cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

So...how does Discover like it?

tag
Anonymous
Not applicable

So...how does Discover like it?

These days I mean. I have of course read through the unofficial data points thread, but I'm just starting out with a secured Discover It card (apologies to the mods if this seems like the wrong board :'( ).

A little more info:

Right now the Discover It is my only card.
My SL is $2500 (went all in on the security deposit).

The unofficial DP thread advocates playing hard to get and placing something small, like a Netflix charge, on the card, PIF (obviously) every month, don't chase rewards. Certainly the circumstances are different, as this card is secured and I can't even think about CLIs until it graduates, but once graduated I'd like to go about hunting for high CLs.

I know this is sort of a second question but...what exactly should my reporting strategy be? I err towards AZEO, and am aming towards apping for two more secured CCs and a SS loan (I'm eligible to join Navy FCU, so I could get a secured card and prepay a SS loan a la the old Alliant SS loan trick), with the hopes of going for a high score when it first generates, but I don't know how to balance what to report and when.

If I'm AZEOing, are the other CAs going to feel neglected if I'm only letting one card report? Should I change the card I let report each month? I understand I can still make charges and PIF the other cards before the due dates; a payment is a payment, I just don't want to hurt my graduation and CLI chances with other cards either.

CAs are such fickle mistresses Smiley Tongue...

Could also use some help choosing a third secured, would like to choose somewhere I'll actually have a future with, so Capital One is out for me. Citi Secured, Bank Americard Secured, and US Bank Secured are what I'm looking at, but I have read a fair number of horror stories about graduation/CLIs/PCs for all 3 of them and I'm not sure where to go.

Any and all help and advice and patience reading all this rambling is much appreciated :'D !
Message 1 of 7
6 REPLIES 6
Shooting-For-800
Senior Contributor

Re: So...how does Discover like it?

Why can't you have a future with Cap One?

I started with Cap One 4 years ago with a single $3,000 card.

YMMV.

Rebuild started in 2014  -  $100k unsecured credit in 2017  -  $500k unsecured credit in 2024.

DON'T WORK FOR CREDIT CARDS ... MAKE CREDIT CARDS WORK FOR YOU!



Message 2 of 7
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: So...how does Discover like it?

Indeed mileage does vary, but I have another in my household who already has credit cards with Capital One and...I'm none too impressed (at this point I understand I have no established credit and can hear the cries of "beggars can't be choosers", but I'm trying anyway Smiley Tongue ).

I don't particularly have an interest in any of their products, I find their non-business rewards cards to be non-competitive, and from said other person's experience and seemingly countless other anecdotes, getting decent SLs and CLIs can be a nightmare with them, unless maybe you're interested in their Venture card (I'm not).

There are outliers of course, folks that manage a crazy $21k CL with a QS card, but I'd rather either go somewhere where I like the rewards, or go somewhere high SLs/CLIs/CLs are the norm, not the exception.

I chose Discover first for that reason, though I don't know how much usage they want to see, and am still debating Citi/BoA/US Bank for my next secured, despite their respective horror stories :/.
Message 3 of 7
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: So...how does Discover like it?


@Anonymous wrote:

Could also use some help choosing a third secured, would like to choose somewhere I'll actually have a future with, so Capital One is out for me. Citi Secured, Bank Americard Secured, and US Bank Secured are what I'm looking at, but I have read a fair number of horror stories about graduation/CLIs/PCs for all 3 of them and I'm not sure where to go.

Welcome to the forums!

 

I read your post and I'm going to say let's stop right there. There's no need to load up the report right now. I started with Disco secured. Used it a ton (Many mid-cycle payments to keep uti under 30% and then brought it down to $3 before the statement cut, i.e., when Disco reports to the CRA's). My first FICO scores were North of 700. I graduated with statement 7 on the dot and get a great auto-CLI.

 

Building credit to work for you is a marathon, not a sprint. My siggy has taken about two years to build up, but it's always moving along. There's no need to do three cards and an SSL right now. I would recommend opening savings with NFCU and building that relationship, because -- depending on your income of course -- that's a good bet for a high SL.

 

Also, AZEO only really matters to squeeze out the last few points in your score. Creditors know how much you're putting on the cards in the case of CLI's, and your SL is (generally) based on your score, income, and relationship with the bank.

 

Best of luck OP!

Message 4 of 7
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: So...how does Discover like it?

I second NFCU. I got an account with them (HP) and they were later generous with the SL for my credit card (HP) with a great increase 1 year later (HP). I like that Capital One gave me a non-secured rebuilder and a few ok CLI'S but now it's one of my lowest cards by far b/c I'm bucketed. In order to go higher, I'd have to app again and the 3 HP's aren't worth it to me.
If it were me, I would probably let my card graduate & age a bit, then see what I pre-qualified for.
Message 5 of 7
AverageJoesCredit
Legendary Contributor

Re: So...how does Discover like it?



@Anonymous wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

Could also use some help choosing a third secured, would like to choose somewhere I'll actually have a future with, so Capital One is out for me. Citi Secured, Bank Americard Secured, and US Bank Secured are what I'm looking at, but I have read a fair number of horror stories about graduation/CLIs/PCs for all 3 of them and I'm not sure where to go.

Welcome to the forums!

 

I read your post and I'm going to say let's stop right there. There's no need to load up the report right now. I started with Disco secured. Used it a ton (Many mid-cycle payments to keep uti under 30% and then brought it down to $3 before the statement cut, i.e., when Disco reports to the CRA's). My first FICO scores were North of 700. I graduated with statement 7 on the dot and get a great auto-CLI.

 

Building credit to work for you is a marathon, not a sprint. My siggy has taken about two years to build up, but it's always moving along. There's no need to do three cards and an SSL right now. I would recommend opening savings with NFCU and building that relationship, because -- depending on your income of course -- that's a good bet for a high SL.

 

Also, AZEO only really matters to squeeze out the last few points in your score. Creditors know how much you're putting on the cards in the case of CLI's, and your SL is (generally) based on your score, income, and relationship with the bank.

 

Best of luck Op

 

great advice Grasshoper, its great to see the student has become the MasterSmiley Happy #RealLiveBoySmiley Happy



Message 6 of 7
Shooting-For-800
Senior Contributor

Re: So...how does Discover like it?

OP - I have never had a secured card in my life and I had a BK.

 

I would keep checking prequals from Discover, Cap One, and Merrick.

 

I doubled my decent SL with Discover within 6-8 months.  They can be very generous.

 

GL!

Rebuild started in 2014  -  $100k unsecured credit in 2017  -  $500k unsecured credit in 2024.

DON'T WORK FOR CREDIT CARDS ... MAKE CREDIT CARDS WORK FOR YOU!



Message 7 of 7
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.