cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Pushing Payments to CCs vs Pulling

tag
barbaralee
Established Contributor

Re: Pushing Payments to CCs vs Pulling


@Gmood1 wrote:
I keep it simple. I just let the CC company pull the payment. Here lately Capital One and Barclay's have gotten a little greedy. Pulling more than the statement balance. So I had to go in and cancel auto pay for both companies. Apparently Cap one changed their policy. Now if you have a balance, regardless if the current statement is paid. They'll pull the remaining balance or minimum depending on what auto pay is set to.

I had mine set to pay full current statement balance. These jokers debited the entire amount. Lol

Good thing I keep that debited account funded. It could have been ugly.

I have all of our credit card accounts set up to pull the statement balance including Capital One, and I have to say I have never seen this happen to me. For example, I had a pull this morning. My previous balance with Capital One was $1299.51. They pulled the statement balance of $805.09, leaving a remainder balance of $494.42. 

 

Maybe I am misunderstanding. Does this happen when you pay in advance and you still have autopay? I am confused with this experience. 

Message 51 of 67
UncleB
Credit Mentor

Re: Pushing Payments to CCs vs Pulling


@Anonymous wrote:

One point about pushing payments...

 

There are some banks, like wells fargo, that if you push a "large" payment from a non-WF account, they *may* hold it for 14 days.

 

The point is: Be very aware of your receiving banks funds availability policy.

 


That's an interesting data point... even back in my 'early' rebuilding days, I never had a lender place a hold on a payment that was sent via ACH 'push'; actually the only time I ever had a problem was on ACH 'pull' transactions, and even then it was arbitrary, and mostly based on the payment amount.

 

I would suggest that if Wells is in the practice of doing this, they are in the minority (thankfully).

 

It's good advice you mention to 'be aware of your bank's funds availability policy'... this is very true, especially if you're having to work within a small credit line. 

 

I'll just add for clarification that 'funds availability' as mentioned here is a different creature altogether from 'funds availability' for deposit accounts.  Smiley Wink

Message 52 of 67
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Pushing Payments to CCs vs Pulling


@UncleB wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

One point about pushing payments...

 

There are some banks, like wells fargo, that if you push a "large" payment from a non-WF account, they *may* hold it for 14 days.

 

The point is: Be very aware of your receiving banks funds availability policy.

 


That's an interesting data point... even back in my 'early' rebuilding days, I never had a lender place a hold on a payment that was sent via ACH 'push'; actually the only time I ever had a problem was on ACH 'pull' transactions, and even then it was arbitrary, and mostly based on the payment amount.

 

I would suggest that if Wells is in the practice of doing this, they are in the minority (thankfully).

 

It's good advice you mention to 'be aware of your bank's funds availability policy'... this is very true, especially if you're having to work within a small credit line. 

 

I'll just add for clarification that 'funds availability' as mentioned here is a different creature altogether from 'funds availability' for deposit accounts.  Smiley Wink


 

My fiance and I had a communication break down (Can you imagine?) and her november credit card auto debit failed because her Wells Fargo checking had nothing in it. We saw it the next week and quickly made a $25 electronic payment to fix it, which went right through. After my next paycheck I made a $400 electronic payment from my bank to pay off the balance. They got the payment, but did not adjust the credit limit.They made reference that the "High Dollar" desk wanted a statement from my banke showing the funds cleared my account. If I did not supply that, it was going to be held for 14 days.

 

 

I wont go into to gory details of the ensuing calls to customer service etc...

Message 53 of 67
barbaralee
Established Contributor

Re: Pushing Payments to CCs vs Pulling

I have never had that happen as well. I have heard of the credit card company holding the payment for 14 days, due to whatever reason. Cap1, USAA, Chase, etc have all done it, but the funds are usually withdrawn pretty quickly. 

 

I have also had issues of a pushed payment getting to a smaller business on time. It is usually when they have to actually cut a check as opposed to sending the funds electronically. 

 

In general, though, when I have pushed payments (and I have had accounts with B of A, USAA, and PNC)  it has been pretty seamless. Although those 3 banks use the same web bill pay processor. 

Message 54 of 67
barbaralee
Established Contributor

Re: Pushing Payments to CCs vs Pulling


@Anonymous wrote:

@UncleB wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

One point about pushing payments...

 

There are some banks, like wells fargo, that if you push a "large" payment from a non-WF account, they *may* hold it for 14 days.

 

The point is: Be very aware of your receiving banks funds availability policy.

 


That's an interesting data point... even back in my 'early' rebuilding days, I never had a lender place a hold on a payment that was sent via ACH 'push'; actually the only time I ever had a problem was on ACH 'pull' transactions, and even then it was arbitrary, and mostly based on the payment amount.

 

I would suggest that if Wells is in the practice of doing this, they are in the minority (thankfully).

 

It's good advice you mention to 'be aware of your bank's funds availability policy'... this is very true, especially if you're having to work within a small credit line. 

 

I'll just add for clarification that 'funds availability' as mentioned here is a different creature altogether from 'funds availability' for deposit accounts.  Smiley Wink


 

My fiance and I had a communication break down (Can you imagine?) and her november credit card auto debit failed because her Wells Fargo checking had nothing in it. We saw it the next week and quickly made a $25 electronic payment to fix it, which went right through. After my next paycheck I made a $400 electronic payment from my bank to pay off the balance. They got the payment, but did not adjust the credit limit.They made reference that the "High Dollar" desk wanted a statement from my banke showing the funds cleared my account. If I did not supply that, it was going to be held for 14 days.

