cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Need Advice

tag
luckydiva95
New Contributor

Need Advice

I think I should dump one of my cards, im not sure which of the two I should cancel. I have a Capital one Secured with a limit of $500 that I got in March 2014 or Credit One with a limit of $1700 that I got in 2008. I was approved for a Wells Fargo Cash Rewards to replace one of the cards. Credit One has crazy fees that are ridiculous. My secured  card is a great card & I do travel so it's useful because of no foreign transaction fees. The only thing to consider is that the Wells Fargo card only has a $1000.00 credit line. I'm think to considering of recon to get a higher credit limit. Any advice would be greatly appreciated.

Capital One QS $9,500| Credit one $3,350| Capital One Quick Silver One $500| Barclay View $6,250| Amazon Chase $4,200|Discover It $14,100| AMEX Everyday Preferred $20,000| Wells Fargo Active Cash $7,500| AMEX Blue Cash Preferred $28,000| Apple Card $4,750| Best Buy Visa $5,000| Citi Custom Cash $9,500| Chase Sapphire Preferred $9,500|Chase Unlimited Freedom $9,100|Amex Platinum| Venture X $10,000
Message 1 of 16
15 REPLIES 15
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Need Advice


@luckydiva95 wrote:

I think I should dump one of my cards, im not sure which of the two I should cancel. I have a Capital one Secured with a limit of $500 that I got in March 2014 or Credit One with a limit of $1700 that I got in 2008. I was approved for a Wells Fargo Cash Rewards to replace one of the cards. Credit One has crazy fees that are ridiculous. My secured  card is a great card & I do travel so it's useful because of no foreign transaction fees. The only thing to consider is that the Wells Fargo card only has a $1000.00 credit line. I'm think to considering of recon to get a higher credit limit. Any advice would be greatly appreciated.


Try to recon and see if Wells Frago will give you a higher limit.  Is it a bigger limit you want? What are your FICOs scores? Any baddies on your report? The reason I ask is you can get just 1 card with a big limit and then call it a day.

Message 2 of 16

Re: Need Advice

Personally, I would ditch the Credit One and never look back... Do you know what your credit score is? Could you apply for a Cap1 unsecured Platinum?
Message 3 of 16
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Need Advice

The problem with getting rid of the one card is you have 7 years history with them. How much are the fees? When do you hit the 7 year marks?

Message 4 of 16
Callandra
Valued Contributor

Re: Need Advice


@luckydiva95 wrote:

I think I should dump one of my cards, im not sure which of the two I should cancel. I have a Capital one Secured with a limit of $500 that I got in March 2014 or Credit One with a limit of $1700 that I got in 2008. I was approved for a Wells Fargo Cash Rewards to replace one of the cards. Credit One has crazy fees that are ridiculous. My secured  card is a great card & I do travel so it's useful because of no foreign transaction fees. The only thing to consider is that the Wells Fargo card only has a $1000.00 credit line. I'm think to considering of recon to get a higher credit limit. Any advice would be greatly appreciated.


Definitely get rid of Credit One. I know the card is old but is the cost of the fees worth the history? You have some other good cards and you can probably close it. It'll still report for 10 years and by the time it stops, everything else will be 10 years older anyway. You can probably get rid of the secured card too and get your money back. 

Quicksilver $10,000 | Better Balance Rewards $2000 | Sallie Mae $3500 | Freedom $3500

Last HP: 9/27/2015
Message 5 of 16
red259
Super Contributor

Re: Need Advice


@Anonymous wrote:

The problem with getting rid of the one card is you have 7 years history with them. How much are the fees? When do you hit the 7 year marks?


Even after they close the card out it will remain on the credit report for years, so paying fees to keep the card open for account history doesn't make much sense. To OP it looks like you have some normal credit cards now. I would close out secured cards (actually I would call and see if you can get it converted to unsecured) and wouldn't be paying fees just to keep a credit card account open (again call and see if there is a way to ditch the fees). . 

