cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Amex Issue - What is best to do?

tag
BobbyJ
Frequent Contributor

Amex Issue - What is best to do?

Hello, I recently was approved for an Amex PR Gold and Zync and both were backdated to my previous card that I had opened in 1985.  That account was charged off in 1986 I believe when I was very young.

 

Fast forward, that old account is now reporting on my CRs in a positive factor even know my two new accounts are not yet reporting. 

 

Is it wise to let Amex know that my old closed account is being reported?  I dont want to rock the boat and not sure what is best.

 

Thanks

Fico 8 Scores: EX: 787 (6/25/21) EQ: 788 (6/12/21) TU: 750 (2/21/21)
Fico 9 Scores: EX: 799 (11/9/20) EQ: 794 (10/13/20)

Ch7 BK Filed on 10/13/2013 - Discharged 1/14/14



Amex Blue Cash Preferred $15K | Amex Gold Card | Citi Costco Visa $7700 | USBank Altitude Go Visa Sig $10K | USBank Cash+ Visa $8K | C1 Savor MC Elite $15K | C1 Venture One $10K | C1 Quicksilver Visa Sig $10K | C1 Quicksilver WMC $10K | Penfed Plat Rewards Visa $9,500 | Penfed Power Cash Rewards Visa $11K | Discover IT $7500 | USAA Pref Rewards Visa $5K | Penfed Path Visa $10K | Logix FCU Plat MC $12K | SDCCU Plat Visa $2,500 | Best Buy Visa $2K | Chase Amazon Prime Visa Sig $500 | Consumers CU Visa Cash Rebate $5K | PNC Points Visa $2500 | JCPenney $1,800 | Abound CU Plat Visa $5K | Lowes $7K | HSN Card $3K | Walmart MasterCard $2K | Walmart Store Card $2K | Kohls $1K | Target Red Card $800 | QVC Card $800
Message 1 of 17
16 REPLIES 16
LTomBerry
Frequent Contributor

Re: Amex Issue - What is best to do?

Never poke a sleeping bear.


Starting Score: 690
Current Score: EQ 780 EX 814 TU 783
Goal Score: 800

Take the FICO Fitness Challenge
Message 2 of 17
pizzadude
Credit Mentor

Re: Amex Issue - What is best to do?


@BobbyJ wrote:

Hello, I recently was approved for an Amex PR Gold and Zync and both were backdated to my previous card that I had opened in 1985.  That account was charged off in 1986 I believe when I was very young.

 

Fast forward, that old account is now reporting on my CRs in a positive factor even know my two new accounts are not yet reporting. 

 

Is it wise to let Amex know that my old closed account is being reported?  I dont want to rock the boat and not sure what is best.

 

Thanks


If it a positive account I don't know why you would want to do anything to it, unless you are saying that you might want to pay it off now.  

March2010 FICO® ~ 695 TU, 653 EQ, 697 EX
Message 3 of 17
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Amex Issue - What is best to do?

I wouldn't do anything. Believe me, they already know!
Message 4 of 17
-Cain-
Valued Contributor

Re: Amex Issue - What is best to do?

I don't see a reason to contact AmEx.
Message 5 of 17
Open123
Super Contributor

Re: Amex Issue - What is best to do?


@Anonymous wrote:
I wouldn't do anything. Believe me, they already know!

Yes, they certainly do.

 

It's one of those things where they know, but really can't prove it (meaning documentation is incomplete).  It's after SOL, so they can't really pursue it, but the amount is likely small which isn't a big deal for them.

 

You have two options.  One, leave it alone, which is what I would do if it were a large amount.  Two, if it were a relatively small amount, I'd pay it and start fresh, since there is much to be said for paying our debts in life--assuming the debt is yours and you know the amount.

 

While the SOL is a viable defense in court, there is no time limit on when a creditor may collect on a debt.  It could be 100 years, and they can still request you pay, unless it was discharged in a BK.

 

 

Message 6 of 17
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Amex Issue - What is best to do?