 

 

I wont go into to gory details of the ensuing calls to customer service etc...


I see... yeah, that is a payment float. The credit card company is the one who held your payment, not WF. They did it because the previous payment to that account bounced. 

Message 55 of 67
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Pushing Payments to CCs vs Pulling


..

I see... yeah, that is a payment float. The credit card company is the one who held your payment, not WF. They did it because the previous payment to that account bounced. 


Actually WF is the credit card company...

Message 56 of 67
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Pushing Payments to CCs vs Pulling


@barbaralee wrote:

I have never had that happen as well. I have heard of the credit card company holding the payment for 14 days, due to whatever reason. Cap1, USAA, Chase, etc have all done it, but the funds are usually withdrawn pretty quickly. 

 


Yep - they were quick to cash the payment - just not so eager apply it to the credit limit.

Message 57 of 67
Kevin86475391
Frequent Contributor

Re: Pushing Payments to CCs vs Pulling

I primarily pull but occasionally push.

 

I like to handle my bills on a weekly rather than monthly basis. I'm not concerned with utilization, I just feel more on top of my finances by looking at everything and making payments weekly. Naturally since the whole point is to closely monitor my fiances I prefer to login to each account individually, so that makes pulling easier. I PIF, but it's obviously more of a PIF weekly than PIF monthly, so this makes the minimum payment (always pay way more than this within the first week), statment balance (pay and charge this many times over), and due date (pay about 4 or 5 times a statement) all essentially irrelvant.

 

I find that pulling payments is pretty much always faster across the board on all accounts than pushing payments. Times vary from lender to lender of course, but I never find pushing payments to be the faster option on any accounts.

 

I pull and push from different accounts though. I pull from my Chase checking account and all the CCCs have that info. However, I push from my Discover account on the few occasions when I do it because I get the $0.10 bonus per transaction.

 

As others have said one benefit of pushing payments is that you can pay pending charges as well, so occasionally I do it for that.

Message 58 of 67
UncleB
Credit Mentor

Re: Pushing Payments to CCs vs Pulling


@Anonymous wrote:

@UncleB wrote:

@Anonymous wrote:

One point about pushing payments...

 

There are some banks, like wells fargo, that if you push a "large" payment from a non-WF account, they *may* hold it for 14 days.

 

The point is: Be very aware of your receiving banks funds availability policy.

 


That's an interesting data point... even back in my 'early' rebuilding days, I never had a lender place a hold on a payment that was sent via ACH 'push'; actually the only time I ever had a problem was on ACH 'pull' transactions, and even then it was arbitrary, and mostly based on the payment amount.

 

I would suggest that if Wells is in the practice of doing this, they are in the minority (thankfully).

 

It's good advice you mention to 'be aware of your bank's funds availability policy'... this is very true, especially if you're having to work within a small credit line. 

 

I'll just add for clarification that 'funds availability' as mentioned here is a different creature altogether from 'funds availability' for deposit accounts.  Smiley Wink


 

My fiance and I had a communication break down (Can you imagine?) and her november credit card auto debit failed because her Wells Fargo checking had nothing in it. We saw it the next week and quickly made a $25 electronic payment to fix it, which went right through. After my next paycheck I made a $400 electronic payment from my bank to pay off the balance. They got the payment, but did not adjust the credit limit.They made reference that the "High Dollar" desk wanted a statement from my banke showing the funds cleared my account. If I did not supply that, it was going to be held for 14 days.

 

 

I wont go into to gory details of the ensuing calls to customer service etc...


Mystery solved, my friend!

 

Some banks are more sensitive than others regarding failed payments... there are threads on here about Synchrony completely closing accounts because of one failed payment (and it was a first occurrence!).  The cases I read about involved new(er) accounts, so perhaps Synchrony would be more forgiving for someone with a longer account history, but they don't play - at all.

 

All we can do is speculate, but I suspect if it wasn't for that failed auto debit, your fiance would have no issues with her available credit being updated promptly.  My primary bank, USAA, is known to behave the same way under the same circumstances.  Actually, on USAA's own website, that's a complaint many folks have... once there's an issue with a payment failing, they start holding funds (I've read very colorful posts over there regarding this).  On the other hand, I've never had a problem (knock on wood...) and so far, they credit my payments and update available credit instantly, just like Amex. 

 

I suspect with a little more time, your own situation with Wells holding payments will change for the better.  On the plus side, at least they do give you the opportunity to prove the funds have cleared... they would be within their rights to simply make you wait it out even with proof (like HSBC used to do me years ago). 

Message 59 of 67
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: Pushing Payments to CCs vs Pulling


@barbaralee wrote:

@Gmood1 wrote:
I keep it simple. I just let the CC company pull the payment. Here lately Capital One and Barclay's have gotten a little greedy. Pulling more than the statement balance. So I had to go in and cancel auto pay for both companies. Apparently Cap one changed their policy. Now if you have a balance, regardless if the current statement is paid. They'll pull the remaining balance or minimum depending on what auto pay is set to.

I had mine set to pay full current statement balance. These jokers debited the entire amount. Lol

Good thing I keep that debited account funded. It could have been ugly.

I have all of our credit card accounts set up to pull the statement balance including Capital One, and I have to say I have never seen this happen to me. For example, I had a pull this morning. My previous balance with Capital One was $1299.51. They pulled the statement balance of $805.09, leaving a remainder balance of $494.42. 

 

Maybe I am misunderstanding. Does this happen when you pay in advance and you still have autopay? I am confused with this experience. 


Sorry  - I dont think you got this answered?

Message 60 of 67
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.