cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

What card to get next?

tag
Anonymous
Not applicable

What card to get next?

I am in the final stages of a credit rebuild. Six months ago all 3 scores (FICO 8) were in the high 500's. Now all my baddies are gone and all 3 are in the mid 700's. I have two credit cards - both about 6 months old. $500 Limit on each, both are secured, I will be closing on a mortgage in 60 days or less. No other debt, no balance on either card. I charge about $20 on each card every other month ( a tank of gas) if I remember to.

 

What should be my next credit card? I would suspect it should be unsecured.

9 REPLIES 9
austinguy907
Valued Contributor

Re: What card to get next?

First and foremost don't apply for anything until you have keys in hand.

 

Secondly just cruise the pre-qual sites and see what pops.

 

If you have something specific in mind then apply for that first regardless of prescreen results.

Message 2 of 10
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: What card to get next?

Thanks. I kinda knew that. No way is anything changing in my credit file until I have the keys in my hand.

 

I guess I should have worded my question differently. Who should I avoid (ther than the obvious Fee Harvester cards)? In my bad credit days I had a lot of charge offs. I know Amex has a memory like an elephant, but I have no history of any kind with them (I had a card for 3-4 months before they closed it for no reason). I do have bad histories with Chase, Wells Fargo and Discover. Any word on how long a memory they have?

Message 3 of 10
TiggerDat
Valued Contributor

Re: What card to get next?

I think you should get two cards.  The Red Aviator card from Barclays and the American Airlines card from Citi.  Take the bonus spend miles and enjoy a free flight somewhere nice for you and your spouse.  I mean you could get a United card and hope that the engine catches on fire, you get kicked off for your attire, or simply dragged off.  I have heard those things can net you either money or miles...

It is by will alone I set my mind in motion.....
Always follow these rules: Only take a HP for a new account. Always use the best rewards card for that reward category. Don't close a card unless you know you really should. Never use more than 35% of a credit limit. Recon as much and as best you can. Use the introductory period to the best advantage. Get the signup bonus. Whenever possible PIF or balance transfer so you pay less in interest. Never give an excellent rating when it is actually the norm. Always look for a discount as more is always better.
Always accept candy from strangers because they have the best candy or from people you know have good candy.
Message 4 of 10
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: What card to get next?


@Anonymous wrote:

Thanks. I kinda knew that. No way is anything changing in my credit file until I have the keys in my hand.

 

I guess I should have worded my question differently. Who should I avoid (ther than the obvious Fee Harvester cards)? In my bad credit days I had a lot of charge offs. I know Amex has a memory like an elephant, but I have no history of any kind with them (I had a card for 3-4 months before they closed it for no reason). I do have bad histories with Chase, Wells Fargo and Discover. Any word on how long a memory they have?


For many banks, it depends if the bad history includes unpaid chargeoffs.   Some banks won't forgive (or at least for a long long time) unless you pay the chargeoffs   (which may not be worth it if the amount is a lot and there is nothing too special about the issuer).

 

So Amex never told you why they closed the card?  

 

In your position, I would "play safe" by applying for one of the other banks (or CUs) e.g. Citi.   Once you have a recent decent unsecured history with them, then you can see how forgiven you are with the others.

Message 5 of 10
austinguy907
Valued Contributor

Re: What card to get next?


@Anonymous wrote:

Thanks. I kinda knew that. No way is anything changing in my credit file until I have the keys in my hand.

 

I guess I should have worded my question differently. Who should I avoid (ther than the obvious Fee Harvester cards)? In my bad credit days I had a lot of charge offs. I know Amex has a memory like an elephant, but I have no history of any kind with them (I had a card for 3-4 months before they closed it for no reason). I do have bad histories with Chase, Wells Fargo and Discover. Any word on how long a memory they have?


6/1/17 EFX 762; TU 794; EXP715

 

Your EX score is going to be the biggest crap shoot on an approval because any lender could end up pulling that one instead of the other 2 that are significantly higher.

Chase for me pulled EQ/EX for the FU/Amazon cards

WF - don't deal with them

Disco pulled EX, they also have been known to pull TU/EQ - not sure how long you might be denied entry though... maybe a phone call to find out if you're blocked from an approval?

Amex pulls EX 99.999% of the time

 

Citi will low ball your SL even with higher scores

BOA might be a good shot though since they pulled EX but, they're all over the place with who they pull.  The Cash/Travel/WWF cards have a $150/$500 bonus right now

 

That covers the big banks for the most part.  There's plenty of options with CU's though.

 

NFCU - tends to hand out 24K CC's all the time 

PF - tends to be lenient as well

Consumers - they offer some decent products 

Tons of others..... dig around on here and check out www.depositaccounts.com and maybe find a high APY checking account that meshes well with a CC offer.  I found my CU on there for 2.5% APY up to 50K balances which is nice considering most top out on the balance chart between 5K-20K and then drop the APY to 0.05%.

 

Of course it's more than just scores that get you an approval though. Do your homework while you're waiting and you should be able to come up with some options for 2-3 cards that work well for the long term.

Message 6 of 10
wilmer007
Contributor

Re: What card to get next?

your first priority is getting an unsecured card. your next priority after that is trying for good rewards cards and/or soft pull CLIs. Capital One fits this need perfectly since they give Soft Pull CLIs and their credit cards are pretty good too (though not as good as Chase or AMEX).

