cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Credit card lineup questions?

tag
Anonymous
Not applicable

Credit card lineup questions?

Hey guys,

I am considering closing a few cards and or opening new cards that better fit what I am looking for.

My current lineup is:

Cap 1 Platinum Visa - 3k Limit
Cap 1 QuickSilver - 3,300 Limit
Cap 1 Helzberg Card - 2,800 Limit
Chase Freedom Unlimited - 6,000 Limit
Chase Amazon Prime Visa - 4,000 Limit
Discover It - 3,000 Limit
Amex Blue Cash - 2,000
Penfed Power Cash - 3,500 Limit
Amazon Store Card (Synchrony) - 3,000 Limit
Newegg Card (Synchrony) - 500$ limit
Dicks Sporting Goods (Synchrony) - 1,800 Limit

Scores FICO 8 - All in the range of 720-750. Util 11%, AAoA is like 2 years

Any recommendations on cards to close and what cards to get? I am looking for a premium card possibly with travel perks.
Message 1 of 13
12 REPLIES 12
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Credit card lineup questions?

For starters an easy chop is the Amazon store card. You have the Amazon visa. Hardly a need for both.

Message 2 of 13
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Credit card lineup questions?

In addition to the Amazon store card, I would also consider closing the Newegg store card (low limit, no remarkable benefits), then the Cap1 Platinum (no rewards).

 

Is there anything special with your Helzberg Diamonds card? If there's nothing outstanding and it would require an online login account separate from Capital One, I'd close that as well.

 

If you're up to accumulating travel points you may consider CSP to complement with your Freedom Unlimited, since it will allow you to transfer points to airline partners and give you certain benefits (rental car insurance, etc.) related to travel. (only if you are < 5/24)

Message 3 of 13
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Credit card lineup questions?

I was considering moving the limit from the Cap 1 platinum to the quicksilver. The platinum is my oldest card at 8 years and I didnt want to ruin my AAoA. However, Id be gardening for awhile so it might be for the best. The newegg card i have never used at all - I needed it for a computer purchase but the low limit made it useless. The helzberg card comes in handy for the 0% APR on purchases over 500$ for 1 year. Other than that its fairly useless. I did recently App for the CSP and was denied because I was over 5/24. I dont use the dicks sporting goods either so i could cut that however I would be losing almost 6,000 of my available credit if i cut all of the synchrony cards. Would this be plausible?
Message 4 of 13
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Credit card lineup questions?


@Anonymous wrote:
I was considering moving the limit from the Cap 1 platinum to the quicksilver. The platinum is my oldest card at 8 years and I didnt want to ruin my AAoA. However, Id be gardening for awhile so it might be for the best. The newegg card i have never used at all - I needed it for a computer purchase but the low limit made it useless. The helzberg card comes in handy for the 0% APR on purchases over 500$ for 1 year. Other than that its fairly useless. I did recently App for the CSP and was denied because I was over 5/24. I dont use the dicks sporting goods either so i could cut that however I would be losing almost 6,000 of my available credit if i cut all of the synchrony cards. Would this be plausible?

Well, by closing an account, it won't ruin your AAoA, and the age of the closed account is still calculated into AAoA until it falls off your credit report (which is 10 years after it got closed, by that time you probably have a bunch of other open accounts reaching that age).

 

Assuming all your sync cards have zero balances, if you close all of them, you lose $5.3k of available credit, bringing your utilization from 11% to 13.1%, which is not a big deal. When you apply for other prime lender cards (especially the premium ones) it's very easy to get back the limit. If you think $5.3k is a lot, you can close the Newegg card first, then when you get approved for new cards you may close the other ones.

Message 5 of 13
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Credit card lineup questions?

Ah. I didnt realize my AAoA wouldn't be affected. I guess thats what I will do. Close the 3 synchrony accounts and combine the 3k platinum to the quicksilver and make a 6,300$ limit.

As for recommended premium cards, anything else you recommend? I was looking at the Amex SPG, the Cap 1 Venture, and CSP.
Message 6 of 13
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Credit card lineup questions?


@Anonymous wrote:
Ah. I didnt realize my AAoA wouldn't be affected. I guess thats what I will do. Close the 3 synchrony accounts and combine the 3k platinum to the quicksilver and make a 6,300$ limit.

As for recommended premium cards, anything else you recommend? I was looking at the Amex SPG, the Cap 1 Venture, and CSP.

All the three cards you mentioned have similar pricing ($95 annual fee, waived first year, no FTF).

 

If you don't have particular categories that you spend a lot (e.g. dining, travel, gas, etc.), then the SPG is a great choice since its points can make very good value (2.5 cent+) if used wisely. It's actually a good card to keep in the long term if SPG keeps their current reward points system after the merger with Marriott. Also they have had limited time 35k point offer, but currently the public offer is 25k.

 

Capital One Venture offers "miles", but that's not something you can transfer to airline partners, but pretty much statement credits for travel related spendings. Max value you can redeem is 1 cent/mile (for crediting travel purchases or buying gift cards), and half of that if you redeem for cash. Think of it as a plain 2% card with limited redeeming options, which Citi Double Cash can easily do better without an annual fee.

 

You are over 5/24 at the moment so CSP won't be an option unless you can get a preapproval through branch or your Chase online account -> Your Offers with a green checkmark and firm APR.

 

From the options you listed, I would go for both SPG and CSP, but due to the 5/24 issue SPG is the way to go. You may still want to wait for the 35k offer, which may be targeted and with additional spending requirement, but 25k is okay. If you at one point fall below 5/24 you can still consider CSP later. If you have the 50k offer for Amex Premier Rewards Gold, you can consider that too, it's annual fee will be $195 (waived for first year), but each calendar year there's $100 airline fee credit (not including tickets) for your selected airline (can only change once a year), still not a bad option though.

Message 7 of 13
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Credit card lineup questions?

I spend alot on dining since I work close to 90 hours a week, its hard to find time to cook/eat at home.
Message 8 of 13
UpperNwGuy
Valued Contributor

Re: Credit card lineup questions?

Cap 1 Platinum Visa - 3k Limit - close
Cap 1 QuickSilver - 3,300 Limit - close
Cap 1 Helzberg Card - 2,800 Limit - close
Chase Freedom Unlimited - 6,000 Limit - keep
Chase Amazon Prime Visa - 4,000 Limit - keep
Discover It - 3,000 Limit - keep
Amex Blue Cash - 2,000 - keep
Penfed Power Cash - 3,500 Limit - keep
Amazon Store Card (Synchrony) - 3,000 Limit - close
Newegg Card (Synchrony) - 500$ limit - close
Dicks Sporting Goods (Synchrony) - 1,800 Limit - close

Daily Carry: PenFed Power Cash • NFCU Flagship • NFCU More Rewards • Chase Freedom
Sock Drawer: PenFed Promise • NFCU cashRewards • Chase Sapphire Preferred • Chase Freedom Unlimited • United Explorer • UNFCU Azure
Message 9 of 13
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Credit card lineup questions?

Why do you recommend closing all the Cap 1's? I know they arent a prime lender but I have never had an issue with them.
Message 10 of 13
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.