cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Balance Transfer Help!

tag
lisbonic
Valued Member

Balance Transfer Help!

Hello all,

 

So I have spent the past 2 years adding cards and trying to rebuild by credit profile.  I have accumulated several cards and utilized them all fairly heavy.

 

I have now had an unfortunate finacial set back (I had an employer go out of business that owed me almost $10k in commision) that suddenly has left me trapped with high utilization and now interest payments due.  We purchased a house last year and added many furnishings with the various cards,knowing that Id pay them off with commision checks. Those never came as I metnioned.  If I had known, we obviously wouldnt have spent as much as we did.

 

I recently took two Citi cards with good balance transfer offers in an attempt to shuffle cards and allow me to save interest while I start trying to whittle away at the balances.

 

I have never done a balance transfer before and wanted some eyes to have a look at tell me if I am missing anything/pitfalls/ ideal money movement thoughts.

 

AccountCredit LimitTotal BalanceUsage Rate %Balance til 30%Interest Rate
Barclays Rewards $          3,900.00 $          3,739.2896% $           2,569.2825.49%
Merrick Bank $          1,700.00 $          1,292.1376% $               782.1324.45%
AMEX Everyday $          1,500.00 $              160.0016% $             (140.00)23.49%
Capital One Quick $          2,150.00 $          2,057.7596% $           1,412.7523.40%
Capital One Quick $              500.00 $              272.7955% $               122.7923.40%
DCU Platnium $          5,000.00 $          4,341.0187% $           2,841.0115.50%

 

 

I have now received a Citi Simplicity Card and a Citi Diamon Prefered Card.

 

Citi Simply -  $1,000 0.00% Promo APR for 21 months on Balance Transfers, 13.49% after

Citi Diamond - $1,800 0.00% Promo APR for 21 months on Balnce Transfers, 12.49% after

 

How shoudl I proceed?  Clearly, even after the almost 2 years is up, they will both be my lowest rate cards.  I am probably spending $500 or so a month on these cards already, as interest has kicked in on all of them.

 

Thoughts?

 

 

 

 

 

Message 1 of 7
6 REPLIES 6
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Balance Transfer Help!


@lisbonic wrote:

Hello all,

 

So I have spent the past 2 years adding cards and trying to rebuild by credit profile.  I have accumulated several cards and utilized them all fairly heavy.

 

I have now had an unfortunate finacial set back (I had an employer go out of business that owed me almost $10k in commision) that suddenly has left me trapped with high utilization and now interest payments due.  We purchased a house last year and added many furnishings with the various cards,knowing that Id pay them off with commision checks. Those never came as I metnioned.  If I had known, we obviously wouldnt have spent as much as we did.

 

I recently took two Citi cards with good balance transfer offers in an attempt to shuffle cards and allow me to save interest while I start trying to whittle away at the balances.

 

I have never done a balance transfer before and wanted some eyes to have a look at tell me if I am missing anything/pitfalls/ ideal money movement thoughts.

 

AccountCredit LimitTotal BalanceUsage Rate %Balance til 30%Interest Rate
Barclays Rewards $          3,900.00 $          3,739.2896% $           2,569.2825.49%
Merrick Bank $          1,700.00 $          1,292.1376% $               782.1324.45%
AMEX Everyday $          1,500.00 $              160.0016% $             (140.00)23.49%
Capital One Quick $          2,150.00 $          2,057.7596% $           1,412.7523.40%
Capital One Quick $              500.00 $              272.7955% $               122.7923.40%
DCU Platnium $          5,000.00 $          4,341.0187% $           2,841.0115.50%

 

 

I have now received a Citi Simplicity Card and a Citi Diamon Prefered Card.

 

Citi Simply -  $1,000 0.00% Promo APR for 21 months on Balance Transfers, 13.49% after

Citi Diamond - $1,800 0.00% Promo APR for 21 months on Balnce Transfers, 12.49% after

 

How shoudl I proceed?  Clearly, even after the almost 2 years is up, they will both be my lowest rate cards.  I am probably spending $500 or so a month on these cards already, as interest has kicked in on all of them.

 

Thoughts?

 

 

 

 

 


You don't have much to work with. You have over 10k in cc debt with two new cards with combined limits of only $2800. What are your FICO scores?

 

Not sure if you could get a debt consolidation loan with a decent APR. 

 

Join a credit union.

