cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Amex - Options for BCP, when holding a BCE?

tag
SanDiegoCredit
New Contributor

Amex - Options for BCP, when holding a BCE?

I hold a BCP and BCE. I get a portion of my groceries from walmart online delivery which no longer codes as grocery due them Merging online+grocery biz. No longer makes sense to hold BCP.  BCP has been held for 1 year, BCE for 16. I'm coming up on renewal and will call in to find out options.

 

See if there is a retention offer?

 

Normally I'd product change to avoid AF, but is that possible while holding a BCE?

 

Transfer credit limit to BCE and close card?

 

Advice?




Credit Age:




Gardening.
Message 1 of 6
5 REPLIES 5
Gollum
Established Contributor

Re: Amex - Options for BCP, when holding a BCE?


@SanDiegoCredit wrote:

I hold a BCP and BCE. I get a portion of my groceries from walmart online delivery which no longer codes as grocery due them Merging online+grocery biz. No longer makes sense to hold BCP.  BCP has been held for 1 year, BCE for 16. I'm coming up on renewal and will call in to find out options.

 

See if there is a retention offer?

 

Normally I'd product change to avoid AF, but is that possible while holding a BCE?

 

Transfer credit limit to BCE and close card?

 

Advice?


Close the BCP.

Credit Scores: (FICO 8) 844 Experian October 2025, 836 TransUnion September 2025
Credit Cards (newest to oldest): U.S. Bank Cash+ $17,300 | NFCU Platinum $25,000 | BECU Cash Back $12,500 | American Express BCE $9000 | Simmons Bank Visa $10,500 | Capital One Quicksilver Visa Signature (upgrade from Quicksilver Visa Platinum, which was a PC from No Hassle Miles Rewards Visa Platinum) $5000
Message 2 of 6
MrDisco99
Valued Contributor

Re: Amex - Options for BCP, when holding a BCE?

You can have more than one BCE so downgrade is an option.  Or you can just transfer credit (need to leave $1000 minimum on the donor) and close it.

 

Definitely check for retention offers first, though.

 

Message 3 of 6
Trini88
Established Contributor

Re: Amex - Options for BCP, when holding a BCE?

I know, the Walmart thing made me so mad because I only got to use my BCP there one time for the 6% back before they messed around and changed everything. Gave it to my husband to use at the other grocery stores he shops at.

If Walmart is your main grocery store, I personally would close it and try to transfer some limit to the BCE. If you have a large family and do your grocery shopping elsewhere, I would keep it open. With my 5 member family, we spend $300+ monthly on non Walmart grocery stores so I can justify the $95 AF.

10/19 Quicksilver: $2K
3/21 Americard pc Customized Cash Rewards: $30K
6/21 Target RedCard: $700
6/21 Discover It: $8.5K
6/21 Victoria Secret: $6K
6/21 Savor: $2.3K
7/21 Walmat MC pc VentureOne: $4.1K
8/21 Amex BCP: $25K
11/21 Lowes Advantage: $35K
11/21 FNBO Evergreen: $25K
11/21 GS Apple Card: $4K
4/22 Chase Amazon Prime: $11.2K
7/22 Amex BCE: $8.4K
10/24 Amex Gold: Charge Card
Message 4 of 6
GatorCowboyLion
Regular Contributor

Re: Amex - Options for BCP, when holding a BCE?

You should be able to product change from BCP to Cash Magnet. DW pc'd from Cash Magnet to BCE via online chat, no phone call was required.  

Message 5 of 6
UncleB
Credit Mentor

Re: Amex - Options for BCP, when holding a BCE?

Just a note, if you don't mind using gift cards Fluz might be an option... the last time I checked (back in the summer) "Walmart Grocery" coded as grocery with Amex (as well as other cards I've tried).

 

Also notable, before the recent WM change gift cards couldn't be used for grocery orders, but they can be now.  Also note that with Walmart Pay it's easy-peasy to use electronic gift cards even at the register in the store (this is the only reason I'm willing to bother with it).

Message 6 of 6
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.