I cleared out my cookies, went to a different browser, clicked on all 21 cards, but it only says "compare cards". Nothing about offers. Thanks for the help! 
@sccredit wrote:CM matched me to First Premier. I don't put too much stock in it.
That made me laugh after looking at your TL's.
@Anonymous wrote:I cleared out my cookies, went to a different browser, clicked on all 21 cards, but it only says "compare cards". Nothing about offers. Thanks for the help!
Well dang. AE does funny things when they think they know who you are. In my case, the button for "Check for Pre-Qualified Offers" shows up when I use IE. I never login into my CC accounts using IE.
However, it doesn't show up when I use FF (I login to my AE account using FF). With FF, they label the card I have as mine and don't have as good of sign up offers, even when I am not logged in.
Perhaps you can try a different computer? I think you are just not seeing the pre-approval link because of a bug with American Express' website. You should see the button.
@sccredit wrote:CM matched me to First Premier. I don't put too much stock in it.
Thanks for posting that you had me laughing 
What you may try is logging on amex site via incognito mode. You should see the pre approval link. FWIW I don't get any pre approvals from amex.
I've applied for a card or two via cardmatch. Approved each time.
@CreditDunce wrote:
@Anonymous wrote:I cleared out my cookies, went to a different browser, clicked on all 21 cards, but it only says "compare cards". Nothing about offers. Thanks for the help!
Well dang. AE does funny things when they think they know who you are. In my case, the button for "Check for Pre-Qualified Offers" shows up when I use IE. I never login into my CC accounts using IE.
However, it doesn't show up when I use FF (I login to my AE account using FF). With FF, they label the card I have as mine and don't have as good of sign up offers, even when I am not logged in.
Perhaps you can try a different computer? I think you are just not seeing the pre-approval link because of a bug with American Express' website. You should see the button.
I tried igcognito, no go. So I went onto my computer on IE and you're right... It did say preselected offers! It said it couldn't find any offers for me, but all the sites say that for me for some reason. Barclays, nothing.... Approved. Same with Cap1. I feel like my opt in/out is not working, though I know I've opted in. My Fico as of a few days ago was 716.