No credit card required
Browse credit cards from a variety of issuers to see if there's a better card for you.
@Anonymous wrote:Welcome to the forums!! While it's great that you want to start building your credit I would probably take it easy with the recon if I were you. 2 months is a very very short credit history, student or otherwise. As someone else mentioned, there are people with high FICOs and high incomes that get denied by Citi for fairly innocuous reasons. As a student who is new to credit it may not be in your best interest to rouse the Citi higher ups since they would probably view your calls as more of a nuisance than actually wanting to help if you were a high net worth client (sorry, just my honest opinion).
No kidding. Citi seems to deny people for frivolous reasons, like 2 inquiries being 'excessive'.
@Anonymous wrote:
@CreditChampion wrote:I have been denied a recon through the office of the president because of limited credit history. I will not take no for answer, and have left a message at Mod Cut house voicemail. Anyone have any suggestions? I have a 2 month old Wells Farco Cash Back college card.
Hello there.
Please don't post personal information in the public forums.
MarineVietVet, myFICO moderator
Welcome to the forums!! While it's great that you want to start building your credit I would probably take it easy with the recon if I were you. 2 months is a very very short credit history, student or otherwise. As someone else mentioned, there are people with high FICOs and high incomes that get denied by Citi for fairly innocuous reasons. As a student who is new to credit it may not be in your best interest to rouse the Citi higher ups since they would probably view your calls as more of a nuisance than actually wanting to help if you were a high net worth client (sorry, just my honest opinion).
Citi generally looks for at least 12 months of credit history. I would suggest you garden for a bit. Allow your Wells Fargo account to mature and reapply then. You stand a really good chance of approval by doing that. I'm not sure any further recon would be beneficial to you at this moment. It may even be negative - you definitely don't want them flagging your file or anything that would ruin your chances for approval in the future.
Another poster mentioned the MTVu card. I believe this was discontinued recently and cardholders will be converted to Forward. As far as which is better (Freedom or Forward) they are so different in bonus categories that I actually have both cards to maximize rewards. 5 Thank You points = 3.3% cash back if you want to better compare these cards.
Citi discontinued their MTV and Driver's Edge cards but Capital One created their version of MTV. It's on the Capital One Website Under the student link.
I have to say lately I've seen many people getting denied over lack of credit history even on student cards. It appears that the best route for those looking to build will be secured for a year or so and moving on. I'm glad I was able to get my 3 (Prime) cards given the sensitivity of having a credit history. Especially considering I had only a student loan for about 4 months before I applied.
@CC365 wrote:
@Anonymous wrote:
@CreditChampion wrote:I have been denied a recon through the office of the president because of limited credit history. I will not take no for answer, and have left a message at Mod Cut house voicemail. Anyone have any suggestions? I have a 2 month old Wells Farco Cash Back college card.
Hello there.
Please don't post personal information in the public forums.
MarineVietVet, myFICO moderator
Welcome to the forums!! While it's great that you want to start building your credit I would probably take it easy with the recon if I were you. 2 months is a very very short credit history, student or otherwise. As someone else mentioned, there are people with high FICOs and high incomes that get denied by Citi for fairly innocuous reasons. As a student who is new to credit it may not be in your best interest to rouse the Citi higher ups since they would probably view your calls as more of a nuisance than actually wanting to help if you were a high net worth client (sorry, just my honest opinion).
Citi generally looks for at least 12 months of credit history. I would suggest you garden for a bit. Allow your Wells Fargo account to mature and reapply then. You stand a really good chance of approval by doing that. I'm not sure any further recon would be beneficial to you at this moment. It may even be negative - you definitely don't want them flagging your file or anything that would ruin your chances for approval in the future.
Another poster mentioned the MTVu card. I believe this was discontinued recently and cardholders will be converted to Forward. As far as which is better (Freedom or Forward) they are so different in bonus categories that I actually have both cards to maximize rewards. 5 Thank You points = 3.3% cash back if you want to better compare these cards.
Citi discontinued their MTV and Driver's Edge cards but Capital One created their version of MTV. It's on the Capital One Website Under the student link.
Cap One's version is not so good. Only 2 points at restaurants and the APR is sky high 25% (that's almost the level of a penalty APR on a regular card)
@Anonymous wrote:
@CC365 wrote:
@Anonymous wrote:
@CreditChampion wrote:I have been denied a recon through the office of the president because of limited credit history. I will not take no for answer, and have left a message at Mod Cut house voicemail. Anyone have any suggestions? I have a 2 month old Wells Farco Cash Back college card.
Hello there.
Please don't post personal information in the public forums.
MarineVietVet, myFICO moderator
Welcome to the forums!! While it's great that you want to start building your credit I would probably take it easy with the recon if I were you. 2 months is a very very short credit history, student or otherwise. As someone else mentioned, there are people with high FICOs and high incomes that get denied by Citi for fairly innocuous reasons. As a student who is new to credit it may not be in your best interest to rouse the Citi higher ups since they would probably view your calls as more of a nuisance than actually wanting to help if you were a high net worth client (sorry, just my honest opinion).
Citi generally looks for at least 12 months of credit history. I would suggest you garden for a bit. Allow your Wells Fargo account to mature and reapply then. You stand a really good chance of approval by doing that. I'm not sure any further recon would be beneficial to you at this moment. It may even be negative - you definitely don't want them flagging your file or anything that would ruin your chances for approval in the future.
