cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Help Me Optimize My Rewards

tag
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Help Me Optimize My Rewards


@Anonymous wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

inb4 Sallie Mae

 

But no, really. Sallie Mae.


Why?


Amazon offers everything. Lol.

 

EDIT: Yes, Barclays does distinguish between those fulfilled by Amazon and those fulfilled by 3rd party vendors. Also, $6000 a year on groceries, while a decent amount, is still pretty easy to surpass when you consider it's only $500 a month on average. Sallie Mae would effectively give you a 50% boost on the amount of groceries you can get 5% on, plus Sallie Mae works at many Walmarts and Targets, while Amex BCP does not.


Amazon GC's solve this problem.


In most cases yes.  However Amazon GC cannot be used to by other gift cards (which is what I mainly use SM for!)

 

For Target spend, Redbird is the way to go, as you get the 5% + whatever reward your cc gives you.   (Sadly, BB doesn't do the same for Walmart)


But at Target, can't you use the Sallie Mae to refill the Redbird card and effectively get 5% back twice?


Possibly, but the double dip actually only equates to 9.75% off.


I'm aware, but that's still pretty dang terrific, lol.


Yes it is, I was just clarifying that it isn't 10%.

Message 21 of 34
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Help Me Optimize My Rewards


@Anonymous wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

inb4 Sallie Mae

 

But no, really. Sallie Mae.


Why?


Amazon offers everything. Lol.

 

EDIT: Yes, Barclays does distinguish between those fulfilled by Amazon and those fulfilled by 3rd party vendors. Also, $6000 a year on groceries, while a decent amount, is still pretty easy to surpass when you consider it's only $500 a month on average. Sallie Mae would effectively give you a 50% boost on the amount of groceries you can get 5% on, plus Sallie Mae works at many Walmarts and Targets, while Amex BCP does not.


Amazon GC's solve this problem.


In most cases yes.  However Amazon GC cannot be used to by other gift cards (which is what I mainly use SM for!)

 

For Target spend, Redbird is the way to go, as you get the 5% + whatever reward your cc gives you.   (Sadly, BB doesn't do the same for Walmart)


But at Target, can't you use the Sallie Mae to refill the Redbird card and effectively get 5% back twice?


Right, if that is all you want to do.  As the Redbird takes $5K per month, I use other cards to load it

Message 22 of 34
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Help Me Optimize My Rewards


@Anonymous wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

inb4 Sallie Mae

 

But no, really. Sallie Mae.


Why?


Amazon offers everything. Lol.

 

EDIT: Yes, Barclays does distinguish between those fulfilled by Amazon and those fulfilled by 3rd party vendors. Also, $6000 a year on groceries, while a decent amount, is still pretty easy to surpass when you consider it's only $500 a month on average. Sallie Mae would effectively give you a 50% boost on the amount of groceries you can get 5% on, plus Sallie Mae works at many Walmarts and Targets, while Amex BCP does not.


Amazon GC's solve this problem.


In most cases yes.  However Amazon GC cannot be used to by other gift cards (which is what I mainly use SM for!)

 

For Target spend, Redbird is the way to go, as you get the 5% + whatever reward your cc gives you.   (Sadly, BB doesn't do the same for Walmart)


But at Target, can't you use the Sallie Mae to refill the Redbird card and effectively get 5% back twice?


Possibly, but the double dip actually only equates to 9.75% off.


I'm aware, but that's still pretty dang terrific, lol.


Yes it is, I was just clarifying that it isn't 10%.


Although now that I think about it, I actually think it is the full 10%. Normally, 5% plus 5% does not equal the full 10%, but with the initial 5%, you aren't getting 5% off the total purchase at first (which would reduce the amount of cashback you would get on the second 5% cashback.)

 

 

For example, I use my Sallie Mae and get a Redbird card and fill it for $100. I get $5 back on my Sallie Mae card for my spending. Then, I turn around and use my Redbird card on a $100 TV. I then save $5 off that and it rings up $95. In total, I got the full $10 back. It's not a "5% off and then a 5% on what's left" situation.

