cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Close it or Keep it open

tag
Anonymous
Not applicable

Close it or Keep it open

I have a capital one platinum card that I opened up when I first turned 18. The card is about a year and 7 months old but I dont use it becuase of capital ones horrible customer service and interest rates and horrible rewards (All around terrible!!!). I have a GM card with capital one along with a Neiman Marcus card with them. Would closing the card kill my credit? I am at a 715 and have a Util of 15% total on the following cards:

Chase SP

Chase Disney

Chase Amtrak

Chase Amazon

Gm Card (Capital one)

Citi Dividend Platinum

Macys Amex

Bloomingdales Amex

Neiman Marcus Store (Cap 1)

Discover it

Amex Blue Preferred

 

Thank you for the input!

 

Average card is about 1.5 years old

Message 1 of 5
4 REPLIES 4
j_casteel
Valued Contributor

Re: Close it or Keep it open

It will only potentially effect your utilization. AAoA won't be effected for ~10yrs. If your utilization won't take a big hit then neither will your score. FYI, closing cards doesn't directly impact your scores.
Learning from my past and rebuilding..

BK discharged 1/10/17
scores: EQ 659 | TU 630 | EX 659

QS 3.8K | WF 500 | Cabela's 3k | ACU 500 |

Message 2 of 5
MT936
Established Contributor

Re: Close it or Keep it open

it won't affect you until it drops from your report after 10 years. The only immediate effect is utilization which I would get down first before closing

Amex Blue Cash Everyday: $25,000 | Navy FCU Cash Rewards: $25,000 | Discover It: $20,500
Chase Freedom: $12,500 | Citi Double Cash: $10,000 | Bank of America Cash Rewards: $8,000

Message 3 of 5
BluePoodle
Valued Contributor

Re: Close it or Keep it open


@Anonymous wrote:

I have a capital one platinum card that I opened up when I first turned 18. The card is about a year and 7 months old but I dont use it becuase of capital ones horrible customer service and interest rates and horrible rewards (All around terrible!!!). I have a GM card with capital one along with a Neiman Marcus card with them. Would closing the card kill my credit? I am at a 715 and have a Util of 15% total on the following cards:

Chase SP

Chase Disney

Chase Amtrak

Chase Amazon

Gm Card (Capital one)

Citi Dividend Platinum

Macys Amex

Bloomingdales Amex

Neiman Marcus Store (Cap 1)

Discover it

Amex Blue Preferred

 

Thank you for the input!

 

Average card is about 1.5 years old


Why don't you just PC the card to the QuickSilver?

CapOne $7500 | Discover $8500 | Amex ED $25K | Barclay SM $5700 | Chase Disney $500 | Chase Slate $5K | Target $3K | Hilton Amex $2K
Gardening Since 4/3/2017
Message 4 of 5
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Close it or Keep it open


@BluePoodle wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

I have a capital one platinum card that I opened up when I first turned 18. The card is about a year and 7 months old but I dont use it becuase of capital ones horrible customer service and interest rates and horrible rewards (All around terrible!!!). I have a GM card with capital one along with a Neiman Marcus card with them. Would closing the card kill my credit? I am at a 715 and have a Util of 15% total on the following cards:

Chase SP

Chase Disney

Chase Amtrak

Chase Amazon

Gm Card (Capital one)

Citi Dividend Platinum

Macys Amex

Bloomingdales Amex

Neiman Marcus Store (Cap 1)

Discover it

Amex Blue Preferred

 

Thank you for the input!

 

Average card is about 1.5 years old


Why don't you just PC the card to the QuickSilver?


They wont change it and made me apply for it, I asked and they denied a new app....First credit app I have ever been denied for did a recon and still denied. I just sent a facebook message to see if the do anything more but thats what I really wanted as a result

Message 5 of 5
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.