cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Amex Plat pre approval questions...

tag
tcbofade
Super Contributor

Amex Plat pre approval questions...

...what in the world would it do for us?

 

DW has an Amex BCE and they will NOT give her a CLI...but she's approved for a Platinum. 

 

60k MR sign up bonus, $200 in Uber rides (which she'll never use) 5X MR points on hotels and airfare.

 

I can't see what good it would do for us... we don't uber, we don't travel a great deal and almost never fly.

 

It's nice to have an offer, but we'd rather have a CLI on her existing account or a preapproval for a different revolver... I can't see how a charge card would be beneficial to us.

 

Am I missing something?

Fico 8 5/02/25: EX 817, EQ 831, TU 829.
Fico 9: EX 812 04/15/25, EQ 804 04/08/25, TU 792 02/15/25.

Zero percent financing is where the devil lives...
Message 1 of 16
15 REPLIES 15
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Amex Plat pre approval questions...

Im with you, This is an excellent travel card, Not so much for everyday spend.  

Message 2 of 16
Shadowfactor
Valued Contributor

Re: Amex Plat pre approval questions...

As it’s considered a premium travel card and it’s rewards are structured towards airfare/hotels. It’s not a good everyday card.

The Uber credits can be used towards Uber eats. And with the addition of the Saks Credit. The net annual fee is only $50

But if you don’t travel. This isn’t the card for you. If you want an Amex MR points card. Look at the Everyday/preferred version or PRG. Both are structured more towards everyday spending then the Platinum.

The platinum really shines with its extensive lounge access. $50 net annual fee for the most extensive lounge access offered by any CC is a steal.




Total Revolving Limits $254,800

Message 3 of 16
wasCB14
Super Contributor

Re: Amex Plat pre approval questions...

It's meant for people who travel a lot...or at least who travel a moderate amount and favor certain airlines/airports or hotel chains/brands.

Personal spend: Amex Gold, Amex Schwab Plat., BofA PR+CCR(x2), Costco
Business use: Amex Bus. Plat., BBP, Lowes Amex AU, CFU AU
Perks: Delta Plat., United Explorer, IHG49, Hyatt, "Old SPG"
Mostly SD: Freedom Flex, Freedom, Arrival
Upgrade/Downgrade games: ED, BCE
SUB chasing: AA Platinum Select
Message 4 of 16
K-in-Boston
Epic Contributor

Re: Amex Plat pre approval questions...

If you really do no travel at all, it would likely be pretty pointless.  If she were to cold app for it, she'd want to get in on one of the 100k offers - even getting an average redemption, I'll use the example that that's about enough to get both you and DW round-trip to Europe on Delta during a sale.

 

I rarely use Uber (5 times to be exact), so I don't really calculate that in for me.  It has saved me probably $60, though.  The 5x back on airfare has been a pretty nice boost for me and my family, as has the $200 airline credit.  Keep in mind that for hotels, you only get 5x back if you book through Amex.  Airfare is through Amex or directly from the airlines. 

 

The big thing for me initially was SPG Gold status matching to Marriott Gold.  With the merger, I no longer consider that, since new Gold will essentially be old Silver and I've already earned new Gold by nights stayed this year and from spend on the SPG card.  You also get Hilton Gold as well as status with Hertz, Avis, and National (and by extension Enterprise).

 

If you use the Global Entry credit, you can deduct another $100 off of the AF.  If you even think you might leave the country once in the next 5 years, that's worth getting for the time saved coming home.  Amex Offers can be huge, too.  Generally, the best reasons to have Amex charge cards are for their unmatched buyer protections, spending power, and the fact that they don't calculate into your revolving utilization on modern credit scoring models.  But if you never travel, Platinum is likely a waste unless you're just churning it for the SUB.

Message 5 of 16
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Amex Plat pre approval questions...


@Shadowfactor wrote:
As it’s considered a premium travel card and it’s rewards are structured towards airfare/hotels. It’s not a good everyday card.

The Uber credits can be used towards Uber eats. And with the addition of the Saks Credit. The net annual fee is only $50

But if you don’t travel. This isn’t the card for you. If you want an Amex MR points card. Look at the Everyday/preferred version or PRG. Both are structured more towards everyday spending then the Platinum.

The platinum really shines with its extensive lounge access. $50 net annual fee for the most extensive lounge access offered by any CC is a steal.

I don't see it as net 50 dollars. You get 200 dollar in airline gift card and it has an 550 dollar annual fee.  I wouldn't say 200 dollar in airline gift cards are worth 200 dollars as I could use the money on something else.  So say worth 180 dollars.

 

If you use the Uber credit it is 15 dollars a month.  Uber charges 4.95 for delivery and you have to tip.  So say 7 bucks for delivery plus tax it doesn't allow for ordering much food.  I got the 50 dollar Sak's credit and ordered some sandals for 50 bucks on sale from 125 dollars.  The sandals are unwearable as they are so uncomfortable.  I will most likely just throw them away.I am sure there are plenty of great things from Sak's but most of them will cost you many hundreds of dollars. I consider the 50 dollar credit a coupon.   

 

60k MR points don't even get you a 600 dollar gift card in most instances. I will keep churning the Ameriprise version to get the airline gift cards and lounge access but I would never pay 550 dollars for one. 

