@kdm31091 wrote:
Chase AARP gives you 3% on dining as well. Cash+ will do 5% but only on fast food. 2% on real restaurants. Otherwise, yes, your options are basically Discover/Freedom for the rotating 5%. Citi Costco will offer 3% dining but to me that only makes sense if you're going to shop there anyway (not just paying the fee for 3% on dining).
However, in general, I find these "3% on ___" cards can be kind of overrated if you already have a base 1.5% or 2% card. If you spend $10,000 a year on those 3% categories, it's an extra $100 over a 2% card. But you could easily get more than $100 by signing up for a card with a bonus. It's not always mutually exclusive -- AARP offers a $100 bonus for example -- but the Marvel card is just a $25 bonus. The point is that I think it's important not to get too caught up in "3% on ___" but worry more about what that means in dollars for your spending, and compare to other options where you may come out ahead for quite awhile.
kdm, you've been making this point a lot recently and I agree with you. I'm in a similar boat as the OP. I've been trying to justify the need for the new Marvel card with Spider-Man (or Iron Man) on it, but so far, I'm having a difficult time doing so. I ran the numbers and was surprised at how little I spend on dining on average per month. In addition to this, if Discover continues to run a dining/entertainment quarter each year, that would render this new card nearly useless (for me) for 3 months out of the year (another excellent point that kdm mentioned in another thread earlier today). From what I can see, the OP has the Discover it and the Chase Freedom. Therefore, the OP might have dining covered at 5% for half the year if Discover and Chase continue to run dining quarters that don't overlap with each other.
That's a good suggestion you made regarding the Capital One image card, but I suspect that copyright laws would prevent us from getting Spider-Man or some other superhero added to our Capital One cards.