Message 23 of 34
PNW_Hunter
Regular Contributor

Re: Help Me Optimize My Rewards

Any thoughts on the Amex Starwood/Mariott vs Penfed Travel Amex?

 

Penfed is 5 points/dollar on airfare and Starwood/Mariott have great rewards, I've heard as well.

 

Might look to add a travel card as well

Message 24 of 34
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Help Me Optimize My Rewards


@Anonymous wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

inb4 Sallie Mae

 

But no, really. Sallie Mae.


Why?


Amazon offers everything. Lol.

 

EDIT: Yes, Barclays does distinguish between those fulfilled by Amazon and those fulfilled by 3rd party vendors. Also, $6000 a year on groceries, while a decent amount, is still pretty easy to surpass when you consider it's only $500 a month on average. Sallie Mae would effectively give you a 50% boost on the amount of groceries you can get 5% on, plus Sallie Mae works at many Walmarts and Targets, while Amex BCP does not.


Amazon GC's solve this problem.


In most cases yes.  However Amazon GC cannot be used to by other gift cards (which is what I mainly use SM for!)

 

For Target spend, Redbird is the way to go, as you get the 5% + whatever reward your cc gives you.   (Sadly, BB doesn't do the same for Walmart)


But at Target, can't you use the Sallie Mae to refill the Redbird card and effectively get 5% back twice?


Possibly, but the double dip actually only equates to 9.75% off.


I'm aware, but that's still pretty dang terrific, lol.


Yes it is, I was just clarifying that it isn't 10%.


Although now that I think about it, I actually think it is the full 10%. Normally, 5% plus 5% does not equal the full 10%, but with the initial 5%, you aren't getting 5% off the total purchase at first (which would reduce the amount of cashback you would get on the second 5% cashback.)

 

 

For example, I use my Sallie Mae and get a Redbird card and fill it for $100. I get $5 back on my Sallie Mae card for my spending. Then, I turn around and use my Redbird card on a $100 TV. I then save $5 off that and it rings up $95. In total, I got the full $10 back. It's not a "5% off and then a 5% on what's left" situation.


Smiley Tongue I suppose.

Message 25 of 34
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Help Me Optimize My Rewards


@Anonymous wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

inb4 Sallie Mae

 

But no, really. Sallie Mae.


Why?


Amazon offers everything. Lol.

 

EDIT: Yes, Barclays does distinguish between those fulfilled by Amazon and those fulfilled by 3rd party vendors. Also, $6000 a year on groceries, while a decent amount, is still pretty easy to surpass when you consider it's only $500 a month on average. Sallie Mae would effectively give you a 50% boost on the amount of groceries you can get 5% on, plus Sallie Mae works at many Walmarts and Targets, while Amex BCP does not.


Amazon GC's solve this problem.


In most cases yes.  However Amazon GC cannot be used to by other gift cards (which is what I mainly use SM for!)

 

For Target spend, Redbird is the way to go, as you get the 5% + whatever reward your cc gives you.   (Sadly, BB doesn't do the same for Walmart)


But at Target, can't you use the Sallie Mae to refill the Redbird card and effectively get 5% back twice?


Possibly, but the double dip actually only equates to 9.75% off.


I'm aware, but that's still pretty dang terrific, lol.


Yes it is, I was just clarifying that it isn't 10%.


Although now that I think about it, I actually think it is the full 10%. Normally, 5% plus 5% does not equal the full 10%, but with the initial 5%, you aren't getting 5% off the total purchase at first (which would reduce the amount of cashback you would get on the second 5% cashback.)

 

 

For example, I use my Sallie Mae and get a Redbird card and fill it for $100. I get $5 back on my Sallie Mae card for my spending. Then, I turn around and use my Redbird card on a $100 TV. I then save $5 off that and it rings up $95. In total, I got the full $10 back. It's not a "5% off and then a 5% on what's left" situation.


