cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Card approvals - OK to close one or 2?

tag
Anonymous
Not applicable

Card approvals - OK to close one or 2?

So recently I decided to go on a spree.

 

Amex delta gold - approved for about 15k CL

Citi Premier - no approval at first but called in and they approved right away for 5.6K CL

Chase (CSP) - still waiting, but it seems like it was approved but declined pending verification

Capital One - still pending

 

So let's say all 4 are approved.  Is it OK to close 2 of them?  I should've done all the research before apply for all 4.  I really needed 2 (mainly CSP for dining out points and such and then one other for travel benefits.

 

What are the implications for closing 2 newly opened cards?

 

Thanks!

Message 1 of 7
6 REPLIES 6
jamesdwi
Valued Contributor

Re: Card approvals - OK to close one or 2?


@Anonymous wrote:

So recently I decided to go on a spree.

 

Amex delta gold - approved for about 15k CL

Citi Premier - no approval at first but called in and they approved right away for 5.6K CL

Chase (CSP) - still waiting, but it seems like it was approved but declined pending verification

Capital One - still pending

 

So let's say all 4 are approved.  Is it OK to close 2 of them?  I should've done all the research before apply for all 4.  I really needed 2 (mainly CSP for dining out points and such and then one other for travel benefits.

 

What are the implications for closing 2 newly opened cards?

 

Thanks!


you have taken the hit, the HP and new TL will show on your report your AAoA will be effected, closing the cards will only change card status will change to closed. it will look back under manual review, that you opened cards only to close them within a month.  


Cards: Chase Southwest 20k & CSR 17k & CSP 10k & FNBO 30k Oregon Duck 5k, & AMEX BCP 32.5k & Amex Magnet 15k&amg; Hilton Surpass 7.5k & Delta Gold 12k & Zync NPSL, Fidelity AMEX 17k Commerce5.9k & Cash Forward 7.5k & Sams Club MC 20k, Paypal Extras MC 10k, Paypal Credit 7.25k CapOne Venture 15k, QS 2.5k, QS 750, Amazon 10k, Walmart 10k, Citi Simplicity 18k, Discover IT 23k and a nice stack of store cards.
Landmarkcu Personal Loan 10k
Message 2 of 7
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Card approvals - OK to close one or 2?


@jamesdwi wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

So recently I decided to go on a spree.

 

Amex delta gold - approved for about 15k CL

Citi Premier - no approval at first but called in and they approved right away for 5.6K CL

Chase (CSP) - still waiting, but it seems like it was approved but declined pending verification

Capital One - still pending

 

So let's say all 4 are approved.  Is it OK to close 2 of them?  I should've done all the research before apply for all 4.  I really needed 2 (mainly CSP for dining out points and such and then one other for travel benefits.

 

What are the implications for closing 2 newly opened cards?

 

Thanks!


you have taken the hit, the HP and new TL will show on your report your AAoA will be effected, closing the cards will only change card status will change to closed. it will look back under manual review, that you opened cards only to close them within a month.  



So best to leave as is? Rack up points on all 4 cards and then sock drawer 2?

Message 3 of 7
jamesdwi
Valued Contributor

Re: Card approvals - OK to close one or 2?


@Anonymous wrote:

@jamesdwi wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

So recently I decided to go on a spree.

 

Amex delta gold - approved for about 15k CL

Citi Premier - no approval at first but called in and they approved right away for 5.6K CL

Chase (CSP) - still waiting, but it seems like it was approved but declined pending verification

Capital One - still pending

 

So let's say all 4 are approved.  Is it OK to close 2 of them?  I should've done all the research before apply for all 4.  I really needed 2 (mainly CSP for dining out points and such and then one other for travel benefits.

 

What are the implications for closing 2 newly opened cards?

 

Thanks!


you have taken the hit, the HP and new TL will show on your report your AAoA will be effected, closing the cards will only change card status will change to closed. it will look back under manual review, that you opened cards only to close them within a month.  



So best to leave as is? Rack up points on all 4 cards and then sock drawer 2?



@Anonymous wrote:

@jamesdwi wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

So recently I decided to go on a spree.

 

Amex delta gold - approved for about 15k CL

Citi Premier - no approval at first but called in and they approved right away for 5.6K CL

Chase (CSP) - still waiting, but it seems like it was approved but declined pending verification

Capital One - still pending

 

So let's say all 4 are approved.  Is it OK to close 2 of them?  I should've done all the research before apply for all 4.  I really needed 2 (mainly CSP for dining out points and such and then one other for travel benefits.

 

What are the implications for closing 2 newly opened cards?

 

Thanks!


you have taken the hit, the HP and new TL will show on your report your AAoA will be effected, closing the cards will only change card status will change to closed. it will look back under manual review, that you opened cards only to close them within a month.  