@BobbyJ wrote:

Hello, I recently was approved for an Amex PR Gold and Zync and both were backdated to my previous card that I had opened in 1985.  That account was charged off in 1986 I believe when I was very young.

 

Fast forward, that old account is now reporting on my CRs in a positive factor even know my two new accounts are not yet reporting. 

 

Is it wise to let Amex know that my old closed account is being reported?  I dont want to rock the boat and not sure what is best.

 

Thanks


 

Never tickle the tail of a sleeping dragon!

 

FWIW, I have a similar situation. I had an account with them from 1987 that went to a CO in 1991. That old account popped up on my EX report a couple of months before they sent me an offer to apply for a new card. The account is reporting positive, because it is long past the CRTP for derogatory information. I really don't know why they chose to report the old account, but since it's adding to my AAoA on EX, I'm certainly not going to argue. I advise the same for you -- enjoy the windfall!

 

And congrats on your approval!

Message 7 of 17
BobbyJ
Frequent Contributor

Re: Amex Issue - What is best to do?

Thanks everyone for your responses.  I will just leave it alone.  It will be nice to have 3 accounts reporting a 27 year history each rather than just 2.  My AAOA already has increased from 3 years 8 months to 4 years 7 months with just this one reporting.  Cant wait for the other 2 backdated accounts to report.  This forum is great!!!!!

Fico 8 Scores: EX: 787 (6/25/21) EQ: 788 (6/12/21) TU: 750 (2/21/21)
Fico 9 Scores: EX: 799 (11/9/20) EQ: 794 (10/13/20)

Ch7 BK Filed on 10/13/2013 - Discharged 1/14/14



Amex Blue Cash Preferred $15K | Amex Gold Card | Citi Costco Visa $7700 | USBank Altitude Go Visa Sig $10K | USBank Cash+ Visa $8K | C1 Savor MC Elite $15K | C1 Venture One $10K | C1 Quicksilver Visa Sig $10K | C1 Quicksilver WMC $10K | Penfed Plat Rewards Visa $9,500 | Penfed Power Cash Rewards Visa $11K | Discover IT $7500 | USAA Pref Rewards Visa $5K | Penfed Path Visa $10K | Logix FCU Plat MC $12K | SDCCU Plat Visa $2,500 | Best Buy Visa $2K | Chase Amazon Prime Visa Sig $500 | Consumers CU Visa Cash Rebate $5K | PNC Points Visa $2500 | JCPenney $1,800 | Abound CU Plat Visa $5K | Lowes $7K | HSN Card $3K | Walmart MasterCard $2K | Walmart Store Card $2K | Kohls $1K | Target Red Card $800 | QVC Card $800
Message 8 of 17
pizzadude
Credit Mentor

Re: Amex Issue - What is best to do?


@BobbyJ wrote:

Thanks everyone for your responses.  I will just leave it alone.  It will be nice to have 3 accounts reporting a 27 year history each rather than just 2.  My AAOA already has increased from 3 years 8 months to 4 years 7 months with just this one reporting.  Cant wait for the other 2 backdated accounts to report.  This forum is great!!!!!



Good idea ~ and congrats on the backdating, having your other two AMEX cards reporting will most certainly help your AAoA !!

March2010 FICO® ~ 695 TU, 653 EQ, 697 EX
Message 9 of 17
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Amex Issue - What is best to do?


@BobbyJ wrote:

Hello, I recently was approved for an Amex PR Gold and Zync and both were backdated to my previous card that I had opened in 1985.  That account was charged off in 1986 I believe when I was very young.

 

Fast forward, that old account is now reporting on my CRs in a positive factor even know my two new accounts are not yet reporting. 

 

Is it wise to let Amex know that my old closed account is being reported?  I dont want to rock the boat and not sure what is best.

 

Thanks


How do you know that it's the old account that is reporting? Is it showing a balance? Could it be that it's just one of the new cards reporting already? The new accounts will repot as opened in 1985.

Message 10 of 17
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.