cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Elaborate on why having more cards with the same company?

tag
Skye12329
Valued Contributor

Elaborate on why having more cards with the same company?

I was just wondering why would someone choose to have the same card with the same company but twice? Im not saying its bad but was just wondering.

 

Ex. ive seen people have 2 QS cards, or 2 Target Cards...etc. OR Why have 2 cards with Cap1 or Citi...etc.

BK7 - 2/21
Cap1 QS - 2k (4/21) - Closed
Mission Lane - 4k (11/21) - Closed
Venmo - 900 (11/21) - Closed
SavorOne - 2700 (12/21)
VentureOne - 2000 (7/22) - Closed
CareCredit - 15000 (6/23)
Sam's Club - 5000 (7/23)
Venture - 5500 (8/24)
HELOC - 33000 (7/23)
Venture X - 15000 (11/24)
WF Reflect - 5000 (6/25)
Costco - 6800 (8/25)
Message 1 of 12
11 REPLIES 11
john398
Senior Contributor

Re: Elaborate on why having more cards with the same company?

LOL I heard of people having 3 Target cards, I have more than one card with Chase but they are different products. Disney, SOuthwest, Slate and Freedom

Message 2 of 12
VirusCredit13
Regular Contributor

Re: Elaborate on why having more cards with the same company?

For some cards I just assume its for cap purposes. 5% cash back capped at w/e dollar amount. If you have two of same card, can double that cap. Othertimes, may be they just want another TL or higher total limit.

 

I'm not sure if these guys are applying for two cards or just AU on one and owner on another. I'm assuming the latter.


Message 3 of 12
coldnmn
Mega Contributor

Re: Elaborate on why having more cards with the same company?

For the US Bank Cash+ you can have more 5% categories. 

Discover IT $17k / US Bank Ace (VSig) $13.5K / US Bank Cash+ (VSig) $13.5k
Sam's Mastercard $15k / Walmart Mastercard $10k / Blispay $7.5k PayPal Ex MC $10.8k
CareCredit 5k / Husq $5k / Cap1 QS $4.5k / Barclay Ring $5.35k / Citi DC (WMC) $12k
Gardening Date 7/01/16 / MyFico 08: EQ 801 / TU 777 / EX 771 / 06/08/17
Message 4 of 12
azguy13
Senior Contributor

Re: Elaborate on why having more cards with the same company?


@VirusCredit13 wrote:

For some cards I just assume its for cap purposes. 5% cash back capped at w/e dollar amount. If you have two of same card, can double that cap. Othertimes, may be they just want another TL or higher total limit.

 

I'm not sure if these guys are applying for two cards or just AU on one and owner on another. I'm assuming the latter.


With some banks like Chase, you can get mutliple cards for their promo rewards and then transfer all rewards to one account. For example, I had a Southwest card and got the 30,000 promo miles after spending $3K in 3 months. I also had a CSP where I got 50,000 promo points (i think it was 50k at the time). Once I realized that I did not need the southwest card to transfer my CSP UR points to my Southwest RR account, I moved the CL to my CSP and closed the Southwest. This resulted in me getting both promo rewards and transferring them to one card. I did not plan it like that, but thats how it happened.

 

Also, it is hard to pass up the CSP/Freedom combo

Message 5 of 12
creditjunkie_503012
Established Member

Re: Elaborate on why having more cards with the same company?

I have two Quicksilver cards that were actually upgrades from platinum cards; one is a Visa and the other is a Master card. I've asked capital one if I could combine limits, and I would close out one of the cards but I was told no by a CSR. I wanted a rewards card to add to my Citi line up, hence the reason for two Citcards. Same with BOA, two different product offerings in terms of rewards.

My Wallet: CSP $20,000 / BOA World MC $20,000 / Discover it $14,500 / Citi Simplicity $20,900 / BOA Cash Rewards Sig $15,400 / Chase Freedom $9,000 / Citi Dividend $16,000/ Walmart $15,000 / BOA Travel Rewards Sig $5000 / Amex Blue Cash Preferred $5000/ / Cap one Quick Silver(1) $5000 / Cap one Quick Silver(2) $3000 / Kays $7,100 / Best Buy $10,800 / JcPenny MasterCard $8000




Message 6 of 12
sexy_kitten7
Regular Contributor

Re: Elaborate on why having more cards with the same company?