;
Starting Score: EQ: 714, TU 684
Current Score: EQ: 725 7/30/13, TU 684 6/2013, Exp 828 5/2018, Last App 8/5/17
Goal Score: 800 (Achieved!) In garden until Sepetember 2019
Message 6 of 16
red259
Super Contributor

Re: Need Advice


@Callandra wrote:

@luckydiva95 wrote:

I think I should dump one of my cards, im not sure which of the two I should cancel. I have a Capital one Secured with a limit of $500 that I got in March 2014 or Credit One with a limit of $1700 that I got in 2008. I was approved for a Wells Fargo Cash Rewards to replace one of the cards. Credit One has crazy fees that are ridiculous. My secured  card is a great card & I do travel so it's useful because of no foreign transaction fees. The only thing to consider is that the Wells Fargo card only has a $1000.00 credit line. I'm think to considering of recon to get a higher credit limit. Any advice would be greatly appreciated.


Definitely get rid of Credit One. I know the card is old but is the cost of the fees worth the history? You have some other good cards and you can probably close it. It'll still report for 10 years and by the time it stops, everything else will be 10 years older anyway. You can probably get rid of the secured card too and get your money back. 


I always confuse this. Do the cards continue to report for 10 years and its the baddies that disappear after 7 years? 

;
Starting Score: EQ: 714, TU 684
Current Score: EQ: 725 7/30/13, TU 684 6/2013, Exp 828 5/2018, Last App 8/5/17
Goal Score: 800 (Achieved!) In garden until Sepetember 2019
Message 7 of 16
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Need Advice


@red259 wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

The problem with getting rid of the one card is you have 7 years history with them. How much are the fees? When do you hit the 7 year marks?


Even after they close the card out it will remain on the credit report for years, so paying fees to keep the card open for account history doesn't make much sense. To OP it looks like you have some normal credit cards now. I would close out secured cards (actually I would call and see if you can get it converted to unsecured) and wouldn't be paying fees just to keep a credit card account open (again call and see if there is a way to ditch the fees). . 


This.

Message 8 of 16
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Need Advice


@red259 wrote:

@Callandra wrote:

@luckydiva95 wrote:

I think I should dump one of my cards, im not sure which of the two I should cancel. I have a Capital one Secured with a limit of $500 that I got in March 2014 or Credit One with a limit of $1700 that I got in 2008. I was approved for a Wells Fargo Cash Rewards to replace one of the cards. Credit One has crazy fees that are ridiculous. My secured  card is a great card & I do travel so it's useful because of no foreign transaction fees. The only thing to consider is that the Wells Fargo card only has a $1000.00 credit line. I'm think to considering of recon to get a higher credit limit. Any advice would be greatly appreciated.


Definitely get rid of Credit One. I know the card is old but is the cost of the fees worth the history? You have some other good cards and you can probably close it. It'll still report for 10 years and by the time it stops, everything else will be 10 years older anyway. You can probably get rid of the secured card too and get your money back. 


I always confuse this. Do the cards continue to report for 10 years and its the baddies that disappear after 7 years? 


Correct.

Message 9 of 16
Callandra
Valued Contributor

Re: Need Advice


@red259 wrote:

@Callandra wrote:

@luckydiva95 wrote:

I think I should dump one of my cards, im not sure which of the two I should cancel. I have a Capital one Secured with a limit of $500 that I got in March 2014 or Credit One with a limit of $1700 that I got in 2008. I was approved for a Wells Fargo Cash Rewards to replace one of the cards. Credit One has crazy fees that are ridiculous. My secured  card is a great card & I do travel so it's useful because of no foreign transaction fees. The only thing to consider is that the Wells Fargo card only has a $1000.00 credit line. I'm think to considering of recon to get a higher credit limit. Any advice would be greatly appreciated.


Definitely get rid of Credit One. I know the card is old but is the cost of the fees worth the history? You have some other good cards and you can probably close it. It'll still report for 10 years and by the time it stops, everything else will be 10 years older anyway. You can probably get rid of the secured card too and get your money back. 


I always confuse this. Do the cards continue to report for 10 years and its the baddies that disappear after 7 years? 


Yup! Cards will reports for up to 10 years and baddies (although there are exceptions, ie- BK7) are usually for no more than 7 years plus 180 days.

Quicksilver $10,000 | Better Balance Rewards $2000 | Sallie Mae $3500 | Freedom $3500

Last HP: 9/27/2015
Message 10 of 16
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.