cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

What Credit Cards have you closed and Why?

tag
GmbH
Contributor

Re: What Credit Cards have you closed and Why?

2007 - Old Navy - $127 limit was useless (my first credit card btw.)

2007 - American Express Platinum - back then it was much more difficult to get approved for Amex revolvers with a thin file so I applied for highest fee charge card (and got approved) with the plan of applying for a revolving Amex at latter date and then backdating it.

Message 61 of 148
EdMan63
Established Contributor

Re: What Credit Cards have you closed and Why?

I haven't closed very many cards. I did close two last year:

 

Home Depot- Reason being that I only got it when we moved into a new house 3 years ago and wanted to build a fence. Well it turned out we couldn't do what we wanted per the city so we decided against a fence. I really had no use for it other than a couple of items here and there and they offered no real rewards with the card. Only interest free financing on purchases over $200. No thank you. 

 

Cap One QS- Thought long and hard about this one. I got a Citi DC last year plus I have a FU. I felt it was redundant and I wanted to cut my cards down some. It was one of my younger cards so it didn't really effect my AAoA that much. I had reached my max with them CL wise so bye bye. Sometimes I miss it. It wasn't a bad card at all. 


Message 62 of 148
icednightpaper
Regular Contributor

Re: What Credit Cards have you closed and Why?

I’ve only closed a credit union student card because it wouldn’t grow past $1k. 3 months later they came out with new products and got approved for a regular card at $10k, go figure.

I’m about to close my Elan card, as the bank I originally got it from was absorbed and the resulting bank cut ties. It was my 2nd ever card and I did get one auto-CLI, it’s ultimately a redundant part of my lineup and they denied a requested CLI.
Message 63 of 148
VPExecutive
Frequent Contributor

Re: What Credit Cards have you closed and Why?

I closed my Paypal MasterCard because it had a paltry $300 limit and a 29% APR (not that I carried balances on it). 

 

I had much better cards in my wallet. 


Message 64 of 148
Josh2942
Established Contributor

Re: What Credit Cards have you closed and Why?

I have closed the Amex Green, Gold, and Platinum because I got them in college and didn't spend enough to justify them. I closed the Barclay aviator cars because I had the Citi AAdvanatge card. Just wanted to swoop in on 50,000 points after first purchase and waived annual fee. I closed My Barclay World MasterCard because they sliced my limit a couple years ago. 

Jaguar F-Type R Loan 50K Balance
Goldman Sachs Signature Loan $29,000 TU 750 score pulled at time of loan.
Student Loan Debt $1,500
Credit Card Debt $300 1>% of $166,700
FAKO Transunion 723 Equifax 744
What's in my wallet? Chase Sapphire Reserve, Chase Freedom Unlimited, and AMEX Blue for Business
Message 65 of 148
M_Smart007
Legendary Contributor

Re: What Credit Cards have you closed and Why?

 

Thank you all that participated. I am just looking for some reasons to close more cards this year.

 

I was hoping that @UncleB or @K-in-Boston would chime inSmiley Happy

 

If you have any questions for those that posted, or any other Credit Card closing related Questions, Please ask!

I am sure some of the great myFICO posters would be more than Happy to answer.

 

Again, Thanks for Everyone's inputSmiley Happy

 

A Special shout out to @pinkandgrey for keeping it "simple"Smiley Happy

Also to @Gmood1 For all those SUB'sSmiley Very Happy

Can't forget @AverageJoesCredit For just being an all around great DudeSmiley Wink

 

Message 66 of 148
AverageJoesCredit
Legendary Contributor

Re: What Credit Cards have you closed and Why?

Most interesting  fact about my closed cards ....

 

 

Chase Amazon Prime still reporting as open on Eq😳🤯🥴😏💳😎🙋‍♂️

Message 67 of 148
UpperNwGuy
Valued Contributor

Re: What Credit Cards have you closed and Why?

In 2017 I purged a number of cards I wasn’t using:

1.  Amex Green Card

2.  Amex Blue Cash Everyday

3.  Citi Simplicity

4.  PenFed Platinum Rewards

5.  Exxon (my oldest card, received in 1974)

6.  Macy’s

7.  Bloomingdale’s

8.  Lord and Taylor

9.  Nieman Marcus

 

Why keep them if you don’t use them?

 

After the purge, I had six cards.  I added one a few months later.  I’ve had the same seven cards for the last two and a half years.  I may purge two of them this year.

Daily Carry: PenFed Power Cash • NFCU Flagship • NFCU More Rewards • Chase Freedom
Sock Drawer: PenFed Promise • NFCU cashRewards • Chase Sapphire Preferred • Chase Freedom Unlimited • United Explorer • UNFCU Azure
Message 68 of 148
MAZDA3
Frequent Contributor

Re: What Credit Cards have you closed and Why?

Just closed via secure message my NFCU Flagship which was coming up for renewal in two days. Also closed my Choice Priveleges Barclays. Didn't feel like paying AF on NFCU card and Barclays was just taking up space.

And I just discovered I can't access Credit Karma from Thailand. Still getting the alerts but can't log in. Guess I'll have to wait until I'm back in the states on Saturday. 

Message 69 of 148
Namaste7
Established Contributor

Re: What Credit Cards have you closed and Why?

Accounts closed in the last 3 years

  1. Sub complete / consolidate CL: Amex co-branded, CU Visa, BofA
  2. Reduce exposure: Capital One, Barclay and Comenity (SCT cards)

All accounts were closed on good terms and I do not have any regrets 👍.

~~MMXX~~
2025 Goal$
2024 Goal$
2023 Goal$
FICOs 780+
Message 70 of 148
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.