 

Someone mentioned Marriott Gold and even that is pretty worthless.  The hotels you will want to go to on vacation don't even honor any of that stuff and it is going away anyway. 

Message 6 of 16
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Amex Plat pre approval questions...


@tcbofade wrote:

...what in the world would it do for us?

 

DW has an Amex BCE and they will NOT give her a CLI...but she's approved for a Platinum. 

 

60k MR sign up bonus, $200 in Uber rides (which she'll never use) 5X MR points on hotels and airfare.

 

I can't see what good it would do for us... we don't uber, we don't travel a great deal and almost never fly.

 

It's nice to have an offer, but we'd rather have a CLI on her existing account or a preapproval for a different revolver... I can't see how a charge card would be beneficial to us.

 

Am I missing something?


You answered your own question. It's a TRAVEL perk card. It's not for your everyday Joe Schmo. 

 

If you're pre-approved for the Plat, you'll be approved for the Green or Premier Rewards gold, both gered towards everyday spend (or a more realistic AF for non-travelers). 

Message 7 of 16
K-in-Boston
Epic Contributor

Re: Amex Plat pre approval questions...


@Anonymous wrote:

Someone mentioned Marriott Gold and even that is pretty worthless.  The hotels you will want to go to on vacation don't even honor any of that stuff and it is going away anyway. 


<sarcasm>Yeah, in 2017 and 2018 I only got about $4k-5k in value from having Marriott Gold.  Totally worthless.</sarcasm>  While it hasn't done much at Ritz-Carlton or at resort properties, for most other stays it can add up pretty quickly which is why I'm determined to hold onto my status by hitting Marriott Platinum.  If you're using it for something like a resort once a year or only stay in low-tier hotels where everyone gets free breakfast anyway and there really aren't any upgraded rooms, yes it might not be worth much, but if like my family you stay quite regularly in Marriott properties anyway getting executive lounge access, free breakfast, upgrades, and elite multipliers on rewards earned adds up fast.  Plus the ability to transfer unlimited points via SPG between household members has saved us thousands by being able to buy Starpoints and move them to a single Marriott account.

Message 8 of 16
Shadowfactor
Valued Contributor

Re: Amex Plat pre approval questions...

@frogman1

Everyone’s valuation of perks is different.

I fly enough that I would easily use the $200 airline credit on baggage fees. So I value that at a dollar to dollar value.

While I agree Uber eats has high delivery fees in most places. They range only 2.99-4.99 for me for almost every restaurant I’ve used them for. But I plan to use the Uber credits on actual uber’s Atleast half the year. So say $5 x 6 =$30 in lost money for the delivery fee. I normally get pizza or other food delivered several times a year or my girlfriend can use it while I’m overseas so I normally pay that anyway. So I value that at at almost a dollar to dollar value as well.

My girlfriend buys her makeup at Saks. So to me that’s a dollar to dollar value as it would have been spent anyway. Not many places around me sell channel makeup so Saks is her go to place.

So say $80 net annual fee after the lost $30 on Uber eats just to use the credit. And let’s say $10 for additional lost money for good measure

So $90 net annual fee for extensive lounge access is worth it to me. Being able to access Amex Centurion in MIA and Delta in FLL are well worth the $90. That’s only 2 lounge visits. I would use those atleast 7-10 a year.

I wasn’t ever interested in the platinum before the addition of the Saks Credit as the $150 after credits wasn’t worth it in my opinion but with the added Saks Credit. It’s now worth it.




Total Revolving Limits $254,800

Message 9 of 16
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Amex Plat pre approval questions...


@K-in-Boston wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

Someone mentioned Marriott Gold and even that is pretty worthless.  The hotels you will want to go to on vacation don't even honor any of that stuff and it is going away anyway. 


<sarcasm>Yeah, in 2017 and 2018 I only got about $4k-5k in value from having Marriott Gold.  Totally worthless.</sarcasm>  While it hasn't done much at Ritz-Carlton or at resort properties, for most other stays it can add up pretty quickly which is why I'm determined to hold onto my status by hitting Marriott Platinum.  If you're using it for something like a resort once a year or only stay in low-tier hotels where everyone gets free breakfast anyway and there really aren't any upgraded rooms, yes it might not be worth much, but if like my family you stay quite regularly in Marriott properties anyway getting executive lounge access, free breakfast, upgrades, and elite multipliers on rewards earned adds up fast.  Plus the ability to transfer unlimited points via SPG between household members has saved us thousands by being able to buy Starpoints and move them to a single Marriott account.


The status is worthless at resorts. .  I only stay at Marriotts for the free stays at resorts.  I don't like chain hotels.  Next stay is at the Ritz in Aruba.

 

I stayed at Marriotts a lot when business traveling in my younger days. Didn't really use the lounges I went a couple of times but I was on expense account why I am bothering with free cheese and drinks at a lounge when I can go to any restaurant or bar I want for free.   But like I said most of the Marriotts that I would ever want to stay in don't give you anything for status.  Last week I stayed at a Hyatt and they didn't even let me have the 2PM check-out.  They gave me 2k points instead.  Were you the one saying you got free Wifi because of your status?  LOL everyone gets free wifi. 

 

 

 

 

Message 10 of 16
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.