cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Credit Addict - How Many Is Too Many?

tag
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Credit Addict - How Many Is Too Many?


@SunriseEarth wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

+1 haha I would like to read CreditAddict's response as well.

 

Side Note: I actually applied for the Amazon.com Chase Card, got approved with a 2,500 Limit and got a $70 gift card. I opened it for the sole purpose for purchases on Amazon. 

 

My next card is definitely going to be the Sallie Mae Card. But my question is I have recently applied for 3 new credit cards and got approved for all 3 (Citi Thank You Preferred, Citi Double Cash, Amazon.com Chase) my CK score right now is 740. I expect it go down a bit from these 3 new cards. How long should I wait until I apply for the Sallie Mae card? I was thinking 6-8 months from now. What do you guys think?


I think that's a very prudent observation and a great plan.   Anecdotally, Barclay's can be apprehensive about too many new accounts at once.   In 6 months, the affect of the INQs on your scores will largely dissipate and your accounts will have aged someone in that time period.   If you can wait at least 6 months, it's a great idea.  


Thanks so much for affirming my plan and providing me with your insight Smiley Happy Are you looking to apply for the card as well? 

Message 21 of 60
SunriseEarth
Moderator Emeritus

Re: Credit Addict - How Many Is Too Many?


@Anonymous wrote:

@SunriseEarth wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

+1 haha I would like to read CreditAddict's response as well.

 

Side Note: I actually applied for the Amazon.com Chase Card, got approved with a 2,500 Limit and got a $70 gift card. I opened it for the sole purpose for purchases on Amazon. 

 

My next card is definitely going to be the Sallie Mae Card. But my question is I have recently applied for 3 new credit cards and got approved for all 3 (Citi Thank You Preferred, Citi Double Cash, Amazon.com Chase) my CK score right now is 740. I expect it go down a bit from these 3 new cards. How long should I wait until I apply for the Sallie Mae card? I was thinking 6-8 months from now. What do you guys think?


I think that's a very prudent observation and a great plan.   Anecdotally, Barclay's can be apprehensive about too many new accounts at once.   In 6 months, the affect of the INQs on your scores will largely dissipate and your accounts will have aged someone in that time period.   If you can wait at least 6 months, it's a great idea.  


Thanks so much for affirming my plan and providing me with your insight Smiley Happy Are you looking to apply for the card as well? 


Yes, Sallie Mae is one of my goal cards for 2015!   I have a settled CO that is due to fall off in May/June of next year.   My Ch 7 BK is due to fall off in October.  I may wait until my CRs are clear of both of these before I attempt, but certainly at least clear of the CO.  



Start: 619 (TU08, 9/2013) | Current: 804 (TU08, 10/07/25)
BofA CCR WMC $75000 | AMEX Cash Magnet $64000 | Disney Premier VS $52000 | Discover IT $46000 | NFCU cashRewards Plus WMC $33000 |Venmo VS $30000 | Cash+ VS $30000 | Macy's AMEX $25000 | Ralphs Rewards WEMC $25000 | Synchrony Premier $24,200 | Citi Custom Cash MC $22600 | GS Apple Card WEMC $22000 | WF Attune WEMC $22000 | Freedom Flex WEMC $18000 | Amazon VS $15000 | Target MC $14500 | BMO Harris Cash Back MC $14000 | Rakuten AMEX $12500 | Sephora VS $11900 | Belk MC $10000 | Wayfair MC $9500 |~~
Message 22 of 60
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Credit Addict - How Many Is Too Many?


@SunriseEarth wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

@SunriseEarth wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

+1 haha I would like to read CreditAddict's response as well.

 

Side Note: I actually applied for the Amazon.com Chase Card, got approved with a 2,500 Limit and got a $70 gift card. I opened it for the sole purpose for purchases on Amazon. 

 

My next card is definitely going to be the Sallie Mae Card. But my question is I have recently applied for 3 new credit cards and got approved for all 3 (Citi Thank You Preferred, Citi Double Cash, Amazon.com Chase) my CK score right now is 740. I expect it go down a bit from these 3 new cards. How long should I wait until I apply for the Sallie Mae card? I was thinking 6-8 months from now. What do you guys think?


I think that's a very prudent observation and a great plan.   Anecdotally, Barclay's can be apprehensive about too many new accounts at once.   In 6 months, the affect of the INQs on your scores will largely dissipate and your accounts will have aged someone in that time period.   If you can wait at least 6 months, it's a great idea.  


Thanks so much for affirming my plan and providing me with your insight Smiley Happy Are you looking to apply for the card as well? 


Yes, Sallie Mae is one of my goal cards for 2015!   I have a settled CO that is due to fall off in May/June of next year.   My Ch 7 BK is due to fall off in October.  I may wait until my CRs are clear of both of these before I attempt, but certainly at least clear of the CO.  


I had/still have two unsettled, unpaid C/O's (due to fall off ~mar 2015), one paid C/O and was approved after several recon sessions. Smiley Happy

 

BK might push them away a little more though :/ Good plan. Smiley Happy

Message 23 of 60
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Credit Addict - How Many Is Too Many?

OP: why did you go for the TY Preferred and Double Cash?  The TYP has no advantage over the DC that I know of!

Message 24 of 60
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Credit Addict - How Many Is Too Many?


@vpae wrote:

For some reason I thought this was a question directed towards CreditAddict Smiley Very Happy


I honestly thought the same thing.

Message 25 of 60
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Credit Addict - How Many Is Too Many?


@Anonymous wrote:

OP: why did you go for the TY Preferred and Double Cash?  The TYP has no advantage over the DC that I know of!