Smiley Tongue I suppose.


How the technicality tables have turned. Smiley Tongue

 

 

To the OP, sorry to hijack your thread, lol. I don't know much about either of those cards, but I do think the Chase Marriott is a great hotel card worth looking into. You get a free annual night's stay, which more than pays for the annual fee.

Message 26 of 34
mongstradamus
Super Contributor

Re: Help Me Optimize My Rewards


@PNW_Hunter wrote:

Any thoughts on the Amex Starwood/Mariott vs Penfed Travel Amex?

 

Penfed is 5 points/dollar on airfare and Starwood/Mariott have great rewards, I've heard as well.

 

Might look to add a travel card as well


i would take SPG since they have better partners, which to me means better value. 



EX Fico 804 11/16/16 Fako 800 Credit.com 11/16/16
EQ SW bank enhanced 11/16/16 839 CK fako 822 11/16/16
TU Fico discover 10/19/16 814 Fako 819 Creditkarma 11/16/16
Message 27 of 34
PNW_Hunter
Regular Contributor

Re: Help Me Optimize My Rewards


@Anonymous wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

inb4 Sallie Mae

 

But no, really. Sallie Mae.


Why?


Amazon offers everything. Lol.

 

EDIT: Yes, Barclays does distinguish between those fulfilled by Amazon and those fulfilled by 3rd party vendors. Also, $6000 a year on groceries, while a decent amount, is still pretty easy to surpass when you consider it's only $500 a month on average. Sallie Mae would effectively give you a 50% boost on the amount of groceries you can get 5% on, plus Sallie Mae works at many Walmarts and Targets, while Amex BCP does not.


Amazon GC's solve this problem.


In most cases yes.  However Amazon GC cannot be used to by other gift cards (which is what I mainly use SM for!)

 

For Target spend, Redbird is the way to go, as you get the 5% + whatever reward your cc gives you.   (Sadly, BB doesn't do the same for Walmart)


But at Target, can't you use the Sallie Mae to refill the Redbird card and effectively get 5% back twice?


Possibly, but the double dip actually only equates to 9.75% off.


I'm aware, but that's still pretty dang terrific, lol.


Yes it is, I was just clarifying that it isn't 10%.


Although now that I think about it, I actually think it is the full 10%. Normally, 5% plus 5% does not equal the full 10%, but with the initial 5%, you aren't getting 5% off the total purchase at first (which would reduce the amount of cashback you would get on the second 5% cashback.)

 

 

For example, I use my Sallie Mae and get a Redbird card and fill it for $100. I get $5 back on my Sallie Mae card for my spending. Then, I turn around and use my Redbird card on a $100 TV. I then save $5 off that and it rings up $95. In total, I got the full $10 back. It's not a "5% off and then a 5% on what's left" situation.


Smiley Tongue I suppose.


How the technicality tables have turned. Smiley Tongue

 

 

To the OP, sorry to hijack your thread, lol. I don't know much about either of those cards, but I do think the Chase Marriott is a great hotel card worth looking into. You get a free annual night's stay, which more than pays for the annual fee.


haha no problem!

 

Thanks for all the info

Message 28 of 34
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Help Me Optimize My Rewards


@mongstradamus wrote:

@PNW_Hunter wrote:

Any thoughts on the Amex Starwood/Mariott vs Penfed Travel Amex?

 

Penfed is 5 points/dollar on airfare and Starwood/Mariott have great rewards, I've heard as well.

 

Might look to add a travel card as well


i would take SPG since they have better partners, which to me means better value. 


Agreed, unless you have major loyalty with Marriott.

Message 29 of 34
PNW_Hunter
Regular Contributor

Re: Help Me Optimize My Rewards

No loyalty with Mariott, but would simply want the best card for travel rewards, be it hotel or airline.
Message 30 of 34
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.