cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Macy's Store Card to Amex upgrade soft pull

tag
uscgamecock
Valued Member

Macy's Store Card to Amex upgrade soft pull

Was just paying bills and checking my Macy's account. I got a pop-up on their site that I was eligible for an upgrade to a Macy's Amex card. It specifically said that my store card balance and benefits would transfer over to the new card and I would get a new card number. I said what the heck and clicked the link. Approved. Just pulled new reports through MyFico and no inquiry, so they just pulled a soft. I guess all this will effect is average age of accounts. I do not currently have any Amex network cards, so I'm happy about this.

 

Any downside to asking for a CLI right now? How much should I ask for? Limit is sitting at $6k with a small balance. Experian FICO score 678.

Message 1 of 13
12 REPLIES 12
CreditAggie
Community Leader
Super Contributor

Re: Macy's Store Card to Amex upgrade soft pull

Congratulations on your Macy's Amex product upgrade!

Current Cards (in order of approval):


         
Current FICO 8 | 9 (October 2025):  
Credit Age:  
Inquiries (6/12/24):  
Banks & CUs:

Message 2 of 13
KLEXH25
Valued Contributor

Re: Macy's Store Card to Amex upgrade soft pull

Congratulations on your upgrade!



Message 3 of 13
sauciefarr
New Contributor

Re: Macy's Store Card to Amex upgrade soft pull


@uscgamecock wrote:

Was just paying bills and checking my Macy's account. I got a pop-up on their site that I was eligible for an upgrade to a Macy's Amex card. It specifically said that my store card balance and benefits would transfer over to the new card and I would get a new card number. I said what the heck and clicked the link. Approved. Just pulled new reports through MyFico and no inquiry, so they just pulled a soft. I guess all this will effect is average age of accounts. I do not currently have any Amex network cards, so I'm happy about this.

 

Any downside to asking for a CLI right now? How much should I ask for? Limit is sitting at $6k with a small balance. Experian FICO score 678.


This will not affect your average age of accounts --- they will delete your current account and replace with the AMEX account with the same start date as your store account.  I just got the upgrade as well and it hit my credit report yesterday.  And congratulations!  I believe the general concensus is that you can request a CLI every 30 (or is it 31??) days with Macy's, but you may want to wait until you have your new account number just to avoid any confusion.

10.18.2025 FICO 8 EXP 813; EQ 807; TU 817. TU 830 AMEX Platinum NPSL; AMEX Gold NPSL; AMEX Cash Magnet 35,000; AMEX Delta Reserve 40,000; PenFed PCR Visa 12,500; PenFed Pathfinder 15,000; PenFed Gold Visa 10,000; PenFed LOC 10,000; Macys AMEX 25,000; Home Depot 25,000; NFCU Plat Visa 46,000; NFCU Plat MC 34,000; USAA Cash Rewards VISA 20,000; IKEA 35,000, Venmo VISA 20,000; SamsClub MC 20,000; Discover 34,600 (2 cards), Citibank Aadvantage Platinum Select World Elite MC 11,800; Pottery Barn 37,000; Williams-Sonoma 27,000; FNBO VISA Signature 18,000; Sportsmans Guide VISA 12,400; Sephora VISA Signature 20,000; Target MC 7000; AAA Signature Visa 26,000; Apple Card 13,500; Truist Visa 19,700; GM Card 14,000; Chase Sapphire Preferred 18,000; Chase Prime Visa 14,000. Utilization less than 1%
Message 4 of 13
uscgamecock
Valued Member

Re: Macy's Store Card to Amex upgrade soft pull


@sauciefarr wrote:

 

This will not affect your average age of accounts --- they will delete your current account and replace with the AMEX account with the same start date as your store account.  I just got the upgrade as well and it hit my credit report yesterday.  And congratulations!  I believe the general concensus is that you can request a CLI every 30 (or is it 31??) days with Macy's, but you may want to wait until you have your new account number just to avoid any confusion.

Good info. Thank you!

Message 5 of 13
babygirl1256
Senior Contributor

Re: Macy's Store Card to Amex upgrade soft pull

Congrats on your Macy's store card upgrade to AmEx . . . Welcome to "my" Macy's, I Heart that store!!!

Starting FICO 8 Score in 06/2019: EQ-625, TU-649, EX-640
Current FICO 8 Score in 06/2021: EQ-796, TU-806, EX-812
Goal FICO 8 Score in 06/2022: EQ-825, TU-850, EX-850
Message 6 of 13
KingRue8500
Senior Contributor

Re: Macy's Store Card to Amex upgrade soft pull

Congrats on your Macy's Store Card AMEX upgrade




Message 7 of 13
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Macy's Store Card to Amex upgrade soft pull

Congratulations on the upgrade! I'm envious and hoping I get the opportunity at some point as well. 

Message 8 of 13
gingerflower
Senior Contributor

Re: Macy's Store Card to Amex upgrade soft pull

Congratulations to your Macy's Amx upgrade! 👍

Message 9 of 13
in4maous
Established Member

Re: Macy's Store Card to Amex upgrade soft pull

Did you get any boost in points from the upgrade?

Message 10 of 13
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.