 

I don't think anyone (as you see from Citi) is going to give you a high starting line on a cc because of your utilization.

 

 

Message 2 of 7
lisbonic
Valued Member

Re: Balance Transfer Help!

Thanks for the response.

 

I am mid 600's depending on with Fico score they use.  Probably between 620-655 on all 3 based on Fico 8.

 

I feel I should atleast move some amounts over to the Citi cards, as te Barclays card has a high balance and a high rate and is almosy $80 a month in interest now.

Message 3 of 7
NRB525
Super Contributor

Re: Balance Transfer Help!

I would pay off the AMEX EveryDay card to zero, wait for a statement to cut to see the last interest charge, pay that last interest amount the day after the statement is available, and then a few days later, start using only the EveryDay card for all daily spend. Pay it frequently throughout the month, but you need a vehicle to make new charges without adding to your existing debt / interest cost. Try to pay off the $500 Cap One card to have that available for the times AMEX is not accepted.

 

I would transfer the amount off the Barclays card to the Citi cards, taking each of those to 80% or 85% Utilization and try to get the Barclays card to zero in the hope of freeing up a BT to that Barclays card.  If a BT is available, then transfer other balances to Barclays. If they do CLD after you have the balances on Barclays just continue to pay it down, don't panic.

 

Moving balances off the Cap One $2k card is next. Continue to keep up with all the cards of course, but you want to have the $2k Cap One at zero when the Barclays and each Citi card goes back to regular APR, because you may want to park amounts on the Cap One while you line up the next BT move. 

 

Good luck!

High Bal Jan 2009 $116k on $146k limits 80% Util.
Oct 2014 $46k on $127k 36% util EQ 722 TU 727 EX 727
April 2018 $18k on $344k 5% util EQ 806 TU 810 EX 812
Jan 2019 $7.6k on $360k EQ 832 TU 839 EX 831
March 2021 $33k on $312k EQ 796 TU 798 EX 801
May 2021 Paid all Installments and Mortgages, one new Mortgage EQ 761 TY 774 EX 777
April 2022 EQ=811 TU=807 EX=805 - TU VS 3.0 765
Message 4 of 7
Aahz
Established Contributor

Re: Balance Transfer Help!


@lisbonic wrote:

Hello all,

 

So I have spent the past 2 years adding cards and trying to rebuild by credit profile.  I have accumulated several cards and utilized them all fairly heavy.

 

I have now had an unfortunate finacial set back (I had an employer go out of business that owed me almost $10k in commision) that suddenly has left me trapped with high utilization and now interest payments due.  We purchased a house last year and added many furnishings with the various cards,knowing that Id pay them off with commision checks. Those never came as I metnioned.  If I had known, we obviously wouldnt have spent as much as we did.

 

I recently took two Citi cards with good balance transfer offers in an attempt to shuffle cards and allow me to save interest while I start trying to whittle away at the balances.

 

I have never done a balance transfer before and wanted some eyes to have a look at tell me if I am missing anything/pitfalls/ ideal money movement thoughts.

 

AccountCredit LimitTotal BalanceUsage Rate %Balance til 30%Interest Rate
Barclays Rewards $          3,900.00 $          3,739.2896% $           2,569.2825.49%
Merrick Bank $          1,700.00 $          1,292.1376% $               782.1324.45%
AMEX Everyday $          1,500.00 $              160.0016% $             (140.00)23.49%
Capital One Quick $          2,150.00 $          2,057.7596% $           1,412.7523.40%
Capital One Quick $              500.00 $              272.7955% $               122.7923.40%
DCU Platnium $          5,000.00 $          4,341.0187% $           2,841.0115.50%

 

 

I have now received a Citi Simplicity Card and a Citi Diamon Prefered Card.

 

Citi Simply -  $1,000 0.00% Promo APR for 21 months on Balance Transfers, 13.49% after

Citi Diamond - $1,800 0.00% Promo APR for 21 months on Balnce Transfers, 12.49% after

 

How shoudl I proceed?  Clearly, even after the almost 2 years is up, they will both be my lowest rate cards.  I am probably spending $500 or so a month on these cards already, as interest has kicked in on all of them.

 

Thoughts? 

 


The last thing you need to worry about right now is improving your FICO scores, so forget about how close you are to 30% on a card and other scoring related concerns.  You just need to get things paid off as quickly as possible.

