cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Do I have too many open CC's-Should I close some?

tag
Rhaeny
Valued Contributor

Do I have too many open CC's-Should I close some?

Okay you all can smack me later.  But seriously I think I have opened too many cards and I don't want to keep managing them all.  I can't believe I'm saying this coming from where I came from last year Smiley Embarassed.  One year ago I wouldn't have dreamed that I would have come this far.  Nonetheless I find myself thinking that I have too many cards now and wayyyy too soon.  So I started thinking about if I should just shut some of them down or just let them age.  

 

I have some teeny weeny limits and some large limits.  The differences between the smallest to the largest is so out of whack that it shows from where I started.  I don't plan on appying for anything else until early next year.  If Barclays doesn't CLI by 2014 then I would like to get one of the Amex CC's that gives rewards on gas and groceries.  I think that I will be pretty well rounded after that. 

 

The below CC's do not have any AF's, so what do you all think?  Should I shut down some of these or just let them be?

 

CCOpenedAmount
The Avenue06/02/12 250
Genisys Visa09/01/12 900
Catherines09/16/12 300
Walmart Store09/16/12 2,500
DCU Visa09/17/12 7,500
Barclays Rewards09/18/12 2,000
JCP09/18/12 1,500
Victoria's Secret09/21/12 750
Woman Within09/21/12 750
Macy's Store10/21/12 1,300
Amazon11/25/12 1,500
NFCU Visa12/22/12 15,000
Discover12/30/12 1,000
Paypal01/13/13 800
NFCU Navcheck03/21/13 3,000
Chase Freedom03/23/13 5,000
HSN04/08/13 2,000
   46,050
Cap1 Quicksilver 11.5K | Chase Amazon Visa 10K | Citizens Bank MC 8K | Citibank MC 5.2K | Home Depot 5K | Bank of America Visa 4.5K | Best Egg Visa 3.8K | Dell 3.5K |Ally MC 2.9K | Apple 2.25K | Merrick Visa 2.3K | Amazon Store (SYNC) 1.8K



Fico Score 8: Equifax 725 | Transunion 742 | Experian 734
Message 1 of 19
18 REPLIES 18
09Lexie
Moderator Emerita

Re: Do I have too many open CC's-Should I close some?

HSN!? When did you sneak that one in? The low limit CL'S are mostly store cards. I assume no AF? I'm not familiar with Avenue, Catherine's etc do they offer coupons like Macy's or Kohls?
Message 2 of 19
LS2982
Mega Contributor

Re: Do I have too many open CC's-Should I close some?


@Rhaeny wrote:

Okay you all can smack me later.  But seriously I think I have opened too many cards and I don't want to keep managing them all.  I can't believe I'm saying this coming from where I came from last year Smiley Embarassed.  One year ago I wouldn't have dreamed that I would have come this far.  Nonetheless I find myself thinking that I have too many cards now and wayyyy too soon.  So I started thinking about if I should just shut some of them down or just let them age.  

 

I have some teeny weeny limits and some large limits.  The differences between the smallest to the largest is so out of whack that it shows from where I started.  I don't plan on appying for anything else until early next year.  If Barclays doesn't CLI by 2014 then I would like to get one of the Amex CC's that gives rewards on gas and groceries.  I think that I will be pretty well rounded after that. 

 

The below CC's do not have any AF's, so what do you all think?  Should I shut down some of these or just let them be?

 

CCOpenedAmount
The Avenue06/02/12 250
Genisys Visa09/01/12 900
Catherines09/16/12 300
Walmart Store09/16/12 2,500
DCU Visa09/17/12 7,500
Barclays Rewards09/18/12 2,000
JCP09/18/12 1,500
Victoria's Secret09/21/12 750
Woman Within09/21/12 750
Macy's Store10/21/12 1,300
Amazon11/25/12 1,500
NFCU Visa12/22/12 15,000
Discover12/30/12 1,000
Paypal01/13/13 800
NFCU Navcheck03/21/13 3,000
Chase Freedom03/23/13 5,000
HSN04/08/13 2,000
   46,050

sponge1.jpg




EQ FICO 548 3/3/16
Message 3 of 19
Ron1
Super Contributor

Re: Do I have too many open CC's-Should I close some?

Why do you want to close them? I got more accounts than you.  I use them once a year. It doesn't cost to keep it open.

You got a good collection of cards. Smiley Happy

 

Ron.

Message 4 of 19
09Lexie
Moderator Emerita

Re: Do I have too many open CC's-Should I close some?

The only thing besides the kitchen sink, is a gas and home improvement cc! 😒
Message 5 of 19
Rhaeny
Valued Contributor

Re: Do I have too many open CC's-Should I close some?


@09Lexie wrote:
HSN!? When did you sneak that one in? The low limit CL'S are mostly store cards. I assume no AF? I'm not familiar with Avenue, Catherine's etc do they offer coupons like Macy's or Kohls?