So best to leave as is? Rack up points on all 4 cards and then sock drawer 2?


yes, keep the cards for at least  11 months, a year or longer if no AF. 

 

 

Cards: Chase Southwest 20k & CSR 17k & CSP 10k & FNBO 30k Oregon Duck 5k, & AMEX BCP 32.5k & Amex Magnet 15k&amg; Hilton Surpass 7.5k & Delta Gold 12k & Zync NPSL, Fidelity AMEX 17k Commerce5.9k & Cash Forward 7.5k & Sams Club MC 20k, Paypal Extras MC 10k, Paypal Credit 7.25k CapOne Venture 15k, QS 2.5k, QS 750, Amazon 10k, Walmart 10k, Citi Simplicity 18k, Discover IT 23k and a nice stack of store cards.
Landmarkcu Personal Loan 10k
Message 4 of 7
Ghoshida
Valued Contributor

Re: Card approvals - OK to close one or 2?


@Anonymous wrote:

@jamesdwi wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

So recently I decided to go on a spree.

 

Amex delta gold - approved for about 15k CL

Citi Premier - no approval at first but called in and they approved right away for 5.6K CL

Chase (CSP) - still waiting, but it seems like it was approved but declined pending verification

Capital One - still pending

 

So let's say all 4 are approved.  Is it OK to close 2 of them?  I should've done all the research before apply for all 4.  I really needed 2 (mainly CSP for dining out points and such and then one other for travel benefits.

 

What are the implications for closing 2 newly opened cards?

 

Thanks!


you have taken the hit, the HP and new TL will show on your report your AAoA will be effected, closing the cards will only change card status will change to closed. it will look back under manual review, that you opened cards only to close them within a month.  



So best to leave as is? Rack up points on all 4 cards and then sock drawer 2?


Since you got them, get the spend bonuses on them. After that, SD them / use them whichever way you like. When the next AF gets closer, think of closing them if you like.

Message 5 of 7
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Card approvals - OK to close one or 2?


@jamesdwi wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

@jamesdwi wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

So recently I decided to go on a spree.

 

Amex delta gold - approved for about 15k CL

Citi Premier - no approval at first but called in and they approved right away for 5.6K CL

Chase (CSP) - still waiting, but it seems like it was approved but declined pending verification

Capital One - still pending

 

So let's say all 4 are approved.  Is it OK to close 2 of them?  I should've done all the research before apply for all 4.  I really needed 2 (mainly CSP for dining out points and such and then one other for travel benefits.

 

What are the implications for closing 2 newly opened cards?

 

Thanks!


you have taken the hit, the HP and new TL will show on your report your AAoA will be effected, closing the cards will only change card status will change to closed. it will look back under manual review, that you opened cards only to close them within a month.  



So best to leave as is? Rack up points on all 4 cards and then sock drawer 2?



@Anonymous wrote:

@jamesdwi wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

So recently I decided to go on a spree.

 

Amex delta gold - approved for about 15k CL

Citi Premier - no approval at first but called in and they approved right away for 5.6K CL

Chase (CSP) - still waiting, but it seems like it was approved but declined pending verification

Capital One - still pending

 

So let's say all 4 are approved.  Is it OK to close 2 of them?  I should've done all the research before apply for all 4.  I really needed 2 (mainly CSP for dining out points and such and then one other for travel benefits.

 

What are the implications for closing 2 newly opened cards?

 

Thanks!


you have taken the hit, the HP and new TL will show on your report your AAoA will be effected, closing the cards will only change card status will change to closed. it will look back under manual review, that you opened cards only to close them within a month.  



So best to leave as is? Rack up points on all 4 cards and then sock drawer 2?


yes, keep the cards for at least  11 months, a year or longer if no AF. 

 

 


Thanks!

Message 6 of 7
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Card approvals - OK to close one or 2?


@Ghoshida wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

@jamesdwi wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

So recently I decided to go on a spree.

 

Amex delta gold - approved for about 15k CL

Citi Premier - no approval at first but called in and they approved right away for 5.6K CL

Chase (CSP) - still waiting, but it seems like it was approved but declined pending verification

Capital One - still pending

 

So let's say all 4 are approved.  Is it OK to close 2 of them?  I should've done all the research before apply for all 4.  I really needed 2 (mainly CSP for dining out points and such and then one other for travel benefits.

 

What are the implications for closing 2 newly opened cards?

 

Thanks!


you have taken the hit, the HP and new TL will show on your report your AAoA will be effected, closing the cards will only change card status will change to closed. it will look back under manual review, that you opened cards only to close them within a month.  



So best to leave as is? Rack up points on all 4 cards and then sock drawer 2?


Since you got them, get the spend bonuses on them. After that, SD them / use them whichever way you like. When the next AF gets closer, think of closing them if you like.


Thank you!

Message 7 of 7
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.