You are totally right. Funny that you bring that up because I actually made a post about my situation. This is what I posted, maybe you can share some insight? 

 

Hey guys! I wanted some insight on what to do with my Citi ThankYou Preffered card now that I have a Citi Double Cash Card. I foolishly applied for a ThankYou Preferred from a mail offer without knowing about the Double Cash card until after I got approved for the ThankYou card. I saw that you can convert the card but it was a no go for me as Citi said that the account has to be older than a year in order for it to be eligible for a conversion. So now I have 2 cards and both are new and I see no point of keeping the ThankYou Preferred card as I can use the Double Cash card instead. If I closed my ThankYou Prefered card would it hurt my credit score? Should I keep the account open for a year and convert it to another type of Citi card? Any tips or suggestions would be appreciated. 

 

Original thread: http://ficoforums.myfico.com/t5/Credit-Cards/What-to-do-with-my-Citi-ThankYou-Preferred-Card/m-p/3639667

Message 26 of 60
takeshi74
Senior Contributor

Re: Credit Addict - How Many Is Too Many?


@Anonymous wrote:

How Many Is Too Many?


 That's a very common topic (don't overlook the prior discussions).  Too many is whatever is more than what you can reasonably manage.

 


@Anonymous wrote:

Any suggestions/opinions would be appreciated Smiley Happy 


You need to specify what you're looking for.  Do you have spend that isn't being covered in terms of rewards by your existing cards?  Are you looking for specific benefits?

 


@Anonymous wrote:

I was thinking of adding the Amazon Chase Card and BarclayCard Rewards MC or Bank Of America Travel Rewards but not sure if they are really necessary with the cards that I have.


If you're not sure then you need to crunch the numbers.  Do the math and you'll see what you stand to gain in rewards on those cards.

Message 27 of 60
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Credit Addict - How Many Is Too Many?


@takeshi74 wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

How Many Is Too Many?


 That's a very common topic (don't overlook the prior discussions).  Too many is whatever is more than what you can reasonably manage.

 


@Anonymous wrote:

Any suggestions/opinions would be appreciated Smiley Happy 


You need to specify what you're looking for.  Do you have spend that isn't being covered in terms of rewards by your existing cards?  Are you looking for specific benefits?

 


@Anonymous wrote:

I was thinking of adding the Amazon Chase Card and BarclayCard Rewards MC or Bank Of America Travel Rewards but not sure if they are really necessary with the cards that I have.


If you're not sure then you need to crunch the numbers.  Do the math and you'll see what you stand to gain in rewards on those cards.


I actually applied for the Amazon Card yesterday and got approved with a credit limit of 2,500! I'm more or less looking for a good travel rewards card without an annual fee and many also have suggested the Sallie Mae card, so I'm looking to apply for that in the next 6-8 months since I just recently applied for 3 cards around the same time. 

 

 

Message 28 of 60
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Credit Addict - How Many Is Too Many?


@SunriseEarth wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

@SunriseEarth wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

+1 haha I would like to read CreditAddict's response as well.

 

Side Note: I actually applied for the Amazon.com Chase Card, got approved with a 2,500 Limit and got a $70 gift card. I opened it for the sole purpose for purchases on Amazon. 

 

My next card is definitely going to be the Sallie Mae Card. But my question is I have recently applied for 3 new credit cards and got approved for all 3 (Citi Thank You Preferred, Citi Double Cash, Amazon.com Chase) my CK score right now is 740. I expect it go down a bit from these 3 new cards. How long should I wait until I apply for the Sallie Mae card? I was thinking 6-8 months from now. What do you guys think?


I think that's a very prudent observation and a great plan.   Anecdotally, Barclay's can be apprehensive about too many new accounts at once.   In 6 months, the affect of the INQs on your scores will largely dissipate and your accounts will have aged someone in that time period.   If you can wait at least 6 months, it's a great idea.  


Thanks so much for affirming my plan and providing me with your insight Smiley Happy Are you looking to apply for the card as well? 


Yes, Sallie Mae is one of my goal cards for 2015!   I have a settled CO that is due to fall off in May/June of next year.   My Ch 7 BK is due to fall off in October.  I may wait until my CRs are clear of both of these before I attempt, but certainly at least clear of the CO.  


Good luck! I hope we both get it Smiley Happy 

Message 29 of 60
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Credit Addict - How Many Is Too Many?


@Anonymous wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

OP: why did you go for the TY Preferred and Double Cash?  The TYP has no advantage over the DC that I know of!


You are totally right. Funny that you bring that up because I actually made a post about my situation. This is what I posted, maybe you can share some insight? 

 

Hey guys! I wanted some insight on what to do with my Citi ThankYou Preffered card now that I have a Citi Double Cash Card. I foolishly applied for a ThankYou Preferred from a mail offer without knowing about the Double Cash card until after I got approved for the ThankYou card. I saw that you can convert the card but it was a no go for me as Citi said that the account has to be older than a year in order for it to be eligible for a conversion. So now I have 2 cards and both are new and I see no point of keeping the ThankYou Preferred card as I can use the Double Cash card instead. If I closed my ThankYou Prefered card would it hurt my credit score? Should I keep the account open for a year and convert it to another type of Citi card? Any tips or suggestions would be appreciated. 

 

Original thread: http://ficoforums.myfico.com/t5/Credit-Cards/What-to-do-with-my-Citi-ThankYou-Preferred-Card/m-p/3639667


 

I see no advantage to closing it. Eventually, Citi is bound to come up with some worthwhile program to convert to. In the meantime, look for special targeted offers for 5x points for specific categories. They can provide reasons to pull it out of the sock drawer.

Chris.

Message 30 of 60
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.