cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Dont know if I should close this card. Dont want negitive effects....

tag
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Dont know if I should close this card. Dont want negitive effects....

I still recommend closure.  Average age won't be affected for 10 years, and even then not drastically.  Utilization won't be affected much in the short term because the $200 limit is your smallest one.  Clost it, then just make sure to pay on time on all your accounts and have less than 10% utilization when you apply for the auto loan in 6 months.  I'd say that would be the best way to approach it.

Message 11 of 22
JasonBourneOfCredit
Frequent Contributor

Re: Dont know if I should close this card. Dont want negitive effects....


@Anonymous wrote:

I still recommend closure.  Average age won't be affected for 10 years, and even then not drastically.  Utilization won't be affected much in the short term because the $200 limit is your smallest one.  Clost it, then just make sure to pay on time on all your accounts and have less than 10% utilization when you apply for the auto loan in 6 months.  I'd say that would be the best way to approach it.


Deal. Calling and closing in the morning.

 

thanks

Message 12 of 22
Smug
Established Contributor

Re: Dont know if I should close this card. Dont want negitive effects....


@JasonBourneOfCredit wrote:

Cant figure out how to quote.

 

Orchard is 1.5 yrs old. Cap is about 1.3yrs old. Firestone is about 1.1 yr old.

 

Never late on anything ever. I'm in good shape, just dont want to shoot myself in the foot. Would like to add the $200 to savings.


Click reply, then hit the Quote upper right corner before typing replySmiley Wink
Experian® 808/Equifax® ?/TransUnion® 810
Baddies Experian® clean/Equifax® 1/TransUnion® Clean
Last CLI 6-13-2013
Total Credit $121,190.00
Goal 780!
Message 13 of 22
JasonBourneOfCredit
Frequent Contributor

Re: Dont know if I should close this card. Dont want negitive effects....

Hey one more thing while I have your attention..

 

 

I've been bad until recently. 300 limit on Orchard and 500 limit on Cap1 but I saw the light and paid them off. Or am this week.

 

If I called back doors, think they will increase me anytime soon? Seriously want higher limits.

Message 14 of 22
Smug
Established Contributor

Re: Dont know if I should close this card. Dont want negitive effects....

You need to let them grow, I joined PSECU and they finally gave me a 5k card then NFCU gave me 10k, it will come 1.5 years ago I have a 300.00 cap on card, today about 35k in credit, 20k on 4 main cards.
Experian® 808/Equifax® ?/TransUnion® 810
Baddies Experian® clean/Equifax® 1/TransUnion® Clean
Last CLI 6-13-2013
Total Credit $121,190.00
Goal 780!
Message 15 of 22
bichonmom
Senior Contributor

Re: Dont know if I should close this card. Dont want negitive effects....

If you read on the boards, you'll see that CLIs with either Cap One or Orchard are hard to come by. Cap One CLIs are virtually non-existent. They have a "steps program" and beyond that, they don't do customer-initiated CLIs. At least not with their sub-prime cards. I haven't had an Orchard, but have read many posts of people not getting CLIs or getting very low and slow CLIs with them.

 

You have really low limit cards, but you've had them open more than one year. If I were you, I would really look to app for a new CC before closing. When is your AF due? I'd call the CCC and find out how much time you have to close your account before being charged the AF.

 

I wouldn't recommend applying for a Cap One because they do 3 HP. If your history is clean, I would contact some local CUs and see about getting a CC with one of them. Different CCs have different criteria for CCs. Your score is good, assuming it's a FICO and not a FAKO. With your history and score, you should be able to open a decent CC with a CU.

 

Frankly, I would strongly recommend doing that before closing your other CC. It does make a difference when they look at your CR and see an open vs closed acct reporting. Several loan officers and underwriters at different banks/CUs have told me that. It may not affect your FICO, but it does affect their decision-making. (And closing the CC will affect your FICO indirectly via your util.)

 

Also, if you build a relationship with a good CU, you have a good likelihood of getting a low interest auto loan later on. Smiley Tongue

 

 

EQ FICO 750 | TU FICO 761 (Walmart) | EX FAKO 767 | Goal: 800+

Edits, funky spacing and spelling due to my iPad not getting along with the forum editor!

Message 16 of 22
SoulMaster
Established Contributor

Re: Dont know if I should close this card. Dont want negitive effects....