Possible explanations are sign up bonuses, rewards, spending category caps (for MS), choosing multiple bonus categories, decreasing your utilization, etc.

I have two QS, not by choice. At one point, I held 1 Cash Rewards and 1 QS. The Cash Rewards product was discontinued and existing accts were automatically converted to QS. Both are currently SD'd, as I am meeting min spend requirements.

I have two BBR on purpose for the rewards. Each yields $120 per year. I'm going to PC another BoA card later this summer, giving me 3!


Quicksilver MC / Amazon.com / Better Balance Rewards Visa / Freedom / Dividend / Quicksilver Visa / Cash+ / Thank You Preferred / Blue Cash Everyday / Better Balance Rewards MC / BankAmericard HRC Cash Rewards / It / Arrival / FlexPerks / Platinum AAdvantage / MileagePlus Explorer / LifeMiles
Message 7 of 12
VirusCredit13
Regular Contributor

Re: Elaborate on why having more cards with the same company?


@azguy13 wrote:

@VirusCredit13 wrote:

For some cards I just assume its for cap purposes. 5% cash back capped at w/e dollar amount. If you have two of same card, can double that cap. Othertimes, may be they just want another TL or higher total limit.

 

I'm not sure if these guys are applying for two cards or just AU on one and owner on another. I'm assuming the latter.


With some banks like Chase, you can get mutliple cards for their promo rewards and then transfer all rewards to one account. For example, I had a Southwest card and got the 30,000 promo miles after spending $3K in 3 months. I also had a CSP where I got 50,000 promo points (i think it was 50k at the time). Once I realized that I did not need the southwest card to transfer my CSP UR points to my Southwest RR account, I moved the CL to my CSP and closed the Southwest. This resulted in me getting both promo rewards and transferring them to one card. I did not plan it like that, but thats how it happened.

 

Also, it is hard to pass up the CSP/Freedom combo


OP's title make it sound like he only meant what your talking about, but based on his post, he was refering to having the same card twice, not only the same bank. Aka 2 CSP, or 2 Freedoms. I was responding to that. 


Message 8 of 12
Kenny
Moderator Emeritus

Re: Elaborate on why having more cards with the same company?

A lot of people get multiples by product changes, but some also get some by apping for the same thing again. The easy answer: they're allowed. Smiley Wink
Message 9 of 12
creditFiend
Established Contributor

Re: Elaborate on why having more cards with the same company?


@creditjunkie_503012 wrote:

I have two Quicksilver cards that were actually upgrades from platinum cards; one is a Visa and the other is a Master card. I've asked capital one if I could combine limits, and I would close out one of the cards but I was told no by a CSR. I wanted a rewards card to add to my Citi line up, hence the reason for two Citcards. Same with BOA, two different product offerings in terms of rewards.


Me too.  Well I started with a CapOne platinum re-builder card, then later applied for the green cash back rewards.  I recently upgraded both; the re-builder card to QS; & the cash rewards to QS1 (go figure).  I was also told that limits could not be combined.  Hopefully these cards can blossom since receiving my new TLs with higher CLs.

Last app: 2/21/2016
Amex PRG (NPSL)| Amex Hilton Surpass ($17.6K)| Barclays Arrival WEM ($13K)| Barclays SM ($11K)| Capital One QS ($15K)
CareCredit (15.6K)| Chase CSP ($12K)| Chase Hyatt ($5K)| Chase FU VS ($7K)| Chase Ritz ($16.7K)| Citi DC ($2.4K)
Discover It ($4K)| Lowe's ($17K)| MSUFCU ($5K)| Nasa FCU ($20K)| Navy Cash Rewards ($20K)| Navy CLOC ($15K)
PenFed Thrifty ($500)| USAA Rate Advantage ($7K)
Message 10 of 12
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.