credit in the future, I'll have a solid base.

 

So two questions: 1) is this a realistic, workable plan; and 2) is the BCE a good second card to get?


Welcome to the forum and congratulations on your Chase approval.

 

1. Yes you're doing great. To start right off with one of Chase's core cards is a terrific beginning.

2. You should wait for the next application until you're showing up on all 3 bureaus.

3.  I gather you're concentrating on cash back cards.  Yes the Amex BCE is a fine second card. I have one.

4.  I also have the Comenity AAA Travel Advantage Visa; I find it very useful It's new, but so far it looks like one of the most useful cards I could have. There's also a Comenity AAA Daily Advantage card, which some folks might find more useful.

5. Another good card for you might be the Citi DoubleCash mastercard.


Total revolving limits 568220 (504020 reporting) FICO 8: EQ 689 TU 691 EX 682




Message 3 of 9
SecondToLastDraftDodger
Established Member

Re: Second Card for Super Thin File

Thank you for the reply.

 

Yes, I was an AU on a card for several, several years. Perfect payment record. Unfortunately, that person passed away and the account closed. 

Message 4 of 9
SecondToLastDraftDodger
Established Member

Re: Second Card for Super Thin File


@SouthJamaica wrote:

@SecondToLastDraftDodger wrote:

Long time lurker, first time poster.

 

Went through the first half of my life not using credit. No student loans, paid for cars in full, etc. I just recently got into the credit scene a few months ago. My first card was the Chase FU (have a banking relationship with Chase; still had to call recon) with a $2k limit.

 

February will be six months, and I'm wanting to get a second card. I've paid the Chase card on time every month. I'm looking at the Amex BCE. I've checked the prequal site and I get prequaled for it now. 

 

Right now, my EX8 score is 730, and TU and EQ aren't showing yet. The goal is to get one card at the 6 month mark and then one more at the year mark so I get the three-card dillhickey and the accounts all age together for the second half of life. That way, if I need credit in the future, I'll have a solid base.

 

So two questions: 1) is this a realistic, workable plan; and 2) is the BCE a good second card to get?


Welcome to the forum and congratulations on your Chase approval.

 

1. Yes you're doing great. To start right off with one of Chase's core cards is a terrific beginning.

2. You should wait for the next application until you're showing up on all 3 bureaus.

3.  I gather you're concentrating on cash back cards.  Yes the Amex BCE is a fine second card. I have one.

4.  I also have the Comenity AAA Travel Advantage Visa; I find it very useful It's new, but so far it looks like one of the most useful cards I could have. There's also a Comenity AAA Daily Advantage card, which some folks might find more useful.

5. Another good card for you might be the Citi DoubleCash mastercard.


Thank you for the post. It's nice to hear I haven't mess up yet. 

 

I'm concentrating on cash back, but mostly because I haven't figured out the other reward types yet, so I would appreciate any recommendations as well. 

Message 5 of 9
DONZI
Established Contributor

Re: Second Card for Super Thin File

The Amex Blue Cash Everyday was my second card, via a postal mailer.

My first was (and still is..) started at $1000.

Amex granted me the BCE with a $10k SL Smiley Very Happy

 

The BCE was a fine card to get, and has gotten a bit better!

 

It's a perfect path for upgrading to a Blue Cash Preferred if that suits someone's spend. I've been getting upgrade offers since it got to be about 6mo old I think. I never have asked for a limit increase simply because the initial SL has been fine in combination with my other cards - I've kind of over done the gas/grocery area among my cards but have been using the online retail for some things and it's a good place to park all the 'meh' amex offers that I don't want to use or see in the list of available offers. Smiley Wink

2014 credit2020 credit2021 credit2023 credit
paypal credit imagecredit card imagecredit card imagecredit card imagecredit card imagecharge card imagecredit card imagecredit card imagecharge card imagecharge card image
[2020-12-09]=[EQ8|786]-[TU8|746]-[EX8|772] .... gardening until I can't (again).
[2023-10-01]=[EQ8|797]-[TU8|776]-[EX8|775]
Message 6 of 9
Remedios
Credit Mentor

Re: Second Card for Super Thin File


@SecondToLastDraftDodger wrote:

Long time lurker, first time poster.

 

Went through the first half of my life not using credit. No student loans, paid for cars in full, etc. I just recently got into the credit scene a few months ago. My first card was the Chase FU (have a banking relationship with Chase; still had to call recon) with a $2k limit.

 

February will be six months, and I'm wanting to get a second card. I've paid the Chase card on time every month. I'm looking at the Amex BCE. I've checked the prequal site and I get prequaled for it now. 

 

Right now, my EX8 score is 730, and TU and EQ aren't showing yet. The goal is to get one card at the 6 month mark and then one more at the year mark so I get the three-card dillhickey and the accounts all age together for the second half of life. That way, if I need credit in the future, I'll have a solid base.

 

So two questions: 1) is this a realistic, workable plan; and 2) is the BCE a good second card to get?


I think it's a great plan. Amex will approve you, so go ahead and apply unless you really want to wait. I know you said 6 months, but CFU will only get you so far rewards wise. 

 

Message 7 of 9
SecondToLastDraftDodger
Established Member

Re: Second Card for Super Thin File


@Remedios wrote:

@SecondToLastDraftDodger wrote:

Long time lurker, first time poster.

 

Went through the first half of my life not using credit. No student loans, paid for cars in full, etc. I just recently got into the credit scene a few months ago. My first card was the Chase FU (have a banking relationship with Chase; still had to call recon) with a $2k limit.

 

February will be six months, and I'm wanting to get a second card. I've paid the Chase card on time every month. I'm looking at the Amex BCE. I've checked the prequal site and I get prequaled for it now. 

 

Right now, my EX8 score is 730, and TU and EQ aren't showing yet. The goal is to get one card at the 6 month mark and then one more at the year mark so I get the three-card dillhickey and the accounts all age together for the second half of life. That way, if I need credit in the future, I'll have a solid base.

 

So two questions: 1) is this a realistic, workable plan; and 2) is the BCE a good second card to get?


I think it's a great plan. Amex will approve you, so go ahead and apply unless you really want to wait. I know you said 6 months, but CFU will only get you so far rewards wise. 

 


Thanks! I went ahead and applied the other day and got approved! So now I've got my second card.

 

I guess around August will be a good time to apply for the third card? Right now, I've got my eye on the Citi Custom Cash for my third card, because I have read here and heard elsewhere that Citi really wants at least a year of credit history.

Message 8 of 9
FinStar
Moderator Emeritus

Re: Second Card for Super Thin File

As the OP has provided an update on their approval, this thread is now locked and closed to new messages.

 

@SecondToLastDraftDodger - congrats on the AmEx approval. Feel free to start a new thread in the Approvals section if you wish to do so.

Message 9 of 9
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.