Yea Lexie, HSN is what knocked me out of the garden (see siggy date).  I was buying something from HSN on my Visa and I'll be damned if a popup didn't show up.  Well I'm a ficonian so I took it!  Of course with an sp, but since it was a new account...well you know what happens.   Had to start over with my seedling.

 

The Avenue and Catherines are commenity.  And yes they do offer coupons that you have to use their card to get.  But with those puny limits there isn't a lot of buying power there.

Cap1 Quicksilver 11.5K | Chase Amazon Visa 10K | Citizens Bank MC 8K | Citibank MC 5.2K | Home Depot 5K | Bank of America Visa 4.5K | Best Egg Visa 3.8K | Dell 3.5K |Ally MC 2.9K | Apple 2.25K | Merrick Visa 2.3K | Amazon Store (SYNC) 1.8K



Fico Score 8: Equifax 725 | Transunion 742 | Experian 734
Message 6 of 19
Rhaeny
Valued Contributor

Re: Do I have too many open CC's-Should I close some?


@LS2982 wrote:

@Rhaeny wrote:

Okay you all can smack me later.  But seriously I think I have opened too many cards and I don't want to keep managing them all.  I can't believe I'm saying this coming from where I came from last year Smiley Embarassed.  One year ago I wouldn't have dreamed that I would have come this far.  Nonetheless I find myself thinking that I have too many cards now and wayyyy too soon.  So I started thinking about if I should just shut some of them down or just let them age.  

 

I have some teeny weeny limits and some large limits.  The differences between the smallest to the largest is so out of whack that it shows from where I started.  I don't plan on appying for anything else until early next year.  If Barclays doesn't CLI by 2014 then I would like to get one of the Amex CC's that gives rewards on gas and groceries.  I think that I will be pretty well rounded after that. 

 

The below CC's do not have any AF's, so what do you all think?  Should I shut down some of these or just let them be?

 

CCOpenedAmount
The Avenue06/02/12 250
Genisys Visa09/01/12 900
Catherines09/16/12 300
Walmart Store09/16/12 2,500
DCU Visa09/17/12 7,500
Barclays Rewards09/18/12 2,000
JCP09/18/12 1,500
Victoria's Secret09/21/12 750
Woman Within09/21/12 750
Macy's Store10/21/12 1,300
Amazon11/25/12 1,500
NFCU Visa12/22/12 15,000
Discover12/30/12 1,000
Paypal01/13/13 800
NFCU Navcheck03/21/13 3,000
Chase Freedom03/23/13 5,000
HSN04/08/13 2,000
   46,050

sponge1.jpg


Oh c'mon LS!!  

 

Okay well maybe I'll get one or two or three more, but I'm trying to hold out for now...LOL!!!!

Cap1 Quicksilver 11.5K | Chase Amazon Visa 10K | Citizens Bank MC 8K | Citibank MC 5.2K | Home Depot 5K | Bank of America Visa 4.5K | Best Egg Visa 3.8K | Dell 3.5K |Ally MC 2.9K | Apple 2.25K | Merrick Visa 2.3K | Amazon Store (SYNC) 1.8K



Fico Score 8: Equifax 725 | Transunion 742 | Experian 734
Message 7 of 19
09Lexie
Moderator Emerita

Re: Do I have too many open CC's-Should I close some?

I say, if there is no AF let nature take its course. If you frequent the stores at all then they will serve their purpose. They'll either age off and close on their own with inactivity.
Message 8 of 19
Rhaeny
Valued Contributor

Re: Do I have too many open CC's-Should I close some?


@Ron1 wrote:

Why do you want to close them? I got more accounts than you.  I use them once a year. It doesn't cost to keep it open.

You got a good collection of cards. Smiley Happy

 

Ron.


Oh wow, you have more than that?  Hmmm well okay then I don't feel so bad now Smiley Happy.  I just thought to myself, dang it!, what have I done?  Is this going to stop say Discover and Barclays from giving me CLI's?  I mean I was opening CC's seems like every month.  Did you see those open dates?  Anyway my util is 8% so I am keeping it low to thwart off any AA.  

Cap1 Quicksilver 11.5K | Chase Amazon Visa 10K | Citizens Bank MC 8K | Citibank MC 5.2K | Home Depot 5K | Bank of America Visa 4.5K | Best Egg Visa 3.8K | Dell 3.5K |Ally MC 2.9K | Apple 2.25K | Merrick Visa 2.3K | Amazon Store (SYNC) 1.8K



Fico Score 8: Equifax 725 | Transunion 742 | Experian 734
Message 9 of 19
jsucool76
Super Contributor

Re: Do I have too many open CC's-Should I close some?

+1 to LS.
And ron
And lexie

Shove em in the sd, pop em out every so often for somethin small, pay it off immediately and just let em age.
Message 10 of 19
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.