 

Are you paying monthly fees on the Merrick?  Have an Annual Fee on either CapOne card coming up in the next three months?  Avoiding these fees is extra money used towards paying off your debt ASAP and minimizing interest costs.

 

So, you're starting with $2800 in available BT credit.  But you need to remember the 3% BT fee, so it's really $2716 in available BT.  Let's call it $2600 so we leave a (tiny) buffer on each card.

I'd transfer the entire Merrick balance to the DP then close the Merrick (as I'm assuming it has monthly fees). $2600 - $1330.90 = $1269.10

Pay off the smaller Quicksilver with the Simp then cancel it if it has an AF, sock drawer if it doesn't. $$1269.10 - $280.97 = $988.13

 

The remainder of your available BT should go towards your Barclay card as it has the highest APR.  This will end up being two transfers to maximize the room on the two cards, but there's no real difference in doing a single or multiple BTs.

 

 

Message 5 of 7
rooeez
Regular Contributor

Re: Balance Transfer Help!


@lisbonic wrote:

Hello all,

 

So I have spent the past 2 years adding cards and trying to rebuild by credit profile.  I have accumulated several cards and utilized them all fairly heavy.

 

I have now had an unfortunate finacial set back (I had an employer go out of business that owed me almost $10k in commision) that suddenly has left me trapped with high utilization and now interest payments due.  We purchased a house last year and added many furnishings with the various cards,knowing that Id pay them off with commision checks. Those never came as I metnioned.  If I had known, we obviously wouldnt have spent as much as we did.

 

I recently took two Citi cards with good balance transfer offers in an attempt to shuffle cards and allow me to save interest while I start trying to whittle away at the balances.

 

I have never done a balance transfer before and wanted some eyes to have a look at tell me if I am missing anything/pitfalls/ ideal money movement thoughts.

 

AccountCredit LimitTotal BalanceUsage Rate %Balance til 30%Interest Rate
Barclays Rewards $          3,900.00 $          3,739.2896% $           2,569.2825.49%
Merrick Bank $          1,700.00 $          1,292.1376% $               782.1324.45%
AMEX Everyday $          1,500.00 $              160.0016% $             (140.00)23.49%
Capital One Quick $          2,150.00 $          2,057.7596% $           1,412.7523.40%
Capital One Quick $              500.00 $              272.7955% $               122.7923.40%
DCU Platnium $          5,000.00 $          4,341.0187% $           2,841.0115.50%

 

 

I have now received a Citi Simplicity Card and a Citi Diamon Prefered Card.

 

Citi Simply -  $1,000 0.00% Promo APR for 21 months on Balance Transfers, 13.49% after

Citi Diamond - $1,800 0.00% Promo APR for 21 months on Balnce Transfers, 12.49% after

 

How shoudl I proceed?  Clearly, even after the almost 2 years is up, they will both be my lowest rate cards.  I am probably spending $500 or so a month on these cards already, as interest has kicked in on all of them.

 

Thoughts?

 

 


Sorry for the troubles. If you aren't already using a debt calculator spreadsheet, this is one I've used and is good to play with scenarios.

 

https://www.vertex42.com/Calculators/debt-reduction-calculator.html

 

I think before you go loan route, use the cards that you have to get some relief from interest. If you used the Citi Diamond $1.8k card to pay the Merrick, AMEX, and lower Cap1 QS with the Citi Simply knocking down the Barlcay $1k seems like you can save almost $700, assuming you aren't putting more on them. Again, you can play with alternatives. Either way, put 'em away and get a plan on paying them down over time.

 

Good luck.

 


| TCL = $372,650 | TU FICO 8: 809| EX FICO 8: 807| EQ FICO 8: 806|
Message 6 of 7
lisbonic
Valued Member

Re: Balance Transfer Help!

 

All good advice.  I think I'll follow this path and move 2300 off my Barclays card (where im paying like $80 in interest every month) onto the two new Citi cards.

 

The AMEX is mostly for work stuff, so I can keep that one at zero easily.  I can also zero out the small capital one now as well and will do so.

 

That will drop my highest rate Barclays from a 3700 balance to a 1400 balance, which makes me feel better and seesm more managable to pay off.  I also have about $700 sitting in a rainy day account that I am thinking I could use on the Barclays as well to get that down to only $700 or so within the next week or two.

 

 

At that point, I could move the Merrick balance to Barclays, then close out that card if I wanted.

Message 7 of 7
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.