cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

CLD after Amex Cash Magnet approval

tag
toadsworth
Regular Contributor

CLD after Amex Cash Magnet approval

My 14 month old Amex Everyday is now showing a $5100 limit instead of its previous $10,000 after apping and being approved for the Amex Cash Magnet. I guess I’ve hit my current max exposure with Amex? I also thought it was odd I was approved for $9900 and not $10k. Joke’s on them, I’m probably going to roll it and my BCE’s $1000 limit onto the new Card and close the other two. Less cards to have to remember to put spend on and a $15,000 limit on my reports? Works for me. My scores are more than solid, I have lots of new accounts and AAoA of 13 months.
Kind of have everything I want now, creditwise. Undeliberately gardening until I have some spending to do and find a 100,000 Amex Platinum offer lol

Started my credit journey August 2016, after abstaining from credit for years after some poor financial choices in high school. Started with scores in the 580s. Current scores 11/6/18 - EQ: 754 TU: 757 EX: 743

From oldest to newest: DuPage CU Visa Platinum, SL 500 now 3750, Cap1 Platinum SL 300 PC'd to QS now 1600, Alliant Credit Union Share Secured Loan $500, Amex BCE SL 5000 now 600, Neiman Marcus SL 700 now 10000, Target RedCard SL 400 now 2900, Amex ED SL 10000 now 500 (combined with Cash Magnet), Chase AARP SL 800 now 3300, Chase Amazon Prime SL 1000 now 10000, Honda Lease, Discover it SL 1000 now 7000, Synchrony PayPal 2% CB SL 3000 now 10000, Barclays Uber Visa SL 800 now 2100, Citi ThankYou Preferred SL 3300 now 5300, Chase Ritz-Carlton SL 10000 now 1500 (moved to other cards to get annual fee refund), Comenity Total Rewards Visa SL 2000 now 3250, US Bank Cash+ SL 500 recon'd to 10000, US Bank Reserve LOC 1000, Union Bank Rewards Visa SL 5000 now 5000, Amex Cash Magnet SL 9900 now 20000, Cap1 Venture SL 10000 now 10000, Discover it 3000 SL now 4000, Amex SPG Luxury 3100 SL now 3100, Amex Amazon Business Prime 10000 SL now 10000, Amex Gold NPSL, US Bank Premier LOC 5000, US Bank Visa Platinum 5400 SL currently reconning

Combined revolving CL $135,300

Goal: Spring 2019 800+ club, $50,000 combined Amex limit
Message 1 of 12
11 REPLIES 11
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: CLD after Amex Cash Magnet approval

I think you hit the nail on the head on reaching your max exposure. That would be my only guess because I have only seen CLD after a recent approval when you have reached the ceiling in regards to how much credit they are willing to extend to you.

 

I am sure they will end up sending you some sort of email, secure message or snail mail letter telling you why anyways.

 

Congrats on your approval!

Message 2 of 12
AverageJoesCredit
Legendary Contributor

Re: CLD after Amex Cash Magnet approval

Yeah but now be careful closing other Amex cards may put you on their radarSmiley Wink
Message 3 of 12
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: CLD after Amex Cash Magnet approval


@toadsworth wrote:
My 14 month old Amex Everyday is now showing a $5100 limit instead of its previous $10,000 after apping and being approved for the Amex Cash Magnet. I guess I’ve hit my current max exposure with Amex? I also thought it was odd I was approved for $9900 and not $10k. Joke’s on them, I’m probably going to roll it and my BCE’s $1000 limit onto the new Card and close the other two. Less cards to have to remember to put spend on and a $15,000 limit on my reports? Works for me. My scores are more than solid, I have lots of new accounts and AAoA of 13 months.

I was under the impression that Amex would not let you roll a $1000 limit card onto another.  Is that not true?

Message 4 of 12
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: CLD after Amex Cash Magnet approval

So I'm assuming they rolled $4900 over from the ED to the Magnet, and your total CL with Amex is $15K?

Makes me wonder what they'll do when I app for the ED card in a few days. I'm sitting at $25K with them between BCW and Gold Delta.

Message 5 of 12
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: CLD after Amex Cash Magnet approval

Congrats

Message 6 of 12
Loquat
Moderator Emeritus

Re: CLD after Amex Cash Magnet approval


@Anonymous wrote:

@toadsworth wrote:
My 14 month old Amex Everyday is now showing a $5100 limit instead of its previous $10,000 after apping and being approved for the Amex Cash Magnet. I guess I’ve hit my current max exposure with Amex? I also thought it was odd I was approved for $9900 and not $10k. Joke’s on them, I’m probably going to roll it and my BCE’s $1000 limit onto the new Card and close the other two. Less cards to have to remember to put spend on and a $15,000 limit on my reports? Works for me. My scores are more than solid, I have lots of new accounts and AAoA of 13 months.