 

 

 


@JasonBourneOfCredit wrote:

Hey one more thing while I have your attention..

 

 

I've been bad until recently. 300 limit on Orchard and 500 limit on Cap1 but I saw the light and paid them off. Or am this week.

 

If I called back doors, think they will increase me anytime soon? Seriously want higher limits.



Actually, pay them off... then let them report Zero balances, then@ app for a different card.  In other words, don't use them for a tick.  Best to have your util down below 10% when you app for something else (like Barclays).  Orchard and Cap1 are notorious for not giving CLIs.  Oh, and once you get something real, I'd kill that Orchard One too... In fact, I did kill my Orchard card last month @ 360 days old... didn't want that AF to hit!

 

And yeah, kill that Secured one ASAP!

 

-SM

I am not an attorney and none of what I write should be construed as legal advice. For legal advice please consult an attorney.

Starting Score: ~470 preBK(8/2010)
Current Scores as of Late January 2016 All 700+. Last CR pull from a lender(housing) was mid-score 749.
Goal Score: 700+ - reached.
Message 17 of 22
SoulMaster
Established Contributor

Re: Dont know if I should close this card. Dont want negitive effects....


@bichonmom wrote:

If you read on the boards, you'll see that CLIs with either Cap One or Orchard are hard to come by. Cap One CLIs are virtually non-existent. They have a "steps program" and beyond that, they don't do customer-initiated CLIs. At least not with their sub-prime cards. I haven't had an Orchard, but have read many posts of people not getting CLIs or getting very low and slow CLIs with them.

 

You have really low limit cards, but you've had them open more than one year. If I were you, I would really look to app for a new CC before closing. When is your AF due? I'd call the CCC and find out how much time you have to close your account before being charged the AF.

 

I wouldn't recommend applying for a Cap One because they do 3 HP. If your history is clean, I would contact some local CUs and see about getting a CC with one of them. Different CCs have different criteria for CCs. Your score is good, assuming it's a FICO and not a FAKO. With your history and score, you should be able to open a decent CC with a CU.

 

Frankly, I would strongly recommend doing that before closing your other CC. It does make a difference when they look at your CR and see an open vs closed acct reporting. Several loan officers and underwriters at different banks/CUs have told me that. It may not affect your FICO, but it does affect their decision-making. (And closing the CC will affect your FICO indirectly via your util.)

 

Also, if you build a relationship with a good CU, you have a good likelihood of getting a low interest auto loan later on. Smiley Tongue

 

 


Yeah, but alot of them also don't like to see any open secured lines... he's in a 22.  I'd guess he's better off closing that secured card.

 

@More importantly, he has to get them all paid off and reporting zeros before he apps.  Also, other than the Peggy problem @ Cap one, he's got 721CS.  Getting a HP on all 3 isn't going to hurt him as much as having even $200 (across all his cards) report is.  

 

Get the balances down so that you're <10% (zero is best).  Then go apping.

 

-SM

I am not an attorney and none of what I write should be construed as legal advice. For legal advice please consult an attorney.

Starting Score: ~470 preBK(8/2010)
Current Scores as of Late January 2016 All 700+. Last CR pull from a lender(housing) was mid-score 749.
Goal Score: 700+ - reached.
Message 18 of 22
JusdoNit
Established Contributor

Re: Dont know if I should close this card. Dont want negitive effects....

I suggest a (GE) MASTERCARD, VISA, AMEX, OR DISCOVER  and close any cards with annual fees.  A credit union may serve you very well too and like GE's cards they will grow with you and offer you some great rates with the score you have now.

 

Hopefully it is a fico you have posted now.Smiley Wink


Starting Score: 722
Current Score: Now 687 what the hockey sticks...from a 784 (Aug 12 EX 751 EQ Fico)
Goal Score: 800

If your outGo is more than your INcome than your UpKeep will become your downFALL.

Take the FICO Fitness Challenge


Message 19 of 22
JasonBourneOfCredit
Frequent Contributor

Re: Dont know if I should close this card. Dont want negitive effects....

Awesome, thanks people.

 

Heres the plan.

 

Murder the secured. Throw that $200 into savings. Then, murder any outstanding card balances. Easy, just got tax refund. Then, let it hit my CR. Then, apply for Chase Freedom Card. I think thats a good plan.

Message 20 of 22
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.