edit- thanks for the tip from @ficosuave , you have to leave at least $1000 on the Everyday card.
Tried to reallocate from an older card to a newer one and Amex promptly shot me down. Figured I'd share for the crowd's entertainment:
Card 1- Amex Everyday, opened early April 2018. Mainly used for a balance transfer that was paid off before promo ended. Very little use last 9 months. 0% UTL. ~$5000 limit.
Card 2- Amex Cash Magnet, opened December 2018. Used by an AU, safe way for me to provide a safety net for a family member with a set monthly limit. $100- 200/mo, PIF. 2% UTL. $5000 limit.
Card 3- Amex Honors Hilton, opened December 2019. $7000 limit. Daily use. PIF. $200 current balance. 3% UTL.
Card 3 opened with $2000 limit and I moved $5000 over from the Card 1 in January to give it the current $7000 limit. I figured it's time to cull the herd, so the Everyday card didn't make the cut. I wanted to move most of it's limit to the Hilton. I knew you can only do a reallocation once a month and figured it wouldn't be a problem since it's been 3 months. Instant rejection with a courteous, "we'll send you a letter..."
777 EX F8. 5% (and rapidly decreasing) aggregate UTL. 12/24, 4/12, 3/6 new accounts.
Also worth mentioning- they declined a CLI in January. I figured that was due to the newest Amex being a month old at that point. Coming up on three months from that rejection so we'll see how they like me in May.