 

Bank of America is another recommendation if Chase denies you as they have one of the best travel credit cards after Chase and AMEX. cards like the BBR (no longer offered) Cash Rewards and Travel Rewards (the one in my sig) are loved by many since their cards offer $0 AF and Cashback with no frills. the travel reward card you can PC to it from one of the starter cards if you wanna start small with them and has no FTF and no AF which makes it one of the top travel cards and without question the best NO AF/FTF Travel card. if you don't plan to travel perhaps look at credit cards that offer other rewards such as flat percentage cash back with good CLIs.

 

 


*****|$15,200|********|$13,500|***********|$5,000|*********|$25,000|***********|$500|
Highest Scores: Transunion 08: 821 | Equifax VantageScore 3.0: 780 | Experian 08: 804 | gardening until May 2018 or longer.
Message 7 of 10
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: What card to get next?


@wilmer007 wrote:

your first priority is getting an unsecured card. your next priority after that is trying for good rewards cards and/or soft pull CLIs. Capital One fits this need perfectly since they give Soft Pull CLIs and their credit cards are pretty good too (though not as good as Chase or AMEX).

 

Bank of America is another recommendation if Chase denies you as they have one of the best travel credit cards after Chase and AMEX. cards like the BBR (no longer offered) Cash Rewards and Travel Rewards (the one in my sig) are loved by many since their cards offer $0 AF and Cashback with no frills. the travel reward card you can PC to it from one of the starter cards if you wanna start small with them and has no FTF and no AF which makes it one of the top travel cards and without question the best NO AF/FTF Travel card. if you don't plan to travel perhaps look at credit cards that offer other rewards such as flat percentage cash back with good CLIs.

 

 


Thanks for the suggestions but all I want the cards for is the FICO score increases that will lower my auto and homeowners insurance. The credir cards themselves will spens a LOT more time in my sock drawer than they will in my wallet - figure 1-2 uses a year each.

Message 8 of 10
wilmer007
Contributor

Re: What card to get next?


@Anonymous wrote:

@wilmer007 wrote:

your first priority is getting an unsecured card. your next priority after that is trying for good rewards cards and/or soft pull CLIs. Capital One fits this need perfectly since they give Soft Pull CLIs and their credit cards are pretty good too (though not as good as Chase or AMEX).

 

Bank of America is another recommendation if Chase denies you as they have one of the best travel credit cards after Chase and AMEX. cards like the BBR (no longer offered) Cash Rewards and Travel Rewards (the one in my sig) are loved by many since their cards offer $0 AF and Cashback with no frills. the travel reward card you can PC to it from one of the starter cards if you wanna start small with them and has no FTF and no AF which makes it one of the top travel cards and without question the best NO AF/FTF Travel card. if you don't plan to travel perhaps look at credit cards that offer other rewards such as flat percentage cash back with good CLIs.

 

 


Thanks for the suggestions but all I want the cards for is the FICO score increases that will lower my auto and homeowners insurance. The credir cards themselves will spens a LOT more time in my sock drawer than they will in my wallet - figure 1-2 uses a year each.


in that case you need the easiest plain no frills unsecured card to get approved for that has $0 AF. such as the Capital One Platinum.

 

some cards also offer secondary benefits to you such as free FICO scores every month and/or Soft Pull CLIs. again capital one platinum will give you soft pull CLIs while other no frill cards like BofA BankAmericard or Barclaycard Ring Platinum give you free access to your Transunion FICO score every month for free (the Ring Platinum also comes with no FTF). Citi Simplicity card comes with the Equifax FICO score. And finally Chase Slate gives you Experian FICO score.

 

 

but honestly with scores in the 700s you shouldn't sell yourself short as you are basically giving all your spending away and getting absolutely nothing in return. you could be traveling or getting cash back and using all the cash back to pay for your new mortgage. all you have to do is pay everything with a reward card and then PIF every month. i mean unless you live in a cave somewhere you have expenses like everyone else. the only time a card deserves to be SD is if you can't manage your money/credit properly in which case you need help or you have better cards in your wallet and not enough space in your wallet for the inferior cards.


*****|$15,200|********|$13,500|***********|$5,000|*********|$25,000|***********|$500|
Highest Scores: Transunion 08: 821 | Equifax VantageScore 3.0: 780 | Experian 08: 804 | gardening until May 2018 or longer.
Message 9 of 10
Anonymous
Not applicable

Re: What card to get next?

If youre asking for suggestions for a next card. I agree with the other previous posters. You may want to look into a BofA card, you said you just want another card for fico increases purposes and will barely spend and you only use your other cards for gas once in a while. Well the BofA Cash rewards is $0 annual fee (so go ahead and SD it any time), it also provides you 3% gas since you said thats the only thing youre putting on your card here and there. It also provides you a free Fico score on your account. Last but not least if one of the few cards out there with a sign bonus of $150-200 bucks with such a low spend requirement of $500 in 90 days, compared to a bunch of other cards that reqire you to do $1000-$4000 dollars. 

 

 

Message 10 of 10
Advertiser Disclosure: The offers that appear on this site are from third party advertisers from whom FICO receives compensation.