cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Which Card(s) to Apply For?

tag
Gmood1
Super Contributor

Re: Which Card(s) to Apply For?

Lol..not for the faint of heart..that is for sure.
The SP/HP strategy works well. Let's say you have two lenders you want a card from. One is a SP the other HP on the same CB. Naturally you'd come out better initiating the SP first then the HP app. Neither would know of the others pull. There's no telling how many people screw that up apping the HP lender first. lol
Message 41 of 92
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Which Card(s) to Apply For?

Well I've just read the entire thread again and Gmood1 has really imparted a lot of knowledge here.  I second what he said about the impact INQs and Cards Reporting on credit scores.  I opened a Chase Freedom and a US Bank Cash+ on 12/28. (That's what counts as a spree to me Smiley Happy) . My scores didn't budge with inquires to TU and EX.  The Chase card then reported as a new account on 1/13 and my EX score fell 3 points but I just got an alert this morning that it was back at 701 which is where it was before the most two recent inquiries.  The US Bank card will report on 1/31 so we'll see what that impact is.

 

After reading through this thread I realized I have a EQ FICO 9 score of 792 with only 1 inquiry.  Perhaps its time to hit up PenFed for a Power Cash Rewards Card so I can get the 2% cashback since I already have a checking account with them.  Thanks for the distillation of all that knowledge and experience.

Message 42 of 92
Gmood1
Super Contributor

Re: Which Card(s) to Apply For?


wrote:

Well I've just read the entire thread again and Gmood1 has really imparted a lot of knowledge here.  I second what he said about the impact INQs and Cards Reporting on credit scores.  I opened a Chase Freedom and a US Bank Cash+ on 12/28. (That's what counts as a spree to me Smiley Happy) . My scores didn't budge with inquires to TU and EX.  The Chase card then reported as a new account on 1/13 and my EX score fell 3 points but I just got an alert this morning that it was back at 701 which is where it was before the most two recent inquiries.  The US Bank card will report on 1/31 so we'll see what that impact is.

 

After reading through this thread I realized I have a EQ FICO 9 score of 792 with only 1 inquiry.  Perhaps its time to hit up PenFed for a Power Cash Rewards Card so I can get the 2% cashback since I already have a checking account with them.  Thanks for the distillation of all that knowledge and experience.


That's awesome MB! Mine was a 785 last I checked. Way more INQs than you .lol

Message 43 of 92
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Which Card(s) to Apply For?

Its tempting knowing they will only pull EQ which almost no one else in my experience uses.  But I'm tempering it with the fact that I've only been with them since 9/28  (four months).  When I opened checking and savings accounts I apped for the PCR but they declined stating my EX FICO 9 was only 712 and that I had "maximum open-end credit."  They did approved me for the Promise Visa with a $14,500 SL.  But to me the Promise is only valuable as a BT card and I don't carry balances.

 

So has enough time elapsed or should I wait at least 6 months?

Message 44 of 92
Gmood1
Super Contributor

Re: Which Card(s) to Apply For?

In my experience you should be fine. I apped for a Cash Rewards card and two weeks later got an Amex with them on the same pull. Both had $14,000 limits. My scores weren't as good as yours back then. I was still in the 600s.
Unless something has drastically changed. It wouldn't surprise me if you got another card with the same limit.lol
They allow you to close and combine limits. That's what I did. I combined both and dropped the Amex a year later.
With such a great Fico 9 EQ score, I wouldn't be surprised if they offered it to you on SP after the next AR.
Message 45 of 92
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Which Card(s) to Apply For?

Well I guess we'll see...

 

"Thank you for applying with PenFed. Your application is currently being reviewed by one of our loan officers. We will contact you within 24 – 48 hours with more information."

 

I was told that it could take up to a year for me to get offers based on AR  so I was prepared to wait.  If approved I'll try to move some of my Promise Visa over since I haven't used it after qualifying for the SUB.

Message 46 of 92
Gmood1
Super Contributor

Re: Which Card(s) to Apply For?

It was two years before I saw the SP preapprovals after joining. It started after Penfed moved to Fico 9 scoring. I have my fingers crossed for you. 😀 Good luck!

Hopefully later today or tomorrow you'll know something.

Message 47 of 92
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Which Card(s) to Apply For?

Thanks.  The wait is already too long Smiley Happy but hopefully it works out and I'll be able to get that Pixel XL 2.  I would have never thought of applying before 6 months had elapsed without seeing your comments in this thread. 

 

Now its Lancelot99's turn.

 


wrote:

It was two years before I saw the SP preapprovals after joining. It started after Penfed moved to Fico 9 scoring. I have my fingers crossed for you. 😀 Good luck!

Hopefully later today or tomorrow you'll know something.


 

Message 48 of 92
Lancelot99
Established Member

Re: Which Card(s) to Apply For?

Yes, plotting the CRAs pulled and which is a HP/SP is seemingly critical to planning this out well.  Thank you for all the knowledge shared!

 

I'm especially grateful now that I'm out of purgatory and can finally utilize that credit score wisely with your information / knowledge!

08/04/13 FICO 8: EQ 668; EX 664; TU 624
05/09/18 FICO 8: EQ 826; EX 816; TU 825
09/18/21 FICO 8: EQ 831; EX 832; TU 830
TCL: $180,800
Message 49 of 92
Lancelot99
Established Member

Re: Which Card(s) to Apply For?

That's helpful to know.  I suspect for me, my spree is probably 2 cards, maybe 3 at most too, lol, but I guess conservatively I just want to see the impact on my scores myself.  Then I can use all the information gleaned from this thread to go about this in an organized fashion to minimize impact.  I'm looking forward to applying this knowledge.  The toughest part is going to be figuring out which CCs to get!

08/04/13 FICO 8: EQ 668; EX 664; TU 624
05/09/18 FICO 8: EQ 826; EX 816; TU 825
09/18/21 FICO 8: EQ 831; EX 832; TU 830
TCL: $180,800
Message 50 of 92
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.