Another poster mentioned the MTVu card. I believe this was discontinued recently and cardholders will be converted to Forward. As far as which is better (Freedom or Forward) they are so different in bonus categories that I actually have both cards to maximize rewards. 5 Thank You points = 3.3% cash back if you want to better compare these cards.
Citi discontinued their MTV and Driver's Edge cards but Capital One created their version of MTV. It's on the Capital One Website Under the student link.
Cap One's version is not so good. Only 2 points at restaurants and the APR is sky high 25% (that's almost the level of a penalty APR on a regular card)
Yes, Capital One seemed to have destroyed the benefits.
@CC365 wrote:
@Anonymous wrote:
@CC365 wrote:
@Anonymous wrote:
@CreditChampion wrote:I have been denied a recon through the office of the president because of limited credit history. I will not take no for answer, and have left a message at Mod Cut house voicemail. Anyone have any suggestions? I have a 2 month old Wells Farco Cash Back college card.
Hello there.
Please don't post personal information in the public forums.
MarineVietVet, myFICO moderator
Welcome to the forums!! While it's great that you want to start building your credit I would probably take it easy with the recon if I were you. 2 months is a very very short credit history, student or otherwise. As someone else mentioned, there are people with high FICOs and high incomes that get denied by Citi for fairly innocuous reasons. As a student who is new to credit it may not be in your best interest to rouse the Citi higher ups since they would probably view your calls as more of a nuisance than actually wanting to help if you were a high net worth client (sorry, just my honest opinion).
Citi generally looks for at least 12 months of credit history. I would suggest you garden for a bit. Allow your Wells Fargo account to mature and reapply then. You stand a really good chance of approval by doing that. I'm not sure any further recon would be beneficial to you at this moment. It may even be negative - you definitely don't want them flagging your file or anything that would ruin your chances for approval in the future.
Another poster mentioned the MTVu card. I believe this was discontinued recently and cardholders will be converted to Forward. As far as which is better (Freedom or Forward) they are so different in bonus categories that I actually have both cards to maximize rewards. 5 Thank You points = 3.3% cash back if you want to better compare these cards.
Citi discontinued their MTV and Driver's Edge cards but Capital One created their version of MTV. It's on the Capital One Website Under the student link.
Cap One's version is not so good. Only 2 points at restaurants and the APR is sky high 25% (that's almost the level of a penalty APR on a regular card)
Yes, Capital One seemed to have destroyed the benefits.
Plus, it cost 5,000 points for a $25 statement credit or check (and that's the minimum). Or 2,000 points for a $10 gift card, ect. So each point is 0.5 cents instead of a full 1 cent/1% cash back like most other cards give.
@chris2k5 wrote:My suggestion is to just swallow the hard pull from Citi and move on.
For future reference (by the way I don't suggest you apply for another 1-2 months) I recommend you try:
Chase or CapitalOne. I am definitely recommending CapitalOne's Platinum card. It is easier to get and if you can keep that one clean of late payments and etc for 6 months, you can get Chase then Discover.
Citi cards are kind of pointless in my opinion. Chase offers Freedom card which is MUCH better than Forward. The Discover More card is pretty good as well.
This couldn't be further from the truth. It really depends on the person. Chase is definitely better in general cash back at 1%. However Citi offers 3.3% cash back in dining and entertainment such as bookstores (read all Amazon purchases). For someone like me who does most of their shopping on Amazon and eats out a lot, Citi Forward would be a great rewards card. They would not consider my recon though, so I have the Chase Freedom. Citi Forward actually offers better rewards on Amazon than the Chase Amazon rewards card believe it or not.
@Anonymous wrote:
@chris2k5 wrote:My suggestion is to just swallow the hard pull from Citi and move on.
For future reference (by the way I don't suggest you apply for another 1-2 months) I recommend you try:
Chase or CapitalOne. I am definitely recommending CapitalOne's Platinum card. It is easier to get and if you can keep that one clean of late payments and etc for 6 months, you can get Chase then Discover.
Citi cards are kind of pointless in my opinion. Chase offers Freedom card which is MUCH better than Forward. The Discover More card is pretty good as well.
This couldn't be further from the truth. It really depends on the person. Chase is definitely better in general cash back at 1%. However Citi offers 3.3% cash back in dining and entertainment such as bookstores (read all Amazon purchases). For someone like me who does most of their shopping on Amazon and eats out a lot, Citi Forward would be a great rewards card. They would not consider my recon though, so I have the Chase Freedom. Citi Forward actually offers better rewards on Amazon than the Chase Amazon rewards card believe it or not.
+1 If you exclusively used Freedom for Amazon and restaurants it equates to 2% cash back on the year (5% on 1 quarter and 1% on 3 quarters = 8%/4 quarters = 2%).
However let's say you combine Freedom and Forward. Use Freedom on the quarter it's 5% and Forward for the other 3 quarters at 3.3%. 5%+3.3%*3=14.9%/4=3.725%. You would be getting 3.725% cash back on the year which is no chump change.
I got rejected by citifoward by first time around (no history). Applied for jcpenny and cap1 (accepted). Waited a few months and got $4000 approval for citifoward. Citiforward is one of the top cards and you have no/barely any history. Can't really expect them to approve you. Just wait and you'll get it in a few months.