I was under the impression that Amex would not let you roll a $1000 limit card onto another.  Is that not true?


This has been my experience.  They've always allowed for me to roll everything up to $1000.  I've occasionally read where some were allowed to reduce to $500 but I haven't been so lucky as to get them to do that for me. 

Message 7 of 12
toadsworth
Regular Contributor

Re: CLD after Amex Cash Magnet approval

Total exposure $16,000. $9900 Cash Magnet, $5,100 ED, $1000 BCE. Previously was $11,000 exposure with $1000 BCE and $10,000 ED.
Kind of have everything I want now, creditwise. Undeliberately gardening until I have some spending to do and find a 100,000 Amex Platinum offer lol

Started my credit journey August 2016, after abstaining from credit for years after some poor financial choices in high school. Started with scores in the 580s. Current scores 11/6/18 - EQ: 754 TU: 757 EX: 743

From oldest to newest: DuPage CU Visa Platinum, SL 500 now 3750, Cap1 Platinum SL 300 PC'd to QS now 1600, Alliant Credit Union Share Secured Loan $500, Amex BCE SL 5000 now 600, Neiman Marcus SL 700 now 10000, Target RedCard SL 400 now 2900, Amex ED SL 10000 now 500 (combined with Cash Magnet), Chase AARP SL 800 now 3300, Chase Amazon Prime SL 1000 now 10000, Honda Lease, Discover it SL 1000 now 7000, Synchrony PayPal 2% CB SL 3000 now 10000, Barclays Uber Visa SL 800 now 2100, Citi ThankYou Preferred SL 3300 now 5300, Chase Ritz-Carlton SL 10000 now 1500 (moved to other cards to get annual fee refund), Comenity Total Rewards Visa SL 2000 now 3250, US Bank Cash+ SL 500 recon'd to 10000, US Bank Reserve LOC 1000, Union Bank Rewards Visa SL 5000 now 5000, Amex Cash Magnet SL 9900 now 20000, Cap1 Venture SL 10000 now 10000, Discover it 3000 SL now 4000, Amex SPG Luxury 3100 SL now 3100, Amex Amazon Business Prime 10000 SL now 10000, Amex Gold NPSL, US Bank Premier LOC 5000, US Bank Visa Platinum 5400 SL currently reconning

Combined revolving CL $135,300

Goal: Spring 2019 800+ club, $50,000 combined Amex limit
Message 8 of 12
K-in-Boston
Epic Contributor

Re: CLD after Amex Cash Magnet approval


@Loquat wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

@toadsworth wrote:
My 14 month old Amex Everyday is now showing a $5100 limit instead of its previous $10,000 after apping and being approved for the Amex Cash Magnet. I guess I’ve hit my current max exposure with Amex? I also thought it was odd I was approved for $9900 and not $10k. Joke’s on them, I’m probably going to roll it and my BCE’s $1000 limit onto the new Card and close the other two. Less cards to have to remember to put spend on and a $15,000 limit on my reports? Works for me. My scores are more than solid, I have lots of new accounts and AAoA of 13 months.

I was under the impression that Amex would not let you roll a $1000 limit card onto another.  Is that not true?


This has been my experience.  They've always allowed for me to roll everything up to $1000.  I've occasionally read where some were allowed to reduce to $500 but I haven't been so lucky as to get them to do that for me. 


Certainly a YMMV situation.  For both DW and myself we can move all but $500 around on our cards (see my Blue from American Express as an example) using the online tool.

Message 9 of 12
red259
Super Contributor

Re: CLD after Amex Cash Magnet approval


@toadsworth wrote:
My 14 month old Amex Everyday is now showing a $5100 limit instead of its previous $10,000 after apping and being approved for the Amex Cash Magnet. I guess I’ve hit my current max exposure with Amex? I also thought it was odd I was approved for $9900 and not $10k. Joke’s on them, I’m probably going to roll it and my BCE’s $1000 limit onto the new Card and close the other two. Less cards to have to remember to put spend on and a $15,000 limit on my reports? Works for me. My scores are more than solid, I have lots of new accounts and AAoA of 13 months.

Doesn't seem like a CLD. Seems like Amex moved credit from one of your cards in order to allow you to open up a new credit card. This is not uncommon with amex when you are near your overall credit limit. Usually they send a letter in follow up explaining what they did. I wish they would let you select which card to move credit from though.

;
Starting Score: EQ: 714, TU 684
Current Score: EQ: 725 7/30/13, TU 684 6/2013, Exp 828 5/2018, Last App 8/5/17
Goal Score: 800 (Achieved!) In garden until Sepetember 2019
Message 10 of 12
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.