No credit card required
Browse credit cards from a variety of issuers to see if there's a better card for you.
@Spotsy wrote:
Funny story....
I recently went through this tax return junk with buying a newish car, put 40% down, and didn't want to pay in full because money was still cheap and the market was doing too good use those funds for buying a depreciating asset. Even though I have bought and sold over 10 cars in the last 10 years, this CU wanted a full tax return, all pages, I only gave them the signed front page, nope, they wanted it all, I said no...will give more but I will redact info that I felt was confidential, they said no, I said bye. Went to another local CU, got a better rate, NO tax returns, and was out the door. And of course I did need to call the first CU and rub it in their face. The first CU had a particular UW that was not trained in how to manage clients with different levels of net worth ....so they lost the business.
my 5 cents...
That's funny! My uncle works as an underwriter at a credit union and last week he was telling me this story about some customer who kept refusing to accept that institution's rules (which he had no way of controlling) and when the guy went elsewhere, he took the time to call back and gloat. And my uncle was called in by his boss to explain. Fortunately they both agreed that "An over-entitled ......"***Mod Cut*** please keep it G-rated was a suitable write up for the report.
My $20
Everyone makes mistakes...don't be too hard on yourself. At least you get to work for your Uncle....I am sure that is fun.
This thread is starting to look like a movie about failed exorcism
@Remedios wrote:This thread is starting to look like a movie about failed exorcism
Yes, my uncle is a defrocked priest (thus the move to underwriting) so that's probably inevitable.
@Anonymous wrote:
@Remedios wrote:This thread is starting to look like a movie about failed exorcism
Yes, my uncle is a defrocked priest (thus the move to underwriting) so that's probably inevitable.
Not sure about the exorcism part...but definitely A+ for 'stray tangent' category.
but to bring it back in alignment...yes Discover ask for them probably more then others, and yes they can ask for them, and either we comply or expect the CC to get axed....it is what it is. Can send you a few of my 'tshirts' from my past adventures if you want....
@7774x wrote:
@Remedios wrote:
@KangiCosmos wrote:
@CreditCuriosity wrote:
@OmarGB9 wrote:
@marmaladepie wrote:I know right? I would have liked that request to pop up during the application process.
I'm going to just let it ride and see what happens. If they close the account, that's fine.
What do you mean "just let it ride"? If you don't provide the info they're requesting, they will indeed close the account. That's well documented on here.
Agreed. I would be proactive and ask if Bank Statements/Pay stubs will work vs tax otherwise just call them and tell them you will not provide any above mentioned and just have them close the account and get the pain over with if not willing to provide any of the above. You might get lucky and they will take pay stubs otherwise it will be closed as pay stubs is your best outcome to their request and obviously worse case is pure closure as mentioned
I just spoke to them because I got the same thing. They will NOT take bank statements or anything else. I tried. Sending the consent through Equifax is baffling to me since there is still people like me who are waiting for the class action settlement from Equifax with breach of information. The consent is for 2020 and 2021 taxes. I hnestly don't understand people that are ok with Discover having access to your taxes or anyonelese names and social security numbers on those taxes who are not even apart of the account.
People talk about risk managemnt blah blahblha but if you have paid your card in full for several years straight obviously you are not a risk. 4 months ago I already had fraud on my credit account with someone opening a Paypal credit card. If I had dependent children on my taxes I sure wouldn't want some credit card company having there SSN in case of Dark Web breaches. Like I said. Equifax has already been breached what makes me think it can't happen again?
It's not that "people are okay with Discover" it's about the fact Discover has a right to do so, consumer has a right to decline.
EQ had a big breach, but so did other two CRAs, not to mention retailers who are probably responsible for 95% of info floating on dark web but I don't see anyone going "Boycott Target!!!!"
People complain about the fact it happens but it's spelled out in cardmember agreement, and before one hits final "Apply" button, they have to click on the box acknowledging info available to them PRIOR to completing the application.
I don't think Discover should be faulted for doing what they clearly spelled they may do.
Maybe if people start reading, things would work out a lot better for them ...
If people start reading this .. less people will signup for their card ..Info Discover needs for credit worthines can be found is on a Credit report.. amount of payments , income, late payments , total debt... mortgage/rent Name .
Well ,, this week.. Discover raised their loss reserves on credit cards , loans during the quarter ,from $200 Million to $883 Million ... Guess Demanding IRS returns not much help to stem losses?
@7774x wrote:Well ,, this week.. Discover raised their loss reserves on credit cards , loans during the quarter ,from $200 Million to $883 Million ... Guess Demanding IRS returns not much help to stem losses?
And Chase added $1.4B to their loss reserve, as compared to releasing $1.8B last year, so I guess Chase should demand IRS returns to stem losses?
i.e. single out of context data points aren't that meaningful.
@Anonymous wrote:
@7774x wrote:Well ,, this week.. Discover raised their loss reserves on credit cards , loans during the quarter ,from $200 Million to $883 Million ... Guess Demanding IRS returns not much help to stem losses?
And Chase added $1.4B to their loss reserve, as compared to releasing $1.8B last year, so I guess Chase should demand IRS returns to stem losses?
i.e. single out of context data points aren't that meaningful.
Chase much bigger then Discover..even when I burned Chase CC... they continued to keep their 2 other card accounts open...1 with a promo rate ... no IRS approved tax aproved forms were asked by chase..